Is Christmas dinner a health risk?

by Jennifer Bowden / 13 December, 2012
Overeating and heavy alcohol consumption may be a lethal combination.
Is Christmas dinner a health risk
Getty Images/Listener photo illustration


A little overindulgence on Christmas Day seems harmless enough. After all, it’s just one day, right? Yet each year on Christmas Day more people die than on any other day from sudden cardiac arrest. Is it the excitement or stress of family gatherings? Or are extravagant Christmas dinners dangerous for our health?

Sudden cardiac arrest occurs when the heart develops an abnormal rhythm, or arrhythmia, that causes it to stop beating and pumping blood to the brain and other organs. Cardiac arrest differs from a heart attack, in which the heart usually continues to beat despite its blood flow being blocked.

Typical cardiac arrest signs include sudden collapse, loss of consciousness, no breathing or pulse and skin turning pale or blue. Without prompt medical attention, death occurs within minutes. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) or, ideally, defibrillation (which gives the heart a small shock to restore its rhythm) must be started immediately, as every minute’s delay reduces survival chances by about 10%. See “In for a shock” (December 8) for more about automated external defibrillators.

In New Zealand, about 1500 people suffer sudden cardiac arrest each year and 90% die as a result. Millions of people worldwide die of cardiac arrest each year, most in winter, and many on celebration days such as Christmas and New Year. There’s a well-established link between heavy alcohol consumption (more than six drinks a day) and increased cardiac arrest risk.

Furthermore, stress-related catecholamine hormones have also been shown to cause the arrhythmias associated with cardiac arrest. However, a hypothesis recently published in the Journal of Applied Toxicology adds overeating to the mix.

Christmas Day may create a perfect storm: excitement, stress and excessive food and alcohol intake – especially for genetically susceptible people – raising the risk of sudden cardiac arrest that almost inevitably results in death. Underpinning this hypothesis is a system of enzymes that our body uses to deactivate the catecholamine stress-related hormones. These SULT1A enzymes are naturally less active in winter, coincidentally when most sudden cardiac arrests occur.

Evidence also suggests phenols and polyphenols found in many plant-derived foods can inhibit these enzymes, thereby allowing higher levels of stress hormones to accumulate in our body, possibly leading to arrhythmias. Furthermore, genetic differences may make some people more susceptible to SULT1A inhibition.

Phenols and polyphenol compounds are found in most alcoholic drinks (especially red wines), herbs, spices, citrus fruits, berries, coffee, tea, chocolate, onion, tomato and many other plant-derived foods. But before you throw the red wine and salad off the Christmas menu, consider this.

On Christmas Day, we typically consume more alcohol and food than on any other day of the year, so if this theory is correct (and that’s not yet proven), the food supply is not inherently unsafe. Nor will overindulgence in food and drink cause cardiac arrest in everyone. But, rather, it’s hypothesised that some genetically susceptible people may need to moderate their food and alcohol consumption, particularly when combined with stress or excitement.

Regardless of whether this hypothesis turns out to be correct, there are still many benefits to being a responsible host on Christmas Day, not least in ensuring your guests have a safe and enjoyable time. Make physical activity part of your celebrations – try pétanque on the back lawn or a walk to the park or beach. Insert it between the main meal and dessert to slow down fast eaters and drinkers.

The greater the variety of food offered the more we eat – there’s no need to skimp on quantities, just slightly limit the variety on your menu and you’ll help guests moderate their intake. Regularly offer your guests water or other non-alcoholic drinks between alcoholic drinks. Place pitchers of iced water and water glasses on the Christmas dinner table – the closer they are, the more people will drink.

Conversely, place alcoholic drinks on a side table to slow consumption. Likewise, moderate food intake by placing dishes on a side table rather than the dinner table – out of sight, out of mind.

Email: nutrition@listener.co.nz, or write to “Nutrition”, c/o Listener, PO Box 90783, Victoria St West, Auckland 1142.
MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage

Latest

Polina – movie review
76492 2017-07-20 00:00:00Z Movies

Polina – movie review

by Russell Baillie

A young dancer turns her back on the Bolshoi Ballet to study modern moves in Polina.

Read more
New Zealand International Film Festival: Metro's top picks of what to see
76536 2017-07-20 00:00:00Z Movies

New Zealand International Film Festival: Metro's t…

by David Larsen

Whether you plan to see just a few of the movies in the film festival or dozens, you’ve got some decisions to make and Metro is here to help.

Read more
K Road's wahine tattooists: How they made their mark
76538 2017-07-20 00:00:00Z Arts

K Road's wahine tattooists: How they made their ma…

by Courtney Sina Meredith

From a lush studio on Karangahape Road, three women practise the art of tattooing.

Read more
How artist couple Liz Maw and Andrew McLeod work and live together
76594 2017-07-20 00:00:00Z Arts

How artist couple Liz Maw and Andrew McLeod work a…

by Julie Hill

Painters Liz Maw and Andrew McLeod share their personal and professional lives and are about to exhibit together

Read more
Why the creative duo behind TUR Studio is creating garments the old way
76619 2017-07-19 15:46:53Z Style

Why the creative duo behind TUR Studio is creating…

by Bianca Zander

The creative duo behind Auckland's TÜR Studio lives life as if the industrial revolution never happened.

Read more
Five fun spots perfect for a group outing
76580 2017-07-19 14:20:28Z Auckland Eats

Five fun spots perfect for a group outing

by Paperboy

Break the monotony of winter with a party at one of these five fun Auckland spots

Read more
What to see at the NZ International Film Festival
76576 2017-07-19 13:31:34Z Movies

What to see at the NZ International Film Festival

by Paperboy

Film buffs Caroline Montague and Alexander Bisley pick apart the NZ International Film Festival programme.

Read more
Three Auckland food pop-ups you won't want to miss
76571 2017-07-19 13:04:40Z Auckland Eats

Three Auckland food pop-ups you won't want to miss…

by Paperboy

Merediths, Culprit and Orphans Kitchen take on guest chefs and unusual ingredients at three pop-up events.

Read more