Letters January 5 2013

by Listener Archive / 27 December, 2012
Child poverty; defibrillators; and Fox News.


Marc Wilson’s December 8 Psychology, “Pity the poor children”, came out after the rescreening of TV3’s documentary Inside Child Poverty by Bryan Bruce. There have been numerous other investigations and reports dealing with the same issue in recent times. It makes me angry that this issue continues to be unaddressed by politicians in real terms. Each government of the past 30 years and more is guilty of giving insufficient attention to the problem. It is a political problem. It should not be considered a party political problem. It should be addressed without political bias. Simple suggestions were included in Bruce’s documentary. Provide free medical assistance directly to children. Provide warm, dry housing. Ignore these simple suggestions and visit the consequences not only on today’s children but on society at large in the future. I have been disgusted by much of the rental housing I have seen, whether privately owned or publicly owned. It is a danger to people’s health. If any employer doesn’t provide a safe working environment, and people are hurt or become sick, it is possible for the employer to be financially penalised. Why should those who provide poor housing escape similar provisions? There needs to be a deterrent.
John Haxton
(Raumati Beach)

Yet another report on poverty from some expert. It would be a lot cheaper for the taxpayer to send the experts on a trip to a Third World country to experience real poverty first-hand. I’m sure the experience would change their opinions. It’s time to get tough on welfare dependency so that recipients accept that with assistance comes a responsibility to provide for the necessities of life. The political party that advocates for welfare recipients to be barred from gambling establishments will get my vote.
John Dyer
(Lake Tarawera)


Automated external defibrillators (AEDs) are designed to be used by lay rescuers with little or no experience. In combination with effective cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), early defibrillation increases survival from sudden cardiac arrest. “In for a shock” (December 8) highlighted one survivor’s personal account and is a timely reminder of the value of knowing where to find the nearest AED. With the holiday season upon us, this is the time to visit aedlocations.co.nz and download the app that maps the location of 2400 AEDs around the country.
Bronwyn Tunnage
(Hill Park, Auckland)


Your advocates for “super-efficient” small diesel cars, David Cohen and Gianluca Watson (Letters, December 1 and 8), hope that if “super-efficient” small diesel cars were exempt from road user charges, owners of SUVs would get rid of them – although owners prepared to pay for driving “Ponsonby tractors” would be the last people I’d expect to change to small vehicles. Some owners of small petrol cars may change, though. And the road user charging regime, which charges vehicles by both use and road damage, would seem to be in line with 21st-century values, not the converse.
John Wilson
(Johnsonville, Wellington)


Scott Lelievre (Letters, December 8) expected the Listener to provide more nuanced opinions, more thoughtfulness and more balanced analysis. I was therefore startled to find him defending Fox News, with the implication a viewer might readily find any of those qualities on that channel. He recommends Karl Rove, who is indeed a prominent political analyst. Unfortunately, that didn’t seem to have protected him from wishful thinking descending into delusion, which was nonetheless broadcast as serious commentary on the night of the US elections. He continued arguing the numbers with his own network’s expert analysts long after they unequivocally called the race for Obama, until his co-anchor finally intervened. In a moment that brought unmitigated glee to liberal pundits, she asked him, “Is this the math you do as a Republican to make yourself feel better, or is this real?” Although Fox News’ actual news bulletins are reasonably balanced (as they are required to be), everything else is classed as “commentary”, and can be as distorted as it wants. Fox trots out Rush Limbaugh and Glenn Beck, whose role in life is to take a factoid and stir it, shake it up and stretch it into a whole new thing that is, invariably, “destroying America”. The game is to stir up emotions, polarise people and make rational debate and compromise impossible. Sadly, rational debate and compromise are two foundations of democracy, and actively discouraging them has resulted in an increasingly dysfunctional Government.
Kim Falconer


Marc Wilson is to be applauded for his attempt to explain the activities of psychologists (Psychology, December 15). People need to know what the profession is about because, as Wilson implies, it is very much the coming thing. Probably for space reasons, Wilson referred exclusively to clinical psychology. Qualified psychologists who work with clients with problems of living (rather than mental illnesses) come in a number of other forms, including educational psychologists, counselling psychologists, health psychologists, neuropsychologists, community psychologists and forensic psychologists.
Peter Stanley
PhD, ANZPsS John McGovern MEd, Dip Ed Psych


