Film review: Trishna

by Helene Wong / 26 May, 2012
Michael Winterbottom transports <em>Tess of the d’Urbervilles</em> to modern India, says Helene Wong.
Like Woody Allen, Michael Winterbottom turns out a film a year, sometimes more than one; has fave actors (is Steve Coogan his Tony Roberts?); and hops around genres. He’s far more adventurous than Allen, though, seeming to revel in being a moving target when choosing projects. In 2004-06 alone, he zipped from non-porno porn (9 Songs) to postmodern mash-up (A Cock and Bull Story) to political docudrama (The Road to Guantánamo). But unlike Allen, in his resulting buffet of work I can’t think of any empty calories, just dishes of varying meatiness. The latest, Trishna, is a love story, and if on the surface it appears slight and built from old bones, there’s still some meat left and maybe even a bit of marrow if you’re patient enough.

The old bones come from Thomas Hardy, a writer Winterbottom has adapted before – Jude and The Claim – and here it’s Tess of the d’Urbervilles. In transporting Hardy’s classic of class, gender roles and 19th-century industrial change to contemporary India, Tess becomes Trishna, her two lovers are conflated into one, and the social change, globalisation, is equally or even more massive. This isn’t The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel’s wistful harking back to Empire, but an edgier examination of its consequences. There is a link, though. Globalisation means tourism, which means hotels, and the ones here are the grand old ladies of Rajasthan. Jay (Riz Ahmed), born and brought up in Britain, has been despatched to India by his immigrant father to manage the family’s hotel, er, empire. A spoilt, second-generation rich kid, he’s reluctant and excited at the same time, but when he spots Trishna (Freida Pinto), a village girl of breathtaking beauty, things don’t look so bad after all. He engineers a meeting and they fall in love.

Then the trouble starts, and the first intimation of that meatiness. Both Trishna and Jay are dislocated characters: she’s a country girl transplanted into urban life and wealth; he’s a British Asian grappling with his identity. For him, she’s a pure, close-to-the-earth Indian woman who excites the Henry Higgins in him as well as his hormones; for her, he offers opportunity and an exciting life. Despite shared cultural roots, though, their values and expectations are vastly different or not understood, and the subsequent confusion leads to confl ict of tragic proportions. Straddling documentary and drama as he often does, Winterbottom mixes in non-actors with actors and uses improvised dialogue to achieve a feeling of realism. Mostly it works, except that Pinto (Slumdog Millionaire), although a gorgeous-looking Trishna, seems almost too gorgeous beside the rural people playing her family.

Ahmed (Four Lions) fares better among the energetic new generation of Bollywood film-makers Jay hooks up with. The documentary element is at its most vivid in Marcel Zyskind’s camera work, capturing India’s hurtling tempo with the rush of Mumbai, and the numerous speeding, juddering travelling shots that have become a Winterbottom trademark, particularly in his films set in the Third World. This director has looked at the personal effects of globalism before (In This World, The Road to Guantánamo), but not at this level of intimacy. Trishna is so intimate, in fact, that at times the psychology is very internalised and hard to read. Only on reflection do we get some clarity on what prompted the characters’ behaviour and decisions. It’s possible this may be to underscore the depth of the conflict, and how confusing it is even to the characters, but it can be frustrating and disengaging. It may also be a weakness in subtextual performance.

Compounding this is Trishna’s passivity. Culturally, it’s entirely credible, and responsible for much of Jay’s subsequent behaviour, but it does stop us getting inside her head. More seriously, that absence of point of view makes the melodrama of the finale a shock. Tess fans won’t be surprised, but others might find it unconvincing. But perhaps that’s the point – and the marrow in the bone – a deliberate jolt to a modern Western viewer, now accustomed to feisty, active heroines, into realising the small and hidden costs of globalism.

TRISHNA, directed by Michael Winterbottom.
MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage


The blue zone: Kiwi workers' wage gap trap
71457 2017-04-23 00:00:00Z Economy

The blue zone: Kiwi workers' wage gap trap

by Virginia Larson

For blue-collar workers, the gap between the haves and the have-littles is widening.

Read more
Suitably predictable: Why we're attracted to a uniform
71366 2017-04-23 00:00:00Z Psychology

Suitably predictable: Why we're attracted to a uni…

by Marc Wilson

Why firefighters get the girl more often than the average bloke does.

Read more
Empty nest: Can you be a parent and a minimalist?
71468 2017-04-22 00:00:00Z Social issues

Empty nest: Can you be a parent and a minimalist?

by Michelle Duff

The mind of a parent is in danger of becoming a cluttered wasteland, strewn with the skeletons of high chairs, baby slings and disused toys.

Read more
Jane Millton captures the plight of the Kaikoura cows in a kids' book
71343 2017-04-22 00:00:00Z Profiles

Jane Millton captures the plight of the Kaikoura c…

by Clare de Lore

Two cows and a calf grabbed international headlines after the Kaikoura earthquake, and the story of their rescue is now the subject of a new book.

Read more
Pollution in a Piha paradise
71451 2017-04-22 00:00:00Z Environment

Pollution in a Piha paradise

by Anusha Bradley

Piha is famous for its rugged black-sand beaches, but locals say Auckland Council needs to do more to fix the polluted lagoon.

Read more
Film review: Ghost in the Shell
71490 2017-04-21 12:05:59Z Movies

Film review: Ghost in the Shell

by Russell Baillie

Nothing dates faster than a past idea of the future.

Read more
The 9th Floor: Jim Bolger on his time as Prime Minister
71476 2017-04-21 11:29:57Z Currently

The 9th Floor: Jim Bolger on his time as Prime Min…

by Guyon Espiner

There is so much to the Bolger years. The first MMP government with Winston Peters, the economic growth of the mid-90s, and the birth of Te Papa.

Read more
Immigration: The battle lines are drawn
71454 2017-04-21 09:38:47Z Economy

Immigration: The battle lines are drawn

by Graham Adams

Bill English needs to win Auckland to win the election, but his latest immigration changes seem to ignore one of its citizens’ biggest concerns.

Read more