Toby’s Room by Pat Barker – review

by Marion McLeod / 24 November, 2012
Harold Gillies is just one of the historical figures in Pat Barker’s return to her métier of World War I.
Toby's Room by Pat Barker

Toby’s Room is a sort of sequel to Pat Barker’s previous novel, Life Class. Sort of, because although many characters reappear, this second book opens in 1912, two years earlier than Life Class, and then leapfrogs to 1917. Both books begin in civvy street and move to the front line. And both come alive there after somewhat creaky beginnings. World War I is undoubtedly Barker’s métier. This time a young woman takes centre-stage; much of the narrative consists of her letters and diary entries. Elinor Brooke (the surname surely more than coincidental) is a student at the Slade. In addition, she undertakes drawings in the dissecting room of a London medical school, under the tutelage of Professor Henry Tonks, the real-life surgeon turned artist and teacher.

His contribution to the war effort is to produce portraits of injured soldiers undergoing plastic surgery. As usual, Barker mixes historical figures with fictional. Our very own Harold Gillies appears: “Odd chap, looks a bit like a bloodhound. New Zealander. He calls the patients ‘honey’ and ‘my dear’ and sits on the beds.” He is also the best otolaryngologist (head and neck surgeon) in the world.

Elinor visits Queen Mary Hospital at Sidcup to see his pioneering work, creating hoses of transplanted flesh from which to fashion noses on blown-away faces, for instance. Joseph Merrick, the Elephant Man – Tonks knew him – has a cameo role. Elinor also visits Virginia Woolf and her sister Vanessa at Charleston. At dinner, the talk is of war and of the prospects for the conscientious objectors working on their land. The episode, admittedly a diary entry, is rather stilted, as if included to make a point. Nevertheless, Barker’s echo of Woolf’s title suggests a kind of homage. Jacob’s Room is an elegy for Woolf’s adored older brother Thoby. Toby’s Room is also an elegy: Elinor loses her beloved older brother Toby – rather too beloved, given their sexual relationship (revealed very early on).

It’s Elinor’s quest that fuels the novel. “Missing Believed Killed”, says the telegram, but what does that mean? She is desperate to know more and we, the readers, come to share her need for the truth. Along the way, Barker addresses questions about war, its disciplines, its casualties. She considers the responsibility of artists in wartime. But what she does best, as always, is recreate in visceral detail the horror of the trenches and the equal horror of the wounded survivors. With a bit of luck, she may be working on a third volume to make this a trilogy.

TOBY’S ROOM, by Pat Barker (Hamish Hamilton, $37).

Marion McLeod is a Wellington reviewer.
MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage


Why it's time for a female Doctor Who
77083 2017-07-27 09:12:33Z Social issues

Why it's time for a female Doctor Who

by The Listener

Gender equality is lamentably slow-dawning in many endeavours, but TV and film help normalise desirable social trends. However it does cuts both ways.

Read more
Five great places in Auckland for gluten-free eats
77081 2017-07-27 09:09:05Z Auckland Eats

Five great places in Auckland for gluten-free eats…

by Paperboy

Auckland has a whole swag of places where you can eat well gluten-free - here are five of the best.

Read more
Te Papa’s tribute a real Dagg
71078 2017-07-27 00:00:00Z Profiles

Te Papa’s tribute a real Dagg

by Russell Baillie

The late John Clarke left some big boots to fill. Now you can go see them at Te Papa.

Read more
Manawatu Gorge: Simon Bridges hints at big bucks alternative
76903 2017-07-27 00:00:00Z Economy

Manawatu Gorge: Simon Bridges hints at big bucks a…

by Pattrick Smellie

Years of avoiding the question of an alternative road appear to be over.

Read more
How to overcome comfort eating
76877 2017-07-27 00:00:00Z Nutrition

How to overcome comfort eating

by Jennifer Bowden

Cutting back on chocolate and other indulgences calls for breaking a vicious cycle of comfort eating. Here’s how.

Read more
Baby Driver's Ansel Elgort on the making of this must-see film
77071 2017-07-26 17:42:03Z Movies

Baby Driver's Ansel Elgort on the making of this m…

by India Hendrikse

Actor Ansel Elgort talks to Paperboy about starring in the hit film Baby Driver, doing stunts, and his contribution to the incredible soundtrack.

Read more
How to stop wasting food: These Aucklanders show us how
77051 2017-07-26 16:04:01Z Social issues

How to stop wasting food: These Aucklanders show u…

by Leisha Jones

Meet some of the Auckland champs turning food destined for the bin into three-course dinners and inventive dishes.

Read more
Jesse Mulligan is giving Mike Hosking a run for his money
77043 2017-07-26 15:40:00Z Profiles

Jesse Mulligan is giving Mike Hosking a run for hi…

by Julie Hill

The Project host talks about government underfunding of DoC, being told to cheer up by Maggie Barry, and wanting to crush Hosking.

Read more