Good documentaries may be scarce on TV, but Radio NZ recently produced some crackers, including two excellent ones about Timor Leste. Indonesia’s Reluctant Citizens (Ideas, December 9) also covered Indonesia-controlled West Papua, where the oppression, militarisation and human rights abuses are parallel to the Timorese experience before liberation in 1999. Why don’t we know about our Melanesian neighbour West Papua when there are so many stories and travelogues about its neighbour Papua New Guinea? International journalists and humanitarian workers have found it almost impossible to get a work visa to visit, and even the Red Cross has only limited access. Fortunately, as Peter King pointed out on Ideas, Australia’s ABC network recently succeeded in visiting clandestinely and obtaining compelling footage. The journalists highlighted Australia’s role in funding Indonesia’s crack police unit, Detachment 88, and probed the alleged role of this unit in the killing of student leader Mako Tabuni. Supposedly an anti-terror unit, Detachment 88 seems to have been given free rein to terrorise peaceful activists, whom they dub “separatists”. New Zealand, like Australia, barely makes a squeak about the ongoing human rights abuses in West Papua. In the past few years, we have resumed defence ties with Indonesia and offered training in community policing to the police in West Papua. Who knew? However, Indonesian Foreign Minister Marty Natalegawa has just declared that foreign journalists can visit West Papua and he doesn’t mind what they report on. He needs to be taken up on his offer.
Maire Leadbeater
(Mt Albert, Auckland)


Thanks to Peter Griffin for his useful survey of e-readers (Technology, December 15). If space had allowed, he might have mentioned that the price of any book, including e-books, originates with the publisher. He might also have added – especially for people with a concern for local sustainability – that anyone with any e-reader (except a Kindle, of course) can buy any of three million e-books, including New Zealand authors’ work, by checking out their local indie bookshop websites.
Tilly Lloyd
Unity Books
MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage


Te Papa’s tribute a real Dagg
71078 2017-07-27 00:00:00Z Profiles

Te Papa’s tribute a real Dagg

by Russell Baillie

The late John Clarke left some big boots to fill. Now you can go see them at Te Papa.

Read more
Manawatu Gorge: Simon Bridges hints at big bucks alternative
76903 2017-07-27 00:00:00Z Economy

Manawatu Gorge: Simon Bridges hints at big bucks a…

by Pattrick Smellie

Years of avoiding the question of an alternative road appear to be over.

Read more
How to overcome comfort eating
76877 2017-07-27 00:00:00Z Nutrition

How to overcome comfort eating

by Jennifer Bowden

Cutting back on chocolate and other indulgences calls for breaking a vicious cycle of comfort eating. Here’s how.

Read more
Baby Driver's Ansel Elgort on the making of this must-see film
77071 2017-07-26 17:42:03Z Movies

Baby Driver's Ansel Elgort on the making of this m…

by India Hendrikse

Actor Ansel Elgort talks to Paperboy about starring in the hit film Baby Driver, doing stunts, and his contribution to the incredible soundtrack.

Read more
How to stop wasting food: These Aucklanders show us how
77051 2017-07-26 16:04:01Z Social issues

How to stop wasting food: These Aucklanders show u…

by Leisha Jones

Meet some of the Auckland champs turning food destined for the bin into three-course dinners and inventive dishes.

Read more
Jesse Mulligan is giving Mike Hosking a run for his money
77043 2017-07-26 15:40:00Z Profiles

Jesse Mulligan is giving Mike Hosking a run for hi…

by Julie Hill

The Project host talks about government underfunding of DoC, being told to cheer up by Maggie Barry, and wanting to crush Hosking.

Read more
How doco-maker Annie Goldson captured a remarkable portrait of Kim Dotcom
77035 2017-07-26 14:58:08Z Movies

How doco-maker Annie Goldson captured a remarkable…

by Anthony Byrt

Documentary maker Annie Goldson has gone behind the headlines to create a remarkable portrait of Kim Dotcom – the man who changed the way we use the i

Read more
Bill English gives nod to David Seymour and Peter Dunne for electorate votes
77016 2017-07-26 13:04:17Z Politics

Bill English gives nod to David Seymour and Peter …

by Jane Patterson

It's still "party vote National", but the PM says he wants National voters to support the Act leader in Epsom and United Future leader in Ohariu.

Read more