Editorial: Teach your children well

by The Listener / 21 February, 2013
Although the process has been mismanaged, Christchurch schools do need to change, and grandstanding won’t help.
Hekia Parata
Hekia Parata: underperforming, photo/Getty Images.


The decision-making process around Canterbury’s quake-affected schools has been badly handled – and not just by the Government and officials. There has been a slew of inequities and non sequiturs, pitiful research and poor communication. Even now, the Government acknowledges it might have to further readjust the balance of closures and mergers.

But unless Cantabrians can find it in themselves to rule a line under decisions once they are finalised in the coming months, they risk creating a damaging division with other New Zealanders and undermining their own children’s sense of confidence and security.

This is a time for leadership, and although that displayed by the Government has at times been lamentable, the most important leaders in this process are parents and teachers. The sight of children, some too young even to attend school, being slung with protest signs and paraded for the media, while their parents and even senior teachers bellow raucously at cameras and fail to restrain their sobs, is not likely to engender much sympathy.

Strong advocacy to keep one’s school open is laudable, and this process has been a heartening demonstration of how deeply many people value their children’s schools. However, some teachers appear to be putting political and employment considerations ahead of their young students’ welfare. Some parents, too, have imbued youngsters with an undue sense of insecurity, even while proclaiming their desire to spare their children stress.

Having to change schools is something many children face, sometimes repeatedly, when their parents move to follow jobs. It need not be a trauma or even marginally damaging. Indeed, with positive support, it can help build a confidence and resilience that will stand youngsters in good stead, especially in a modern workplace that requires flexibility and an ability to welcome challenges. In this case, no child is changing schools alone. But if parents and teachers continue to frame the experience as a catastrophe and an injustice, it surely will be traumatic.

It’s undeniable that Canterbury children have faced the kind of stress few others – in this country, at least – have had to cope with, in the destruction of much of their city, including often their own homes. It’s also understandable that the continuity of normal life that schools provide has been of enormous benefit.

But in a region that has consequently undergone large population shifts and faced irremediable new geographical strictures, it would be irresponsible were the Government not to reconfigure its education services.

As with other projects in the sector, this one has found the Ministry of Education flat-footed and slapdash. The property reports on which the first round of interim decisions were made contained obvious errors. The Government’s failure to handle the process with tact, even by the most basic expedient of having Education Minister Hekia Parata personally visit the likely affected schools early in the process, has beggared belief.

It is also beyond unfortunate that the provisional announcement specified that twice as many schools would be affected as is now likely. That created needless stress, and possibly simply for tactical reasons. Politicians often portend a bleaker outcome than they secretly intend, in order to look merciful and willing to compromise later.

Prime Minister John Key’s mulish retention of the under-performing Parata, who has become a lightning rod for National’s unpopularity, was also irresponsible in this context. Her haughty, unapologetic figureheading of this exercise, among others, has added political fury to genuine local pain. Parents and teachers who already oppose National have found it irresistible to catastrophise this issue in a way they might have resisted given a more sympathetic salesperson.

The most important responsibility remains with parents and teachers to strive to make the schools’ changes succeed, however flawed or unfair they might consider the plan.

Being prepared, as at least one principal was, to announce his school’s fate, whatever it was to be, in front of live TV cameras, suggests an appetite for political publicity has begun to supersede the duty to avoid panicking and upsetting children and parents. This is not a time for grandstanding.

Canterbury is a special case, even in an economy where most people are having to make sacrifices and many endure undeserved hardship. But more teacher weeping and toddler protesting won’t obviate the need for some upheaval for schools in Christchurch – it will simply sap much-needed empathy.
MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage

Latest

The troubling rise of Australia's new Attorney-General
85835 2018-01-17 00:00:00Z World

The troubling rise of Australia's new Attorney-Gen…

by Bernard Lagan

The relatively young Australian Attorney-General Christian Porter has a track record in law and order that unsettles many.

Read more
The film-maker who risked death by sugar is fighting fit again
85890 2018-01-17 00:00:00Z Health

The film-maker who risked death by sugar is fighti…

by Nicky Pellegrino

For his documentary That Sugar Film, Damon Gameau consumed 40 teaspoons of the sweet stuff a day.

Read more
Auckland's best cafes 2018
84457 2018-01-17 00:00:00Z Dining

Auckland's best cafes 2018

by Metro

A swarm of new entrants elbow their way onto Metro's annual list of outstanding places for coffee and so much more.

Read more
Does anyone really know how to cut the number of deaths on our roads?
85708 2018-01-16 00:00:00Z Social issues

Does anyone really know how to cut the number of d…

by The Listener

The road toll for 2017 was 380 – 53 more than for 2016 and the highest figure since 2009.

Read more
How trauma incident data can be used to prevent future injuries
85876 2018-01-16 00:00:00Z Social issues

How trauma incident data can be used to prevent fu…

by Donna Chisholm

On a map are hundreds of brightly coloured dots, each colour signifying a type of incident: red for assault, cyan for motorbike crashes.

Read more
Donald Trump appears to have the wits of Homer Simpson
85895 2018-01-16 00:00:00Z World

Donald Trump appears to have the wits of Homer Sim…

by Bill Ralston

Trump may be “stable” and “smart”, but Americans need to decide whether to fire their leader.

Read more
The often-windswept Neil Oliver is headed indoors for a live NZ show
85873 2018-01-16 00:00:00Z Culture

The often-windswept Neil Oliver is headed indoors …

by Russell Baillie

Neil Oliver's live shows are based on a prolific career of making the past come alive on television and in print.

Read more
Hilary Barry takes Mike Hosking’s spot on Seven Sharp
85857 2018-01-15 13:40:27Z Television

Hilary Barry takes Mike Hosking’s spot on Seven Sh…

by Katie Parker

Hilary Barry takes over Seven Sharp and ex-Green candidate Hayley Holt replaces her on Breakfast. But not all are happy at the seat shuffling.

Read more