Why you should crisis-proof your vote

by The Listener / 08 September, 2017
RelatedArticlesModule - Politics editorial

Photo/Getty Images

Voters should consider not only the promises made in the current buoyant economy, but the ability of each party to handle a crisis or downturn.

Whoever becomes Prime Minister this month – or next month, depending on the vagaries of MMP’s mechanics and potential negotiations – will inherit an economy with statistics that would be the envy of many world leaders. New Zealand is in a much better and more stable position than at the height of the global financial crisis, when finance companies were toppling and alarmists were suggesting – with barely suppressed glee – that we were witnessing the death throes of capitalism. As is so often the way, its demise was greatly exaggerated.

Job growth and wages are now increasing in a country that has enjoyed some of the best GDP and employment growth in the Western world in the past five years. Unemployment and inflation have held steady at low levels, at least by historical standards. Interest rates are close to a 50-year low, meaning a family with a $300,000 mortgage are now paying about $300 a week less in interest than a decade ago. And, importantly, with the economy back in surplus, our political parties can make spending promises to address the concerns over housing, health and education that are rightly a focus.

It can seem an impossible task, however, to assess the best policies to deal with difficult social and economic issues. The Financial Times is fond, at election time, of quoting US journalist and cultural critic HL Mencken: “For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple and wrong.”

And yet, even before a vote is cast, one of the great advantages of a close race such as we are seeing is that the parties themselves quickly focus on solutions to those complex problems. They have already come close, for example, to agreeing on a target to lift children out of poverty. That alone is a victory for democracy.

But sometimes what counts most is not the difference between the two sides’ policies in the lead-up to an election, but their approach once in Government as things come up issue by issue. That’s where, New Zealanders presume, National’s instinct is more on the side of free enterprise and personal responsibility and Labour’s is on organised labour and state intervention. What really puts parties to the test is the way they apply those instincts to unforeseen issues – New Zealand was caught unawares not only by the global financial crisis but also the commodity price collapse of 2014.

Our economy was robust enough to withstand the shock. We did not go into recession. The National Government’s economic management deserves some of the credit for the country’s economic recovery and stability over the past nine years, but growth has also been based partly on population increases caused by more immigrants arriving and fewer New Zealanders leaving. There is also, simply put, a cyclical factor in economics: economies expand and they contract and the greatest potential that a government has is to make things worse, rather than better.

Consequently, when New Zealanders vote on September 23, they should consider not only the promises being made in the current buoyant economy, but the ability of various parties to handle a downturn and a crisis. Nothing is surer than that both will come.

It seems unlikely, however, that we will experience the “buyer’s remorse” of voters in Britain’s Brexit referendum, and in the US and French presidential elections. There, voters seem to have been beguiled and focused too little on what their choices would mean in practice. In the US presidential election, Donald Trump pledged to “Make America great again”. Yet as President he has arguably accelerated America’s decline in influence.

In Brexit, it seems all too obvious in retrospect that the single word “leave” could not begin to encompass the pain of disentanglement from the EU. The existential shock to the economy is now making Britain poorer. Meanwhile, in France, the photogenic President Emmanuel Macron, elected in a landslide four months ago, now has a dissatisfaction rating of 57%.

None of these situations is directly comparable to New Zealand’s. Yet each is a salutary reminder that the small, individual act of voting has real consequences. Plato warned us centuries ago that one of the penalties for refusing to participate in politics is that we end up being governed by those we don’t respect. Our choice – a far more positive one than in most nations – is now.

This editorial was first published in the September 16, 2017 issue of the New Zealand Listener.

MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage

Latest

The rise of the social enterprise
83384 2017-11-21 00:00:00Z Business

The rise of the social enterprise

by Sally Blundell

A new breed of business, the social enterprise, is more intent on benefiting the community and protecting the environment than on maximising profit.

Read more
Best for who? The pressure on school leavers to choose university
83358 2017-11-20 15:22:07Z Education

Best for who? The pressure on school leavers to ch…

by Nicole Barratt

Thousands of school leavers will make big decisions this month, but a pressure brewing for years has skewed the decision-making process for some.

Read more
Dominatrix: The Renee Chignell story
83339 2017-11-20 12:58:50Z Crime

Dominatrix: The Renee Chignell story

by Donna Chisholm

Former teen dominatrix Renée Chignell was once NZ's most infamous woman. She talked to Metro in 2009 about one of the country's most notorious murders

Read more
Drugs in small town NZ: 'It's easier to get meth than cannabis'
83326 2017-11-20 11:23:30Z Crime

Drugs in small town NZ: 'It's easier to get meth t…

by Tim Brown

Meth is no longer a big city problem. Otago's sleepy Clutha District is awash with the drug - but there aren't enough addiction services to help.

Read more
Rebecca Gibney’s thriller Wanted is heading for our hills
83324 2017-11-20 11:19:10Z Books

Rebecca Gibney’s thriller Wanted is heading for ou…

by Russell Baillie

The second season of Wanted comes to NZ as the creators find out whether the show has won the International Emmy Award for best drama series.

Read more
Shortlist of three options for Auckland America's Cup bases
83317 2017-11-20 07:27:31Z Economy

Shortlist of three options for Auckland America's …

by Mei Heron

Team NZ's preference for a $190m wharf extension to host the America's Cup in Auckland is winning little favour with either the council or government.

Read more
Crooked: Is the back-pain industry doing more harm than good?
83311 2017-11-20 06:41:01Z Health

Crooked: Is the back-pain industry doing more harm…

by Jules Older

If shots and surgery and addictive pills don’t relieve back pain, what does? Jules Older talks to the author of a spine medicine exposé.

Read more
Win the Listener's 100 Best Books of 2017
83307 2017-11-19 16:57:02Z Win

Win the Listener's 100 Best Books of 2017

by The Listener

Each year, the Listener offers one lucky subscriber the chance to win all 100 of our Best Books.

Read more