The New Hate by Arthur Goldwag and Pity the Billionaire by Thomas Frank – review

by Bryan Gould / 03 November, 2012
The Tea Party? It was ever so in American politics.
The New Hate by Arthur Goldwag

When I was a newly elected Labour MP in Britain in 1974, I became aware of a rumour circulated by my opponents that I was not really a New Zealander, but instead a Russian spy who had been landed secretly by a Russian submarine with instructions to penetrate the British political establishment. Far-fetched though this may seem, it is as nothing compared with the flights of malign fancy that are current today in the further reaches of right-wing American fantasy. Arthur Goldwag has made himself something of an expert in such arcane matters, and in The New Hate he piles well-documented and horrifying – sometimes laughable – detail on horrifying detail, showing how extreme and fantastic the beliefs are of even relatively mainstream figures in American public life.

Indeed, so copious are the examples he cites that, after what seem to be thousands of instances of statements that in a normal society would qualify the speakers for free psychotherapy, he almost loses the power to shock. And that, indeed, is the main weakness of the book. He succeeds all too well in convincing the reader there is a serious degree of “fear and loathing” rampant in US public discourse. What is lacking is any real attempt to examine why. Where does such hatred, manifesting itself in such bizarre ways, come from? Is it a peculiarly American phenomenon (at least on this scale), and if so, why? What, if anything, can be done to correct or counteract it? What Goldwag does instead is, I suppose, in its own way reassuring.

Having laid bare the “birthers”, the “truthers”, those who oppose health care reforms on the grounds they will establish “death panels”, and other weird distortions of current American politics, he then shows these don’t really break new ground. They have a long, rich and dishonourable history, which he demonstrates by considering phenomena such as the John Birch Society, McCarthyism, the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, and many others – a veritable catalogue of the prejudice and hatreds that have disfigured American society over a long period. One can only despair.

Thomas Frank’s Pity the Billionaire deals with a related but quite different phenomenon – the success of the extreme right in America – against all the odds, one would have thought – in turning the global financial crisis and the failure of the free market to political advantage. He is, of course, right to marvel at this achievement; it is astonishing that at a time when public opinion might have been expected to revolt against the manifest failure of the unregulated market, many Americans have been persuaded the private entrepreneur is the victim and the regulator the criminal. Frank goes beyond simply documenting that this has happened. He is skilled at analysing the arguments, techniques and tricks that have been used to bring this about. He lays bare the paranoia and ignorance, but also the skill, ruthlessness and deep understanding of human weakness demonstrated by those who have manipulated opinion so successfully. He is particularly good at describing how those who hold extreme beliefs on the basis of prejudice rather than fact can insulate themselves against any information that might contradict their views.

The book is short and can be easily read in a single sitting, but it is packed full of careful analysis and penetrating insight. If knowing your enemy is the first step in a successful campaign, this is a highly recommended first port of call. It is perhaps no accident that several of those prominent in interpreting events to the American public appear frequently as significant figures in both these books. Glenn Beck and Rush Limbaugh, for example, may not mean much to New Zealand readers, but they are prime examples of the hugely influential commentators who, through their radio and television shows, fan the distortions and hatreds that shape large swathes of American opinion. At a time when the Murdoch media empire has been in the spotlight, it is salutary to realise that – quite apart from phone-hacking scandals and the manipulation of politicians – a malign influence can be exercised by a Murdoch-owned Fox News, as these books demonstrate, through constantly feeding a distorted view of events to a gullible public.

We are not immune in New Zealand from such concerns. Not so long ago, a former editor of the Dominion Post advised his column readers that I had, after a political career in Britain, chosen to advance my views in New Zealand rather than North Korea, which would (by implication) have been a more suitable choice. A trivial example, but surely we don’t have to go down the American road, and can expect better than this?


Bryan Gould is a former vice-chancellor of Waikato University.
MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage


Politicians aren’t talking to us this election year, but to Winston Peters
71902 2017-04-28 14:08:09Z Politics

Politicians aren’t talking to us this election yea…

by Jane Clifton

We don't want any David Cunliffe cod-bogan attempts to get down with the peeps, but MPs seem to be going way too far in the other direction this year.

Read more
9th Floor: Jenny Shipley on how 'middle class welfare' is morally bankrupt
71856 2017-04-28 09:53:00Z Politics

9th Floor: Jenny Shipley on how 'middle class welf…

by Guyon Espiner

Dame Jenny Shipley on being the first woman Prime Minister, plus coups and coalitions, welfare reform and Winston Peters.

Read more
Win a double pass to exclusive screening of McLaren
71854 2017-04-28 09:39:24Z Win

Win a double pass to exclusive screening of McLare…

by The Listener

McLaren is the definitive tale of New Zealander Bruce McLaren, who created a motor racing empire from his shed.

Read more
Win a double pass to Doc Edge Festival
71847 2017-04-28 09:30:01Z Win

Win a double pass to Doc Edge Festival

by The Listener

Doc Edge Festival is one of Australasia’s premier international documentary film festivals.

Read more
First look: Poké Poké
Health Minister dismisses chocolate fundraiser ban
71842 2017-04-28 09:07:08Z Nutrition

Health Minister dismisses chocolate fundraiser ban…

by RNZ

Should schools be selling chocolate to raise funds? The Health Minister says it's ok, but nutrition experts disagree.

Read more
Film review: Denial
71718 2017-04-28 00:00:00Z Movies

Film review: Denial

by Peter Calder

The dramatisation of a Holocaust denier’s libel suit is both engrossing and moving.

Read more
Danish dramas versus Kiwi soaps
71634 2017-04-28 00:00:00Z Television

Danish dramas versus Kiwi soaps

by Jeremy Rose

A quarter of Denmark's population regularly watch Danish TV dramas, while the highest-rating Kiwi drama attracted an audience of just over 250,000.

Read more