The Dinner – movie review

by James Robins / 12 August, 2017
RelatedArticlesModule - The dinner

Paul (Steve Coogan) and Stan (Richard Gere) in The Dinner.

A drama of in-laws debating whether to dob in errant sons makes a meal of it.

At the heart of The Dinner is a knotty moral conundrum. Two teenagers have done something terrible to a homeless woman. One is the son of modest middle-class couple Paul (Steve Coogan) and Claire (Laura Linney). The father of the other boy is Paul’s brother Stan (Richard Gere), a silver-haired congressman in the middle of an election campaign for governor, who is married to the glamorous Katelyn (Rebecca Hall).

The couples meet at a restaurant to discuss how to deal with their wayward, potentially criminal kids. Protect them? Or turn them in?

A parley under similar circumstances was at the heart of Roman Polanski’s Carnage – a taut four-way tangle in which the veneer of civility quickly slipped as the parents battled their respective corners, the audience’s allegiance shifting with each new revelation. If only The Dinner had been as efficient and clever. Instead, it’s a mess, with the participants constantly getting up from the table, knocking over wine glasses and being rude to the maître d’.

Unfocused and wayward, the film dips into inert flashbacks and long digressions, including a complete retelling of the Battle of Gettysburg. There is the suggestion that this odd tangent is supposed to illustrate Paul’s agitated, obsessive mental state, but mostly it feels incongruous.

Director Oren Moverman packs his adaptation of Herman Koch’s novel with clichés and actorly shouting matches resolved with mock platitudes. And the conjecture about Stan’s adopted black son veers uncomfortably close to racism. One can only dream about what such writers as Aaron Sorkin or David Mamet might have done with the material.

Worst of all, the tension is never wound tight enough. So when the final reveal comes, it’s nowhere near as explosive as it ought to be. I’d advise leaving before the aperitif.

IN CINEMAS NOW

★1/2

This article was first published in the August 12, 2017 issue of the New Zealand Listener.

MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage

Latest

NZME-Stuff media merger saga goes to court
81581 2017-10-16 12:54:33Z Business

NZME-Stuff media merger saga goes to court

by Colin Peacock

New Zealand's two biggest publishers of news go to court today to try to overturn the competition watchdog's refusal to green-light a merger.

Read more
The living hell experienced by Rohingya Muslims
81556 2017-10-16 11:02:05Z World

The living hell experienced by Rohingya Muslims

by Kate White

Kate White, a co-ordinator with Médecins Sans Frontières, describes daily life for Rohingya who have fled to Bangladesh - and how you can help.

Read more
Why some people get wheezy when peeling potatoes
81550 2017-10-16 10:31:13Z Nutrition

Why some people get wheezy when peeling potatoes

by Jennifer Bowden

As if living with hay fever isn’t enough, many people with oral allergy syndrome also react to certain foods.

Read more
I almost punched a man in front of the Mona Lisa in the Louvre
81545 2017-10-16 10:11:56Z Travel

I almost punched a man in front of the Mona Lisa i…

by Joanne Black

It was hard to raise a smile at the Mona Lisa, but the rest of the Louvre more than made up for it.

Read more
Is New Zealand turning away from the welfare state?
81539 2017-10-16 07:37:07Z Social issues

Is New Zealand turning away from the welfare state…

by Philippa Tolley

MSD says its mission is to help people look after themselves - so why are there so many complaints about its lack of humanity?

Read more
Dunedin city councillors question $980k payout to power company CEO
81536 2017-10-16 07:20:46Z Business

Dunedin city councillors question $980k payout to …

by Emile Donovan

Grady Cameron received a $980,000 payout after resigning from his position, but the makeup of the payment is confidential.

Read more
How the toxicity of Twitter drove Duncan Garner and Sean Plunket away
81532 2017-10-16 06:43:06Z Social issues

How the toxicity of Twitter drove Duncan Garner an…

by Colin Peacock

Sean Plunket says Twitter brings out the worst in people - including himself.

Read more
Urewera raid pair Tame Iti and Rangikaiwhiria Kemara seek pardon
81529 2017-10-16 06:29:20Z History

Urewera raid pair Tame Iti and Rangikaiwhiria Kema…

by Mihingarangi Forbes

It's 10 years since Tame Iti and Rangikaiwhiria Kemara were jailed on firearms convictions, but it's the 'terrorist' label that haunts them.

Read more