The Jack-Jacinda interview was the silliest ever done on TV – believe meby Bill Ralston
There were lessons for both interviewer and interviewee in an absurd Breakfast TV encounter.
Still, according to the New Zealand Herald, a paper always keen to put the boot into its TV rivals, there were many complaints about the interview on social media, although, to be fair, social media is always bulging at the seams with outrage over a multitude of issues. I recently saw one Twitter user bitterly protesting that on TV news Labour Cabinet ministers’ comments were then followed by comments from National politicians. How dare they do that?
For her part, Jacinda seemed unfazed by young Jack’s attempt at a grilling. Beaming widely, she repeatedly explained that, although she was unaware of it, someone at the conference gathering thought Trump had mistaken her for Mrs Trudeau and she now regretted telling this story to a comedian backstage at the New Zealand Music Awards. The interview went in ever-decreasing “he said, she said” circles, with Jack and Jacinda sounding like a pair of bickering teenagers.
Of course, the Prime Minister is still on a steep learning curve. Repeating what may have been said in a closed session at a conference of world leaders is not a good idea. Taking the proverbial out of the leader of the free world is definitely a bad move, especially when that person is as barking mad as Trump. Regaling a comedian “mate” with the story backstage at an awards ceremony is certainly a mistake. Spending six minutes of a live TV interview endlessly reprising the mistake is a diplomatic boo-boo.
The tale quickly found its way to the Washington Post, the Guardian, the Independent, the Australian, the BBC, Bangladesh’s Dhaka Tribune and possibly everywhere in between. Thankfully, Trump doesn’t believe anything he reads in the “fake news” media, but if his dumped strategist, Steve Bannon, blogs about it, we should prepare to be nuked.
Jacinda (note how quickly we’ve all become on first-name terms with our Prime Minister) needs to look to her predecessors for lessons in how to shut down a persistent questioner.
Helen Clark, John Key and Bill English all knew how to freeze an interviewer into silence. Tortuously responding to a repeated line of enquiry, all the while adding more juicy gossip to the story, is not how it’s done.
I think most people will agree that Jacinda is “nice”. The only interviewer I can recall her being even slightly rude to was Three’s AM Show co-host Mark Richardson, who questioned the newly appointed Labour leader about her baby plans, but everyone is justifiably rude to him.
I am afraid you cannot be a nice world leader. None of them are. Jacinda needs to take lessons from Winston Peters, who for decades has been superbly, scathingly rude to journalists. If she ever ventures back into the minefield of morning television, she should take Peters’ famous black and white “NO” sign and brandish it at any interviewer impertinent enough to ask her something.
One thing for sure is that Tame’s interview will have boosted TVNZ 1’s Breakfast’s ratings. The only worry is what that will provoke from his AM Show rivals Richardson and offsider Duncan Garner.
This article was first published in the December 2, 2017 issue of the New Zealand Listener.
Paul Thomas has chronicled the Trump presidency since its beginning and reviews the extraordinary year since The Donald entered the White House.Read more
But it’s no less entertaining.Read more
Cervical-cancer screening tests have been helping to save lives for more than 25 years. Now the focus of the tests is going to change.Read more
Act leader David Seymour says he was surprised so many MPs supported his bill to legalise euthanasia. It'll now go to select committee.Read more