Fonterra's many masters

by Pattrick Smellie / 08 April, 2016
Co-op’s different interests make life complicated.

John Wilson’s frustration that Fonterra is misunderstood is shared – by the very people his explanations would ideally target: its investors.

The largest interested group is its 10,500-odd dairy farmers, whose pri­mary concern is the price Fonterra pays for its milksolids. The other group is non-farmer investors who can get in on the action with Fonterra through the Fonterra Shareholders’ Fund (FSF), whose units trade on the NZX and give access to dividends based on Fonterra’s earnings, but hold no voting rights.

Farmer shareholders are far less interested in Fonterra’s overall profitability than whether their farms make money.

Private investors in the FSF are more interested in Fonterra’s plans for growth. Those plans require new capital for investment, but farmer shareholders are neither able to provide enough of it, nor willing to let Fonterra take on new equity that would significantly dilute their ownership. Meanwhile, there’s pressure on the co-op to keep farmers afloat.

“The use of scarce capital to support farmers can’t be helpful” for growth plans, noted First NZ Capital after Fonterra announced its results for the six months to December 31, 2015.

This is one of Fonterra’s “elephants in the room”. Another is the misalignment between the interests of its farmer shareholders and its manufacturing and processing operations.

When milk prices are low, farmers struggle, but Fonterra’s processing margins rise because the main input – milk – is comparatively cheap. When the milk price is high, manufacturing is less profitable but farmers do better. In an ideal world, these two would balance out and earnings would be fairly stable.

But life’s not that simple. For a start, milk production is a far larger business than manufacturing, so the two don’t naturally balance. And second, the manufacturing business doesn’t yet match the hype about value-added processing. Most of Fonterra’s production is low-value, commodity goods.

The other big problem is interpreting Fonterra’s financial results. Its ­performance measures are a continuous work in progress, making long-term and sometimes year-to-year comparisons difficult. The business is complex and each of its global operations has a different story. Farming in China is performing poorly, but food service is doing well. The ingredients business here is performing well, but struggling in Australia. Latin America is problematic.

In other words, the problem of interpretation is not all about townies’ ignorance. By design, the Fonterra behemoth is a complex beast.

Read more:

With continuing turmoil in the dairy industry, Fonterra chairman John Wilson says critics of our largest company have got it wrong.

Follow the Listener on Twitter or Facebook.
MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage


How should New Zealand tackle rising tensions in Asia-Pacific and Europe?
83284 2017-11-18 00:00:00Z World

How should New Zealand tackle rising tensions in A…

by Robert Patman

It's time for the big powers to get over their great power rivalries when it comes to international disputes in the 21st century. But what can NZ do?

Read more
Richard Evans: The historian who took on a Holocaust-denier
83242 2017-11-18 00:00:00Z Profiles

Richard Evans: The historian who took on a Holocau…

by Diana Wichtel

When Holocaust denier David Irving addressed the judge in his libel case as “mein Führer”, expert witness Richard Evans couldn’t believe his ears.

Read more
A book of required reading in our time of terror
83277 2017-11-18 00:00:00Z Books

A book of required reading in our time of terror

by Catherine Woulfe

Kamila Shamsie's new novel Home Again is about the beguiling pull of violent causes.

Read more
Memory check-up: The clinics helping pre-dementia sufferers
80411 2017-11-18 00:00:00Z Health

Memory check-up: The clinics helping pre-dementia …

by Donna Chisholm

A nationwide study of memory loss and pre-dementia has good news for one of its first recruits, Graeme Newton

Read more
Whole grain diets could reduce the risk of bowel cancer
83269 2017-11-18 00:00:00Z Nutrition

Whole grain diets could reduce the risk of bowel c…

by Jennifer Bowden

There’s good news and bad about New Zealand’s second-biggest cancer killer.

Read more
7 personal questions for cartoonist Tom Scott
83303 2017-11-17 14:33:23Z Profiles

7 personal questions for cartoonist Tom Scott

by Clare de Lore

Cartoonist, political columnist, playwright and film-maker Tom Scott marks his 70th birthday with the release of Drawn Out: A Seriously Funny Memoir.

Read more
The disappearance of Jim Donnelly: 'There are more questions than answers'
83250 2017-11-17 06:37:31Z Crime

The disappearance of Jim Donnelly: 'There are more…

by Paloma Migone

On Monday June 21, 2004, Jim Donnelly signed into work as usual. Thirteen years later, he still hasn't signed out.

Read more
Auckland rates increase: 'It's a good time to be selling'
83248 2017-11-17 06:27:23Z Property

Auckland rates increase: 'It's a good time to be s…

by RNZ

Homeowners in one of Auckland's cheaper suburbs could find themselves out of pocket when their next rates bill arrives in the mail.

Read more