Prison inspector: Guards' delay after attack at jail 'unacceptable'

by Phil Pennington / 19 May, 2017
Mt Eden prison Photo: RNZ / Diego Opatowski

Inmate's attacker walked around the prison for two hours, as his victim lay critically injured in his cell.

Guards who could not rouse a prison inmate lying near death in his cell following a brutal attack then sat filing paperwork and eating sandwiches for 20 minutes, a prison inspector's report says.

The full extent of the failings that endangered inmate Benjamin Lightbody in May 2013 have been revealed in a prison inspector's investigation of Mt Eden remand jail, which was run by Serco at the time.

Mr Lightbody suffered extensive brain damage in the attack and plans to sue Corrections for failing to keep him safe.

The report, which Mr Lightbody received under the Privacy Act and passed on to RNZ, shows an ambulance was not called until more than two-and-a-half hours after the unprovoked attack.

It said he was in the gym yard when an inmate with a pool ball in his fist smashed him in the side of his head because he would not hand over nicotine patches.

The inspector found other inmates witnessed the attack, but did not help, and no guard came.

Mr Lightbody eventually staggered to his cell and collapsed on his bed.

Nearly two hours later an inmate posted a note to the guards' glassed-in base, saying, "Newbie in cell 4 knocked out by cell 5. I told you this would happen!"

A guard then checked on Mr Lightbody and found him totally unresponsive despite shaking him and shouting at him.

Both guards did nothing else initially. They sat at their base for 20 minutes, with one continuing to file while the other made himself a hot drink and ate a sandwich.

During this time, the prison wing's manager and supervisor left the unit. The supervisor told the guards that he was off for the next week and that it was up to them to "sort it out", the report said.

The supervisor denied being told of the assault.

Nurses were finally called, but the first arrived without an emergency first aid kit.

An ambulance was eventually called at 5.02pm, more than 2 hours 30 minutes after the attack, arriving 11 minutes later.

Benjamin Lightbody in hospital after the attack in Mt Eden prison in 2013. Photo/ Twitter >

The chief inspector said the delay in calling an ambulance was "excessive", "unacceptable" and "unexplained".

The report also revealed Mr Lightbody had told guards just before the attack that he had been threatened, but they did nothing about it.

The attacker was also free to walk around the prison for more than two hours afterwards, as his victim lay in his cell. He was later convicted and received extra prison time.

The report said a root cause of the attack was understaffing.

Usually only two guards were on duty in the wing and an officer told the inspector that staff "felt very unsafe" in such small numbers.

The inspector listed a stack of failures, including poor record keeping, poor risk assessments - which meant seriously violent prisoners were kept in units they should not have been - and inadequate medical care.

Mr Lightbody said Corrections and Serco had both told him this report did not exist - something Corrections disputed.

The department now faces legal action from the Office of Human Rights Proceedings for failing to give Mr Lightbody a video of the attack.

The chief inspector recommended an employment investigation of guards and the supervisor. A member of staff was dismissed.

Corrections said it withheld $160,000 dollars from Serco in the 2012/13 financial year for missing targets.

However, the department continued to rank Mt Eden as exceptional in its prison performance measures when the jail was under scrutiny over the safety of inmates and staff. These ratings were later overhauled.

Serco lost its contract to run Mt Eden after fight clubs at the prison were revealed, and resisting attempts by Corrections to improve poor supervision and understaffing.

It runs South Auckland prison, which Corrections recently ranked one of the worst performing prisons.

 

This article was originally published by RNZ.

MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage

Latest

When Sir Bob Jones met Muhammad Ali
81845 2017-10-23 00:00:00Z Books

When Sir Bob Jones met Muhammad Ali

by Bob Jones

A new biography finds fault with the legendary fighter, but praise wins by a mile.

Read more
Announcing the finalists of the NZ Craft Awards 2017
81876 2017-10-23 00:00:00Z Culture

Announcing the finalists of the NZ Craft Awards 20…

by NZTV Craft Awards

The finalists of the New Zealand Craft Awards have been announced and here is the complete list.

Read more
Hand, foot and mouth disease is not nearly as scary it seems
81868 2017-10-23 00:00:00Z Health

Hand, foot and mouth disease is not nearly as scar…

by Ruth Nichol

It sounds alarmingly like foot and mouth disease, but all they have in common is they are viral.

Read more
What to do in Auckland if you're a local who wants the tourist experience
81902 2017-10-23 00:00:00Z Travel

What to do in Auckland if you're a local who wants…

by Pamela Wade

After living in Auckland for almost 25 years, Pamela Wade decides to reacquaint herself with the city where she still feels like a stranger.

Read more
The Lesley Calvert cold case: 40 years of torment
80160 2017-10-22 00:00:00Z Crime

The Lesley Calvert cold case: 40 years of torment

by Chris Birt

The mum-of-three was found on a hillside in sight of her farmhouse where she'd disappeared 7 months earlier. Suspicions swirled, but no answers found.

Read more
When I went to Rimutaka Prison for a three-course meal
81858 2017-10-22 00:00:00Z Food

When I went to Rimutaka Prison for a three-course …

by Lauraine Jacobs

A three-course meal inside prison walls proves a rewarding experience for food columnist Lauraine Jacobs.

Read more
The Lundy murders: Inside the case that gripped the nation for 17 years
81945 2017-10-21 07:23:00Z Crime

The Lundy murders: Inside the case that gripped th…

by Anne Marie May

A court reporter who's covered both of Mark Lundy's High Court trials looks at how the case has evolved, as the Court of Appeal deliberates his fate.

Read more
The Weinstein scandal is no surprise to this prominent NZ employment lawyer
81809 2017-10-21 00:00:00Z Social issues

The Weinstein scandal is no surprise to this promi…

by Mai Chen

In 25 years of law practice, Mai Chen has helped many women – very often senior employees – who have suffered from sexual harassment.

Read more