Auckland's heritage suffers the death of a thousand careless cuts

by Fiona Rae / 18 February, 2012
Heritage houses in Auckland continue to be demolished, despite a promise from Len Brown.


The catastrophic event in Christchurch last year ought to have radically changed the way we view our urban heritage. Sadly, it has not. In Auckland, the city's links to its past continue to suffer a death of a thousand careless cuts. If anything, the southern experience seems to have reinforced a dangerously narrow view of just what is valuable in our urban history.

Heritage, in that view, is solely about architectural aesthetics. Buildings, to escape the developer's bulldozer, have to be of unquestioned architectural merit. That is the theory, anyway. It is clearly an elastic measure that, in 2006, did not prevent the gracious landmark 1913 Remuera mansion "Coolangatta" being smashed to kindling in just 19 minutes. Auckland City Council could have saved that building, but a slim majority of its members – driven by what seems to have been mansion envy – thought otherwise.

Then last year three Spanish mission villas in St Heliers met the same fate. Essential to the neighbourhood character, argued the residents; a bunch of worthless wrecks, said the experts, and the villas bit the dust. That, of course, was the old, unreconstructed Auckland administration. Things would be better under the new, and the newly elected mayor, Len Brown, promised the St Heliers fiasco would "never happen again". That was then and now is now and a 130-year-old cottage in Freemans Bay is about to join Auckland's mountain of heritage rubble.

It is exactly the same row repeated. Local residents argue that the cottage is an irreplaceable link with their suburb's past. Experts claim it is in a ruinous state beyond repair. The interesting twist to this all-too-familiar Auckland story is that the council's own heritage planner, who would not recommend demolition, was replaced at the 11th hour by an external consultant who would. Coincidently, he was the same planner involved in the St Heliers villa demolitions.

Summing up, the council's chief executive declared "there was an element of judgment and subjectivity to applications to demolish pre-1940 houses in the Residential I zone". That raises the question of what that judgment and subjectivity is based on, and which is given the greater weight. Sadly, it misses what seems to be the essential point in heritage protection. The fundamental thing to be considered is not architectural merit – more often than not a matter of "subjectivity" as much as "judgment" – but context.

What was destroyed in Christchurch was not only a raft of great old buildings but also the city's historical context; all those lesser structures that could not make a case for survival on architectural values alone, but when taken together provided the unique built fabric of Christchurch. The Freemans Bay cottage has no architectural values that will shine in some retirement home for old houses. Where it is, it ties that gentrifying suburb to its past. Heritage is about context and continuity – part of that subtle grid of meaning that makes place much more than just a street address.
MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage

Latest

The blue zone: Kiwi workers' wage gap trap
71457 2017-04-23 00:00:00Z Economy

The blue zone: Kiwi workers' wage gap trap

by Virginia Larson

For blue-collar workers, the gap between the haves and the have-littles is widening.

Read more
Suitably predictable: Why we're attracted to a uniform
71366 2017-04-23 00:00:00Z Psychology

Suitably predictable: Why we're attracted to a uni…

by Marc Wilson

Why firefighters get the girl more often than the average bloke does.

Read more
Empty nest: Can you be a parent and a minimalist?
71468 2017-04-22 00:00:00Z Social issues

Empty nest: Can you be a parent and a minimalist?

by Michelle Duff

The mind of a parent is in danger of becoming a cluttered wasteland, strewn with the skeletons of high chairs, baby slings and disused toys.

Read more
Jane Millton captures the plight of the Kaikoura cows in a kids' book
71343 2017-04-22 00:00:00Z Profiles

Jane Millton captures the plight of the Kaikoura c…

by Clare de Lore

Two cows and a calf grabbed international headlines after the Kaikoura earthquake, and the story of their rescue is now the subject of a new book.

Read more
Pollution in a Piha paradise
71451 2017-04-22 00:00:00Z Environment

Pollution in a Piha paradise

by Anusha Bradley

Piha is famous for its rugged black-sand beaches, but locals say Auckland Council needs to do more to fix the polluted lagoon.

Read more
Film review: Ghost in the Shell
71490 2017-04-21 12:05:59Z Movies

Film review: Ghost in the Shell

by Russell Baillie

Nothing dates faster than a past idea of the future.

Read more
The 9th Floor: Jim Bolger on his time as Prime Minister
71476 2017-04-21 11:29:57Z Currently

The 9th Floor: Jim Bolger on his time as Prime Min…

by Guyon Espiner

There is so much to the Bolger years. The first MMP government with Winston Peters, the economic growth of the mid-90s, and the birth of Te Papa.

Read more
Immigration: The battle lines are drawn
71454 2017-04-21 09:38:47Z Economy

Immigration: The battle lines are drawn

by Graham Adams

Bill English needs to win Auckland to win the election, but his latest immigration changes seem to ignore one of its citizens’ biggest concerns.

Read more