Germany must makes adjustments too

by Fiona Rae / 04 February, 2012
Countries in surplus must play their part if they want to avoid a worse Europe-wide recession.

A decade ago, the Economic and Monetary Union (EMU) replaced 17 European currencies with the euro, locking their nominal exchange rates together. Germany decided its wage and price structure was too high. This made it more likely Germans would buy imports and that other countries wouldn’t buy German goods. Painfully the Germans slowed their wage and price rises relative to their competitors’ until they got their levels into balance; the German economy has prospered since.

Other members of the EMU have not been so rigorous and are now struggling with the consequences of excessive price levels. They have borrowed to maintain domestic demand, for they import too much and cannot sell enough exports. International lenders are increasingly uneasy about the ballooning debt, so they hike their interest rates. The vicious circle of higher debt and higher interest rates continues until the debt-ridden country defaults. The more prudent lenders say, “I told you so”, while those who hung in there for the high interest rates take a haircut – their loans get devalued; this has already happened with Greece and may happen to others, including Italy.

Having the European Central Bank lend to the potentially defaulting countries cannot be the long-term solution, because this does not address the under­lying problem. The Germans are quite right on this point. Moreover, fiscal measures such as less government spending and more taxation are not enough unless wages and prices also come down. It is difficult to do this quickly, so a prudent European Central Bank might offer some cover if it really believed a country was on track. (Does one believe a democracy will stay on track past the next budget? The Germans did.)

There is a potential contradiction here. If the debtor countries lower their internal price level to make them more competitive, then Germany – among others – will be less competitive; its exports will fall and imports rise. As the debtor savings rise, other countries’ savings must fall. Since Germany is the biggest saver in the EMU, its economic prosperity will be compromised.

The official German position, expressed by Chancellor Angela Merkel, is that the deficit countries must be more fiscally austere. There is no hint that the Germans will increase their public spending or cut their taxes. Yet if they do not want to collapse Europe into a serious recession, the surplus countries must be more fiscally relaxed. German economists are as good as those anywhere else in the world, so they must be well aware of the orthodoxy of the previous few paragraphs.

There is growing impatience from some European leaders at the inconsistency in German thinking. Italian Prime Minister Mario Monti, who describes himself as the most German of the Italian economists, has criticised the German stance. He is not saying Italy should abandon the painful adjustment he is implementing, but that it cannot be done alone. Germany has to do its share of the adjustment too.

When the International Monetary Fund was set up nearly 70 years ago, English economist John Maynard Keynes suggested the international monetary system should make economies with external surpluses take adjustment measures as well as the deficit countries. The US, then running a huge surplus, was having none of this, and the system ended up with only the deficit countries having to adjust (as, apparently, is required in Europe).

Today, however, the US is running a huge deficit, and US economists are looking more benignly on Keynes’s proposal, arguing that China with its huge external surplus must reduce its savings. Here on the margins of the world, New Zealanders can but be fearful that political stupidity will lead to international economic disaster – as has happened too often in the past.

But there is a practical issue. Were New Zealand to join Australia in a monetary union, we could end up with a similar – albeit smaller – disaster. Currently, unlike the countries of the EMU, we can also change the exchange rate to get the right price relativities (although we would still need to make a painful fiscal adjustment). The EMU countries can’t change their exchange rate, while those outside it, such as the UK, can. The fate of the EMU countries looks murkier.

Click here for more columns by Brian Easton. Brian's website is at
MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage


The blue zone: Kiwi workers' wage gap trap
71457 2017-04-23 00:00:00Z Economy

The blue zone: Kiwi workers' wage gap trap

by Virginia Larson

For blue-collar workers, the gap between the haves and the have-littles is widening.

Read more
Suitably predictable: Why we're attracted to a uniform
71366 2017-04-23 00:00:00Z Psychology

Suitably predictable: Why we're attracted to a uni…

by Marc Wilson

Why firefighters get the girl more often than the average bloke does.

Read more
Empty nest: Can you be a parent and a minimalist?
71468 2017-04-22 00:00:00Z Social issues

Empty nest: Can you be a parent and a minimalist?

by Michelle Duff

The mind of a parent is in danger of becoming a cluttered wasteland, strewn with the skeletons of high chairs, baby slings and disused toys.

Read more
Jane Millton captures the plight of the Kaikoura cows in a kids' book
71343 2017-04-22 00:00:00Z Profiles

Jane Millton captures the plight of the Kaikoura c…

by Clare de Lore

Two cows and a calf grabbed international headlines after the Kaikoura earthquake, and the story of their rescue is now the subject of a new book.

Read more
Pollution in a Piha paradise
71451 2017-04-22 00:00:00Z Environment

Pollution in a Piha paradise

by Anusha Bradley

Piha is famous for its rugged black-sand beaches, but locals say Auckland Council needs to do more to fix the polluted lagoon.

Read more
Film review: Ghost in the Shell
71490 2017-04-21 12:05:59Z Movies

Film review: Ghost in the Shell

by Russell Baillie

Nothing dates faster than a past idea of the future.

Read more
The 9th Floor: Jim Bolger on his time as Prime Minister
71476 2017-04-21 11:29:57Z Currently

The 9th Floor: Jim Bolger on his time as Prime Min…

by Guyon Espiner

There is so much to the Bolger years. The first MMP government with Winston Peters, the economic growth of the mid-90s, and the birth of Te Papa.

Read more
Immigration: The battle lines are drawn
71454 2017-04-21 09:38:47Z Economy

Immigration: The battle lines are drawn

by Graham Adams

Bill English needs to win Auckland to win the election, but his latest immigration changes seem to ignore one of its citizens’ biggest concerns.

Read more