Ministry of Social Development staff used false names, fearing client attacks

by Edward Gay / 21 September, 2017

The Social Security Appeal Authority ordered MSD to stop the practice. Photo / Alexander Robertson

Ministry of Social Development staff have used false names on legal documents because they say they fear attacks by volatile clients.

The staff were on the ministry's Benefit Review Committee, which hears complaints from beneficiaries.

The Social Security Appeal Authority told the ministry's chief executive two years ago to stop the practice, but it continued.

The authority has now ordered the ministry to release the names, and referred its decision to the Solicitor General.

MSD chief executive Brendan Boyle. Photo / Pool, Fairfax

Beneficiaries who have a dispute can lodge a complaint with the Benefits Review Committee - an internal ministry panel. If they are not happy with the outcome, they can appeal to the Social Security Appeal Authority.

In March, there was an attempt by a ministry manager to communicate with the authority in secret.

The manager told the authority that ministry staff sitting on the committee used false names to protect their safety and that papers filed previously with the authority contained false names and signatures, without telling the authority.

This was not the first time. The authority had previously criticised the ministry for allowing decision-makers to keep their identities secret, saying it contravened natural justice and was unlawful.

Ministry of Social Development (MSD) chief executive Brendan Boyle gave a personal undertaking that the practice would not continue and apologised.

But it did not stop there.

Appeals continued to be signed by staff using false names and signatures. Initially, Mr Boyle told the authority that it was a staff error, but still the practice continued.

MSD argued the practice was justified in light of two Work and Income staff in Ashburton being murdered in 2014 and the ministry being convicted of health and safety charges as a result.

It said one of the cases before the authority involved a beneficiary who had threatened to kill ministry staff and was abusive.

However, evidence before the authority showed the threatening-to-kill allegation was three years old and the police had assessed the beneficiary as "harmless".

MSD referred that client to a section inside the ministry called the Remote Client Unit, which deals with clients the ministry believes to be dangerous.

The authority found that on one occasion the Remote Client Unit had deliberately misled the ministry's own committee.

In its ruling, the Social Security Appeal Authority said that could not be more serious; it deprived the beneficiary of their legal rights and undermined the department.

The authority said the idea of faceless decision-makers was repugnant. It said if the identities of decision-makers remained secret, they could not be held to account for their decisions.

Under New Zealand law, there are very few cases where the identity of a decision-maker is concealed. One example is national security.

The authority ruled that it believes there is an absolute prohibition on decision-makers being anonymous and Mr Boyle's justification for continuing the process lacked substance.

Its finding has been referred to the Solicitor General, as Crown Law Officer, in a rare move.

A spokesperson for Crown Law confirmed the decision had been received.

In a statement to RNZ, Mr Boyle said he was standing by the decision to anonymise staff names when dealing with what he called "volatile clients".

He said the ministry has taken the authority's decision seriously and it was looking at its legal position.

This article was originally published by RNZ.

MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage


How China’s skewed sex ratio is making President Xi’s job a lot harder
81865 2017-10-21 00:00:00Z World

How China’s skewed sex ratio is making President X…

by David Skidmore

As odd as it sounds, China’s economic policy is being held hostage by its heavily skewed sex ratio.

Read more
Allen Curnow: The poet who helped define New Zealand
81753 2017-10-21 00:00:00Z Profiles

Allen Curnow: The poet who helped define New Zeala…

by Sally Blundell

A new literary biography takes the measure of poet Allen Curnow, whose work helped define New Zealand’s voice.

Read more
Does sugar really cause kids' hyperactivity?
81849 2017-10-21 00:00:00Z Health

Does sugar really cause kids' hyperactivity?

by Marc Wilson

Parents blame sugar for causing kids’ hyperactivity, but the evidence suggests it’s not the culprit.

Read more
Minority Rules: Who will be the first voted off Coalition Island?
81921 2017-10-20 15:49:43Z Politics

Minority Rules: Who will be the first voted off Co…

by Jane Clifton

As a reality-TV show full of dramatic challenges, this new Labour-led Government has a lot going for it.

Read more
How to blend your TV into your interior style
81897 2017-10-20 14:13:55Z Technology

How to blend your TV into your interior style

by Noted

Most TVs are a central part of the living areas while at the same time, taking it over. Samsung's Frame TV hangs on the wall like a piece of artwork.

Read more
A play about Tinder, plus more upcoming Auckland theatre
81874 2017-10-20 11:49:18Z What's on

A play about Tinder, plus more upcoming Auckland t…

by India Hendrikse

Your guide to what's on now and later in Auckland

Read more
The decision's been made, what comes next for New Zealand politics?
81839 2017-10-20 06:58:41Z Politics

The decision's been made, what comes next for New …

by Richard Shaw

Expect some questions about how NZ forms governments, an angry National in Opposition and curiosity about political odd couple Ardern and Peters.

Read more
Bill English concedes: 'We all know the rules, we play by them'
81833 2017-10-20 06:15:01Z Politics

Bill English concedes: 'We all know the rules, we …

by RNZ

Mr English, flanked by his wife and senior party colleagues, appeared emotional towards the end of a short press conference accepting the decision.

Read more