John Banks and the whole cabbage boat business

by Toby Manhire / 30 April, 2012
Who are these people spreading absurd river-related rumours? Plus, the bloggers on the Kim Dotcom donation claims.
In the midst of the great John Dot Kim Dot Banks kerfuffle over John Dot mayoralty donations, it is important not to overlook the really important thing.

I don’t mean the fireworks or the helicopters or the frankly terrifying image that graced the cover of Saturday morning’s New Zealand Herald (right).

No, I mean the question of how John Banks got here.

Some pernicious force in New Zealand just won’t let it drop. On and on they drone, one presumes, insisting that John Banks got here on some vegetable-based river boat.

I have no documentary evidence to disprove it, but the poor man has vehemently rejected these slurs time and time again, and I say, enough.

Only yesterday, on Q+A, under a barrage of questioning by his good friend and helicopter apprentice Paul Holmes, Mr Banks felt obliged to say:

I think you think I came up the river on a cabbage boat.


Which he did not.

Hurtle back a few months to the days after the election, and look at what Banks told the press pack:

I didn’t come up the river on a cabbage boat.




How could he be clearer?

And it’s not just up the river – neither did he travel in the opposite direction.

As an embattled Mr Banks told TV3 at the height of the teapot tapes row in November:

Just listen, I think you think I came down the river on the last cabbage boat.


That was shortly after he said, following an Epsom candidates’ meeting, as reported in the Herald:

I think you think I came up the river on a cabbage boat.


The humanity!

As long ago as 1999, in the hallowed house of parliament, Mr Banks announced, in his preferred third-person and without so much as a speck of equivocation, as recorded in Hansard:

This member did not come up the river on a cabbage boat.


More to come on this. Possibly.

And by the way, here’s a selection of the NZ bloggertariat on the scandal:

• Russell Brown from Public Address sizes things up here.

• At Kiwiblog, David Farrar sees trouble for Banks if Kim Dotcom is telling the truth.

• Andrew Geddis looks at the legality, or not, of it all at Pundit.

Karl du Fresne predicts it may be curtains for Banks – “poetic justice for a man who was pathetically desperate to cling to political power”.

• Martyn Bradbury at Tumeke urges readers to call Crime Stoppers.

• The guns are out at the Standard, too, here, here and here.

• At Whale Oil, Cameron Slater scoffs at the calls for Banks to stand down.

Cactus Kate defends Banks. Sort of.

• And here’s Imperator Fish with a “statement from John Banks” (about cabbage boats, naturally).

Big hat-tip to Alastair T
MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage

Latest

The clean-energy revolution is already under way
78094 2017-08-16 00:00:00Z Environment

The clean-energy revolution is already under way

by Rebecca Macfie

The question is whether it is accelerating fast enough to turn the tide on climate change.

Read more
Premature babies: The business of keeping tiny humans alive
78131 2017-08-16 00:00:00Z Science

Premature babies: The business of keeping tiny hum…

by Mava Enoka

Science is helping more premature babies survive, but for parents it's still a journey marked by fear, pain and joy.

Read more
Tim Minchin: The man behind Matilda’s musical magic
78107 2017-08-16 00:00:00Z Theatre

Tim Minchin: The man behind Matilda’s musical magi…

by Linda Herrick

A Roald Dahl fan from an early age, Australian composer Tim Minchin has helped turn a children’s classic into a hit musical.

Read more
HRT: The return of menopause therapy
78098 2017-08-16 00:00:00Z Health

HRT: The return of menopause therapy

by Nicky Pellegrino

Hormone treatment of menopause symptoms is back from exile.

Read more
Why NZ Super Fund is ditching millions worth of climate-damaging investments
78102 2017-08-15 14:46:41Z Investment

Why NZ Super Fund is ditching millions worth of cl…

by Rebecca Macfie

The New Zealand Super Fund has moved to reduce the risk of losses on fossil fuel assets, as part of its strategy on climate change.

Read more
Win a double pass to My Year with Helen
78081 2017-08-15 11:09:55Z Win

Win a double pass to My Year with Helen

by The Listener

Following its premiere screenings at the NZIFF, My Year With Helen returns to New Zealand cinemas for a general release.

Read more
Govt gives details for $100m mental health spend
78078 2017-08-15 11:04:37Z Health

Govt gives details for $100m mental health spend

by RNZ

Health Minister Jonathan Coleman has given more details about where money earmarked for mental health will be spent.

Read more
How will DoC deal with the environmental pressures of runaway tourism?
78074 2017-08-15 10:32:53Z Business

How will DoC deal with the environmental pressures…

by Jonathan Underhill

The environmental pressures of runaway tourism and commercial land use aren’t fazing the country’s conservation chief.

Read more