Film review: Toni Erdmann

by James Robins / 18 March, 2017
Toni Erdmann: languid and preposterous.

A three-hour German comedy veers from implausible to cruel.

To sit through almost three hours of ordinary German comedy calls for an appetite for irony and paradox and a firm grip on sanity, not to mention buttocks of steel. Toni Erdmann, a shock hit at Cannes last year and a ­nominee for the Foreign Language Film Oscar, tests these qualities to the limit.

The picture follows Winfried Conradi (Peter Simonischek), an unreconstructed hippie and prankster, who, when we meet him, is teasing with the postman. “I like to practise defusing bombs,” he deadpans, relishing the courier’s look of dismay. If this amuses, lap it up. It’s the most straightforward joke you’ll get.

Seeking solace after his dog dies, Winfried tracks down his semi-estranged daughter Ines (Sandra Hüller), a corporate consultant posted to Bucharest, where she is helping fire oil workers.

In protest at her coldness, he dons an extravagant wig, a sharkskin suit and a set of false teeth apparently pinched from The Pogues’ Shane MacGowan, and begins showing up at Ines’ work functions masquerading as a tycoon and, later, as a “life coach” whose name gives the film its title.

At first, these impersonations are playful. We watch on, mildly amused, noting the sly grin Winfried occasionally lets slip. But as the parodies become ever more implausible, his efforts to connect with his daughter take on an edge of cruelty.

Toni Erdmann is a defiantly bewildering film of apocalyptic misunderstandings and excruciating encounters, including a nudist birthday party and an impromptu version of Whitney Houston’s Greatest Love of All.

Most of us will spend most of its 162 minutes squirming in our seats and gasping in shocked laughter as each languid and increasingly preposterous scene unfolds. But the humour is so dry as to be combustible and some sequences pass without even a hint of a gag. Who really wants to be lectured about ­Romanian middle-management business philosophy?

To cut a full 90 minutes from the movie would make sense comedically, and yet the slouching gives you time to think: is Winfried trying to rescue Ines or destroy her? Is this an absurdist satire or a character study of breakdown and psychosis?

Some viewers have found a degree of tenderness and resolution in the film, but I found only loss and loneliness, and fragmented lives that can never be repaired. The bitter twist of Toni Erdmann is that it’s all rather tragic. ••

IN CINEMAS NOW

This article was first published in the March 4, 2017 issue of the New Zealand Listener. Follow the Listener on Twitter, Facebook and sign up to the weekly newsletter.

MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage

Latest

'Your daughter is history': Dirty deeds done in the Dome
73773 2017-05-28 00:00:00Z Crime

'Your daughter is history': Dirty deeds done in th…

by Susan Strongman

A 19-year-old woman is left for dead in Dome valley.

Read more
The crushing workload of those on the frontlines of health
70348 2017-05-28 00:00:00Z Social issues

The crushing workload of those on the frontlines o…

by Jenny Nicholls

Athena Drummond hates the term “junior doctor”. It implies she is inexperienced, with “limited responsibility”. We think she has a point.

Read more
Billions of dollars of arms to Saudi Arabia? What a great idea
73761 2017-05-28 00:00:00Z World

Billions of dollars of arms to Saudi Arabia? What …

by Joanne Black

The only times Trump’s presidency has not depressed me are those occasions when I have thought I was reading satire and laughed at its cleverness.

Read more
The Girl on the Train author changes tracks
73654 2017-05-28 00:00:00Z Profiles

The Girl on the Train author changes tracks

by Michele Hewitson

Zimbabwe-born Brit Paula Hawkins turned culture shock into a runaway bestseller with The Girl on the Train. Can she repeat this with Into the Water?

Read more
Why director Gurinder Chadha tackled modern India’s brutal beginnings
73652 2017-05-28 00:00:00Z Movies

Why director Gurinder Chadha tackled modern India’…

by James Robins

Best-known for her film Bend it Like Beckham, Chadha has focused on the mass displacement that happened when the British abandoned India.

Read more
How social media can help reform your eating habits
73637 2017-05-28 00:00:00Z Nutrition

How social media can help reform your eating habit…

by Jennifer Bowden

With users and recipes by the millions, it's not surprising what social media can do.

Read more
How New Zealand police compare: firearms, tasers, pursuits and dogs
Pirates of the Caribbean 5: There be some good science in that there film
73598 2017-05-27 00:00:00Z Science

Pirates of the Caribbean 5: There be some good sci…

by The Conversation

Ever wondered how accurate the film you're watching really is? Michael Milford got to work on the latest Pirates of the Caribbean offering.

Read more