Blue Collar edited by Richard Ford review

by Craig Cliff / 13 August, 2011
Richard Ford leaves too much of the hard work to the reader in his anthology Blue Collar, White Collar, No Collar.
Novelist and short-story writer Richard Ford’s anthology of 32 stories about work, Blue Collar, White Collar, No Collar, has many virtues. It is well intentioned (all author proceeds go toward free youth writing and tutoring programmes offered by the charity 826michigan). It has big-name authors from the older guard (John Cheever, Eudora Welty, Donald Barthelme) and the current darlings (Annie Proulx, TC Boyle, Junot Diaz), alongside writers still rising to the American firmament (Jim Shepherd, Charles D’Ambrosio, Lewis Robinson).

It has a handful of A++ stories, such as Elizabeth Strout’s Pharmacy, from her 2009 Pulitzer Prize-winning collection of linked stories, Olive Kitteridge, which thrives out of its initial context and permits us inside the life and labours of a small-town pharmacist. And it might even be timely: in a “time of shortage”, as Ford terms the current economic situation in his introduction, these stories “apply the consolations of literature to the complex, often perplexing matters of … getting hired, laid off, promoted, demoted, reclassified, sent home or just plain being fed up”.

But as a themed anthology, Blue Collar, White Collar, No Collar is destined to perplex as much as it pleases.

Ford gives the collection a bum steer in his scattered introduction, discussing the importance of knowing how a fictional character makes his or her crust and the “payload of artful plausibility” this carries. This is true enough, but it reduces work and employment in the stories that follow to a mere facet of characterisation. A more important point, it seems to me, is how the best of these stories get to the heart of what it might be like to be a ranch hand in Montana (Tom McGuane’s Cowboy) or a storekeeper in Washington DC (Edward P Jones’s The Store), while still tapping into more universal experiences: friendship, secrets, loss.

Indeed, the stories that fall flat are those that use work as a means of characterisation without providing any insight into the work itself. The biggest flop is Ford’s own Under the Radar, which only touches on work in the fourth paragraph (Steven Reeves works at Packard-Wells, “attending technical seminars, flying to vendor conventions, then writing up detailed status reports”) before getting to the real story about infidelity.

When I read Under the Radar as part of Ford’s 2002 collection, A Multitude of Sins, it struck me as concise and memorable, the stand-out story in what was an otherwise tiresome and one-note collection. But in this new context, under this new lens, the story withered.

Conversely, with a rereading of the title story from Jhumpa Lahiri’s collection Interpreter of Maladies, the attention paid to work shifted the focus from the troubled relationship of Mr and Mrs Das, on holiday in India, to Mr Kapasi, their tour guide. Here was a self-educated man, a grafter, a dreamer; the details of his CV are drip-fed into the story to build his character and provide insights into the tasks of tour guide and interpreter.

The work performed in the stories is suitably varied (typewriter repairman, priest’s housekeeper, lawyer), but the arrangement of the stories in alphabetical order creates some odd connections and a few disharmonies. The stories traverse the last 50 years of North American life and economics and I found myself repeatedly turning to the back of the book to see when a story was first published. If Max Apple’s Business Talk is from 2004 rather than 1984, the narrator’s desire to open a frozen yoghurt stand seems more forlorn than cutting edge and the entire story takes a different slant.

Although Ford has left a lot of the hard work to the reader, those that make their way through the book will surely be rewarded. The stories by Cheever, Strout, Alice Munro and Richard Yates are vivifying examples of the form. Like the best anthologies, Blue Collar, White Collar, No Collar will send you off in directions new and old, but it is hard to shake the feeling it could have been done better.

BLUE COLLAR, WHITE COLLAR, NO COLLAR: STORIES OF WORK, edited by Richard Ford (Harper Perennial, $28.99).

Craig Cliff’s short-story collection
A Man Melting won this year’s Commonwealth Writers’ Prize for Best First Book.
MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage


Crooked: Is the back-pain industry doing more harm than good?
83311 2017-11-20 06:41:01Z Health

Crooked: Is the back-pain industry doing more harm…

by Jules Older

If shots and surgery and addictive pills don’t relieve back pain, what does? Jules Older talks to the author of a spine medicine exposé.

Read more
Win the Listener's 100 Best Books of 2017
83307 2017-11-19 16:57:02Z Win

Win the Listener's 100 Best Books of 2017

by The Listener

Each year, the Listener offers one lucky subscriber the chance to win all 100 of our Best Books.

Read more
Euthanasia referendum: Are opponents afraid of what the public might decide?
83261 2017-11-19 00:00:00Z Social issues

Euthanasia referendum: Are opponents afraid of wha…

by Graham Adams

When it comes to the issue of euthanasia, it’s hardly a face-off between two equal forces as the media likes to frame it.

Read more
How to fix your dry and gritty eyes
83273 2017-11-19 00:00:00Z Health

How to fix your dry and gritty eyes

by Nicky Pellegrino

If your eyes feel gritty or are sensitive to light, chances are you have blocked lipid glands.

Read more
How to take a break in one of the most isolated places on the planet, Antarctica
80515 2017-11-19 00:00:00Z Life in NZ

How to take a break in one of the most isolated pl…

by Guy Frederick

About four times each season, Kate Grenfell, a "domestic" at Scott Base, books in for a night at the world’s southernmost bach.

Read more
How should New Zealand tackle rising tensions in Asia-Pacific and Europe?
83284 2017-11-18 00:00:00Z World

How should New Zealand tackle rising tensions in A…

by Robert Patman

It's time for the big powers to get over their great power rivalries when it comes to international disputes in the 21st century. But what can NZ do?

Read more
Richard Evans: The historian who took on a Holocaust-denier
83242 2017-11-18 00:00:00Z Profiles

Richard Evans: The historian who took on a Holocau…

by Diana Wichtel

When Holocaust denier David Irving addressed the judge in his libel case as “mein Führer”, expert witness Richard Evans couldn’t believe his ears.

Read more
A book of required reading in our time of terror
83277 2017-11-18 00:00:00Z Books

A book of required reading in our time of terror

by Catherine Woulfe

Kamila Shamsie's new novel Home Fire is about the beguiling pull of violent causes.

Read more