Dan Carter's injury doesn't mean defeat

by Paul Thomas / 15 October, 2011
Dan Carter’s groin strain doesn’t have to be the end of everything.

A month ago I wrote that “anyone who doubted there’s a malign force in the universe determined to squeeze every last drop of optimism out of the New Zealand public must surely now be convinced”. I should have known better. I should have realised it was reckless to be expending precious reserves of pessimism before the World Cup was even under way.

Short of declaring the All Blacks can’t win the tournament without Dan Carter, it’s difficult to overstate the significance of his unavailability: put simply, he’s the best in the business in a critical position. The inside backs – halfback and first five, numbers nine and 10 – are the tactical hub: the ball passes through their hands in almost every sequence of play. They direct the team around the park and call the moves; they are the link between the forwards, who win the ball, and the backs, who use it.

The fact we don’t have an outstanding halfback makes the loss of Carter all the more damaging. His designated back-up Colin Slade would be less exposed outside a Fourie du Preez or a Will Genia because they would relieve him of some of the tactical and game management responsibility. Before the tournament some overseas commentators identified halfback as the one weak link in the All Black line-up. Now they will argue the All Blacks are sub-standard at nine and 10, which amounts to a fatal weakness.

No team has won the World Cup without at least one world class inside back. In 1987 it was Grant Fox, in 1995 Joost van der Westhuizen, in 2003 Jonny Wilkinson and in 2007 du Preez. The winning Wallabies had two – Nick Farr-Jones and Michael Lynagh in 1991, George Gregan and Stephen Larkham in 1999. Whether he plays at nine or, as many are advocating, 10, Piri Weepu now becomes a key figure. If you can’t win without a world class inside back, then he’s probably the only one of those available with the capacity to go to that level over the next three weeks.

Weepu brings to mind Churchill’s aphorism about Russia: a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma. He’s steeped in rugby league through his family – his brother played for Manly in the NFL – and Wainuiomata upbringing, and has often given the impression he’d really rather be playing the other code. There have been issues with his fitness, weight and off-field behaviour. He was left out of the 2007 World Cup squad amid suggestions he was inclined to buck protocols around socialising and sulk when he didn’t make the playing 22.

But he’s a confident character with big match temperament and the priceless gift of vision: the ability to see space on a cluttered field. He’s also an extremely solid goal-kicker. Although he’d make a good fist of replacing Carter, he probably offers more value at halfback, especially with the experienced Jimmy Cowan struggling for form.

There will be mutterings about the NZRU’s self-imposed handicap which eliminated England-based Nick Evans from calculations. However, if Evans had wanted to put himself in the position of being the starting All Black 10 should anything happen to Carter, he knew what he had to do. He chose not to. The selectors will also be berated for failing to settle on Carter’s back-up much earlier. If it had been that clear-cut, they would have.

As Graham Henry said, the All Blacks now have to play the hand they’ve been dealt. We should take comfort from the fact their greatest triumph since the 1987 World Cup – the 1996 series win in South Africa – was achieved without either of the star first fives of their generation: Andrew Mehrtens and Carlos Spencer.

When the time came, the responsibility was thrust on Simon Culhane, who like Slade had played very little rugby that season, and Jon Preston, like Weepu a halfback first and foremost. Between them they got the job done.
MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage


Richard Prebble: Jacinda Ardern will face the tyranny of events
86009 2018-01-19 00:00:00Z Politics

Richard Prebble: Jacinda Ardern will face the tyra…

by Richard Prebble

I predicted Bill English would lose the election and the winner would be Winston Peters. But no forecaster, including the PM, predicted her pregnancy.

Read more
Aokigahara: More than just the ‘suicide forest’
85966 2018-01-19 00:00:00Z World

Aokigahara: More than just the ‘suicide forest’

by Justin Bennett

It's known as a 'suicide forest', but Justin Bennett found Aokigahara's quiet beauty outweighed its infamous reputation.

Read more
Truth and Lye: New perspectives on the brilliance of Len Lye
85816 2018-01-19 00:00:00Z Arts

Truth and Lye: New perspectives on the brilliance …

by Sally Blundell

New essays on New Zealand-born US artist Len Lye elevate him to the status of Australasia’s most notable 20th-century artist.

Read more
Brain activity may hold the secret to helping infertile couples
86046 2018-01-19 00:00:00Z Health

Brain activity may hold the secret to helping infe…

by Nicky Pellegrino

For about a third of infertility cases in New Zealand, there is no obvious reason why seemingly fertile couples struggle to conceive.

Read more
Farewells on the Auckland wharves, captured by photographer John Rykenberg
85964 2018-01-19 00:00:00Z Life in NZ

Farewells on the Auckland wharves, captured by pho…

by Frances Walsh

More than one million images from Rykenberg Photography, taken around Auckland, are now in the Auckland Libraries Collection. But who are the people?

Read more
'Termite hell' for Golden Bay man after he woke covered in insects
86027 2018-01-18 11:59:55Z Environment

'Termite hell' for Golden Bay man after he woke co…

by Hamish Cardwell

A Golden Bay man spending his first night in his new house says he woke to find his bed, walls and floor covered in hundreds of creepy crawlies.

Read more
Ten ‘stealth microplastics’ to avoid if you want to save the oceans
86015 2018-01-18 11:18:49Z Environment

Ten ‘stealth microplastics’ to avoid if you want t…

by Sharon George and Deirdre McKay

There's a growing movement to stop the amount of wasteful plastic that goes into our oceans, but what about the tiny bits we can hardly see?

Read more
It's time to chlorinate New Zealand's drinking water
86001 2018-01-18 09:41:15Z Social issues

It's time to chlorinate New Zealand's drinking wat…

by The Listener

The inconvenience to chlorine refuseniks is tiny compared with the risk of more suffering and tragedy from another Havelock North-style contamination.

Read more