"Envious slander": Finns lash out at Gerry Brownlee

by Toby Manhire / 26 March, 2012
Gerry Brownlee's swipe at Finland has gone down like rancid graavilohi.


Gerry Brownlee’s barnstorming attack on Finland was essentially a byproduct of a blast at David Shearer, who had cited the country as an economic model. By happy coincidence, it also allowed Brownlee to suck up to his boss, John Key, who had amusingly skewered Shearer in similar territory the day before.

But Big GB’s chortle-heavy denunciation of the Nordic country as one “which has worse unemployment than us, has less growth than us, can hardly feed the people who live there, has a terrible homicide rate, hardly educates its people, and has no respect for women” had “Finns fuming”, noted the NZ Herald, which quoted a cross Finnish consul-general in Auckland saying, “I think it would have been better left unsaid”.

TVNZ reports that a Facebook page has been set up by a Finnish academic in New Zealand to “educate Gerry Brownlee”. The page has apparently a mighty 31 members and they are saying some rude things. But TVNZ doesn’t include a link to the Facebook page which is silly, so I’m not going to link to the TVNZ page. Which is equally silly but there you have it.

Stuff's take on the story does include a link to the Facebook page - here it is - and news on the way Brownlee's routine is going down in Finland. "The story is flaming in the Finnish media," according to Juha Parikka, counsellor to the Finnish embassy in Canberra.

A scan of the Finnish media online suggests the story has been received with a mix of alarm, amusement and defensiveness – roughly speaking, much as it would have ruffled the feathers of another small country, New Zealand, had some Finnish Weeble-like minister said such things about us.

The embassy in Canberra has told reporters from Finland that they intend to “carefully examine” Brownlee’s comments before deciding to take the matter further, suggesting that it could amount to a rhetorical “overkill”.

Vasabladat reports that Juha Parikka told FNB, the Finnish national news agency, the following:

We want to investigate if there is something else behind it or if it is only if the foul during a political debate. My interpretation is that it is only for domestic political struggle in New Zealand, said Parikka on the phone to FNB.


Parikka out that the language of the New Zealand Parliament is often more harsh and crackling.


“They let it slip. It is very different than what we're used to in Finland.”


Parikka says that relations between Finland and New Zealand are excellent.


“We understand each other very well. We are the countries of the same size and have similar problems. It is usually easy to find a common tone. My guess is that New Zealanders will come to regret this, said Parikka.


Already there are 41 pages of reader comments at the site of Iltalehti, the tabloid which first reported the story in Finland.

“Envious slander,” is, I think, a typical comment – though I didn’t make my way through more than five pages. In common with much of the world, the Finnish comment thread seems home to plenty of bile and incoherence (though admittedly this is compounded by the lens of Google translate).

And one Finnish blogger, who writes chiefly (in English) about maths, and describes himself as a “Tolkien-reading, Dawkins-quoting voracious bibliophile”, seemed more than a little put out.

Mask of Eris concluded his post like this:

But since I don’t want to be too hard on Mr Brownlee, and I want to charitably accept his later comment that his words were satirical, yet with a grain of truth in them… well, don’t worry, Mr Brownlee. I don’t bear a grudge.


Just you New Zealanders stop raping sheep, children and your Maori slaves, which is a satirical comment with a shadow of fact in it so no hard feelings, and we’re okay.



https://www.facebook.com/groups/321199901278283/?notif-t=group-r2j
MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage

Latest

Statistics NZ criticised over census workers' conditions
75656 2017-06-28 07:11:08Z Business

Statistics NZ criticised over census workers' cond…

by Craig McCulloch

Newly employed workers have accused Statistics NZ of treating temporary staff as "workers they can turn off and turn on".

Read more
National MP Alfred Ngaro: 'I own my mistake. I own what I said'
75560 2017-06-28 00:00:00Z Profiles

National MP Alfred Ngaro: 'I own my mistake. I own…

by Guyon Espiner

The minister whose provocative conference speech earned him a rebuke from the PM says voters should support the person whose values they share.

Read more
Upon a fragile planet: NZ Dance Company's new show reflects a world of worry
75523 2017-06-28 00:00:00Z Theatre

Upon a fragile planet: NZ Dance Company's new show…

by Francesca Horsley

The New Zealand Dance Company’s new season mixes deconstructed Vivaldi with a touch of Korean Zen.

Read more
There’s a clear economic argument for spending on mental health
75192 2017-06-28 00:00:00Z Psychology

There’s a clear economic argument for spending on …

by Marc Wilson

In 2001, depression and anxiety were identified as the two highest-ranked diseases in terms of years lost to disability.

Read more
Gender quotas weed out incompetent men - study
Police reopen Todd Barclay case
Toppling titans: NZ's history in the America's Cup
75636 2017-06-27 11:10:01Z Sport

Toppling titans: NZ's history in the America's Cup…

by Matt Chatterton

The highlights and lowlights of this country's 30 years in the America's Cup.

Read more
'We're on top of the world': Team NZ wins 35th America's Cup
75628 2017-06-27 10:26:25Z Sport

'We're on top of the world': Team NZ wins 35th Ame…

by RNZ

Team New Zealand helmsman Peter Burling elated as the America's Cup become New Zealand's Cup.

Read more