Review: The Phoenix Song by John Sinclair

by Nicholas Reid / 27 November, 2012
Our reviewer’s verdict on this month’s <em>Listener</em> Book Club choice.
The Phoenix Song by John Sinclair

There’s a wonderful image at the beginning of John Sinclair’s The Phoenix Song. In 1950, the father of eight-year-old violin prodigy Xiao Magou suffers a stroke and begins to see things. Xiao’s father is a Communist Party official who should still be basking in the first anniversary of Mao’s victory in the Chinese Civil War. Instead, he sees solid walls where there are open doorways, and his young daughter has to coax him into crossing thresholds. What appears solid to him is not really there.

This is a fair symbol of life in a totalitarian state. What is promoted as reality by the state is a facade of prosperity, progress and revolutionary fervour. It seems as solid as delusions seem to Xiao’s father. Behind it are the unseen, unreported, censored realities. Narrated years later by the adult Xiao, now resident in New Zealand, The Phoenix Song is the story of her life in the first decade of Communist rule in China. It looks at some of these gaps between the facade of propaganda and fearful reality.

Music and politics mesh as Xiao reaches virtuoso status. She lives in a northern town with a substantial Russian minority. This means that flashbacks allow Stalin’s official dictates on music in the Soviet Union to feature as much in the story as Mao’s decrees on music in China. The prose is clear and readable, the descriptions are rich and detailed and (given it follows the arc of history) the storyline is straightforward, for all the deceptions most characters have to practise to survive. In other words, The Phoenix Song makes for a good read over its nearly 400 expansive pages. There are some things on the debit side, though.

As a narrator, Xiao is rather blank and colourless. We never really know how she feels about being made a cultural spy. She sometimes gives historical judgments on events that sound more textbook than personal. There are some grimly funny (albeit historically authentic) sequences, such as a Chinese professor’s denunciation of Debussy’s “bourgeois” music and the burning of the composer’s scores. But there are also moments of History Lite.

When Xiao finds a secret letter from Shostakovich about artistic repression in the USSR, readers are really being given a convenient crash course on the subject. Thus, too, as the action sprints through the Great Leap Forward, the “Hundred Flowers” Movement, the Sino-Soviet Split and the beginnings of the Cultural Revolution, before fading out on a slightly contrived ending.

In The Phoenix Song, you are in the hands of somebody whose narrative drive and grasp of history are impeccable. But the characters themselves could be more developed.

THE PHOENIX SONG, by John Sinclair (VUP, $38).

Nicholas Reid is a writer, poet and historian who blogs about books at Reid’s Reader.

The Listener Book Club is taking a break over summer and will return on February 1.
MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage


The often-windswept Neil Oliver is headed indoors for a live NZ show
85873 2018-01-16 00:00:00Z Culture

The often-windswept Neil Oliver is headed indoors …

by Russell Baillie

Neil Oliver's live shows are based on a prolific career of making the past come alive on television and in print.

Read more
Hilary Barry takes Mike Hosking’s spot on Seven Sharp
85857 2018-01-15 13:40:27Z Television

Hilary Barry takes Mike Hosking’s spot on Seven Sh…

by Katie Parker

Hilary Barry takes over Seven Sharp and ex-Green candidate Hayley Holt replaces her on Breakfast. But not all are happy at the seat shuffling.

Read more
Win a double pass to Molly’s Game
85852 2018-01-15 11:06:05Z Win

Win a double pass to Molly’s Game

by The Listener

The thrilling true story of Molly Bloom, the mastermind behind a poker empire whose players included the rich, famous & most powerful men in America.

Read more
Auckland Harbour Bridge lights will 'change the skyline'
85843 2018-01-15 10:41:09Z Urbanism

Auckland Harbour Bridge lights will 'change the sk…

by Sally Murphy

Work is being done around the clock to install 90,000 solar powered LED lights on the Auckland Harbour Bridge.

Read more
Inside Fukushima’s nuclear ghost towns
85838 2018-01-15 10:01:10Z World

Inside Fukushima’s nuclear ghost towns

by Justin Bennett

Seven years after Japan's devastating tsunami, evacuees from towns around Fukushima's Daiichi nuclear plant have yet to return.

Read more
'Baby brain' is real - but we're still not sure what causes it
85822 2018-01-15 08:52:02Z Health

'Baby brain' is real - but we're still not sure wh…

by Sasha Davies

A new study has found "baby brain" is real, but mums-to-be shouldn't worry - it doesn't make a dramatic impact on daily life.

Read more
Paddington 2 – movie review
85704 2018-01-15 00:00:00Z Movies

Paddington 2 – movie review

by James Robins

Returning to its heartening roots, the sequel to Paddington doesn’t disappoint.

Read more
The long Jewish struggle to find a place of belonging
85756 2018-01-15 00:00:00Z Books

The long Jewish struggle to find a place of belong…

by Ann Beaglehole

Comprehensive and personal, Simon Schama's history of the Jewish people is a rewarding read.

Read more