Te solution

by Hamish Keith / 22 March, 2008

Te Papa's 10th anniversary passed in a froth of self-congratulation. There were hints the national museum might not quite have been up to it, but generally all was fine and dandy with its first decade.

There was a smidgeon of criticism. Rob Cherry on Radio New Zealand National's Nine to Noon described it as a mall, which was as close to the reality as anyone ventured. In the lead-in to her coverage on Afternoons, Lucy Orbell opened by noting that Te Papa had been described as a "theme park" and the "cultural equivalent to a fast-food outlet" - both my descriptions - but no more was heard about the institution's continuing failures. There was an implication that any criticism came from only a tiny group of the disaffected cultural classes, who preferred museums for the elite.

In short, the coverage of Te Papa's opening decade was as shallow as the museum itself. That was a pity. The problems and shortcomings that have plagued the national museum since its opening are still there and will not be resolved by pretending they are not. The most obvious is the building itself. It would be easy to blame the architects, but the fault lay in the brief and in the process that arrived at that particular design. The interim board of the museum did not select that design. Some strange sub-committee did.

There was an architectural competition intended to select an architect but not to select a building. The sub-committee lost the plot and went ahead and selected a building anyway. From that point on, it was clear there would be a battle between the building and the museum, and the building won.

In a reverse of what should happen, the museum's functions were shaped by the building. Hence the mall experience - and, worse, the nature of the building bears little resemblance to the nature of the collections. The national art collections suffered the most and still. Despite some architectural paste-ons and a largely new administration, the problem remains. Te Papa is not even a de facto national gallery.

The 10th anniversary should have provided an opportunity to acknowledge the deficits and suggest some solutions. The only Wellington way out would be some radical architectural surgery. It is unlikely that most of the country's taxpayers would be happy to spend another hundred or so million dollars on what their first $300 million got wrong.

So, why not do what other major national institutions do when their collections outgrow their buildings? Open a branch office. There is a spot in the middle of Auckland's Tank Farm marked "iconic building". Just rub that out and replace it with "Te Papa Auckland", thus extending the national museum's reach to a third of the country's population. Simple really. The national collections get space to show and, for a breath¬taking change, something national happens outside Wellington.

MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage


How should New Zealand tackle rising tensions in Asia-Pacific and Europe?
83284 2017-11-18 00:00:00Z World

How should New Zealand tackle rising tensions in A…

by Robert Patman

It's time for the big powers to get over their great power rivalries when it comes to international disputes in the 21st century. But what can NZ do?

Read more
Richard Evans: The historian who took on a Holocaust-denier
83242 2017-11-18 00:00:00Z Profiles

Richard Evans: The historian who took on a Holocau…

by Diana Wichtel

When Holocaust denier David Irving addressed the judge in his libel case as “mein Führer”, expert witness Richard Evans couldn’t believe his ears.

Read more
A book of required reading in our time of terror
83277 2017-11-18 00:00:00Z Books

A book of required reading in our time of terror

by Catherine Woulfe

Kamila Shamsie's new novel Home Again is about the beguiling pull of violent causes.

Read more
Memory check-up: The clinics helping pre-dementia sufferers
80411 2017-11-18 00:00:00Z Health

Memory check-up: The clinics helping pre-dementia …

by Donna Chisholm

A nationwide study of memory loss and pre-dementia has good news for one of its first recruits, Graeme Newton

Read more
Whole grain diets could reduce the risk of bowel cancer
83269 2017-11-18 00:00:00Z Nutrition

Whole grain diets could reduce the risk of bowel c…

by Jennifer Bowden

There’s good news and bad about New Zealand’s second-biggest cancer killer.

Read more
7 personal questions for cartoonist Tom Scott
83303 2017-11-17 14:33:23Z Profiles

7 personal questions for cartoonist Tom Scott

by Clare de Lore

Cartoonist, political columnist, playwright and film-maker Tom Scott marks his 70th birthday with the release of Drawn Out: A Seriously Funny Memoir.

Read more
The disappearance of Jim Donnelly: 'There are more questions than answers'
83250 2017-11-17 06:37:31Z Crime

The disappearance of Jim Donnelly: 'There are more…

by Paloma Migone

On Monday June 21, 2004, Jim Donnelly signed into work as usual. Thirteen years later, he still hasn't signed out.

Read more
Auckland rates increase: 'It's a good time to be selling'
83248 2017-11-17 06:27:23Z Property

Auckland rates increase: 'It's a good time to be s…

by RNZ

Homeowners in one of Auckland's cheaper suburbs could find themselves out of pocket when their next rates bill arrives in the mail.

Read more