NZME-Stuff media merger saga goes to court

by Colin Peacock / 16 October, 2017

Photo: RNZ

New Zealand's two biggest publishers of news go to court today to try and overturn the competition watchdog's refusal to green-light a merger.

Fairfax Media and NZME declared themselves "surprised and disappointed" in May when the Commerce Commission rejected their proposed merger.

While the Commission concluded Fairfax Media - recently rebranded as Stuff - and NZME could save money and extend the life of some publications, it said one joint company would concentrate ownership of newspapers to an "unprecedented" extent.

It also said other major media outlets would not be able to compensate for the reduction in "plurality", or diversity of voices.

NZME owns the New Zealand Herald, Herald on Sunday, several North Island daily papers and several radio networks including Radio Sport, ZM and Newstalk ZB.

Fairfax Media New Zealand owns The Dominion PostThe PressThe Sunday Star Times, several magazines and the country's most-visited news website

Fairfax and NZME said the Commerce Commission gave too much weight to plurality, which was referenced more than 300 times in the Commission's decision document.

The companies argued any loss of plurality should not be considered to be a detrimental effect and the Commerce Act 1986 did not give the Commission scope to determine the extent of it.

Fairfax New Zealand and NZME say the commission made "errors of fact and law."

In their notice of appeal filed with the High Court, the companies also said the Commerce Commission was wrong to conclude there were separate markets for online news, Sunday newspapers and community newspapers - and that competition would be substantially reduced.

They say the Commission failed to give sufficient weight to "the number, variety and nature" of small and large outlets providing news to New Zealanders - including the National Business Review, Otago Daily Times, and Bauer Media, which owns the bulk of New Zealand's magazines.

"Bloggers, businesses, government entities, local and national politicians and other individuals and entities all provide news and commentary online," the companies said.

Google, Facebook, competition for ad revenue

Fairfax and NZME also insist the Commerce Commission was wrong to characterise platform publishers - such as Google and Facebook - as mere distributors of news rather than direct competitors for revenue.

Their notice of appeal says New Zealanders get a growing proportion of news on those platforms which are also "taking the large majority of the total online advertising revenue".

The companies also argue the decision process was unfair because the Commission considered anonymous submissions and granted confidentiality to third parties. They say these amount to "breaches of natural justice".

Since proposing the merger in 2015, Fairfax Media and NZME have stressed their financial positions makes the merger urgent. Many pundits predicted the cost of an appeal and the time it would take would dissuade them from pursuing one, but the companies lodged an appeal just a few days before the deadline.

The Commerce Commission considered the arguments in its draft determination last November, in subsequent submissions from Fairfax and NZME and at a special conference including both companies last December.

It is effectively asking the High Court to overturn the Commission's most significant conclusions and its interpretation of the Commerce Act.

Fairfax lawyer Sarah Keene argued plurality was not the Commerce Commission's business.

The 1975 Commerce Act had a public interest test which was applied in consideration of media mergers, she said, but the current Commerce Act passed in 1986 effectively revoked that.

"We say [protecting plurality] is the role of the government. Ultimately, the government can look at a range of behaviour in the market to figure out whether plurality is protected, including editorial charters ... and New Zealand On Air funding," said Sarah Keene.

Ten days have been set down for the hearings in the Wellington High Court.

David Goddard QC is representing both media companies.

This article was originally published by RNZ.

MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage


For Germany's refugees, home is still where the heart is
Wild Eyes: The website connecting Kiwi kids with the outdoors again
80369 2017-11-22 00:00:00Z Life in NZ

Wild Eyes: The website connecting Kiwi kids with t…

by Sharon Stephenson

A website that creates “backyard missions” for Kiwi kids is dragging digital natives back outdoors.

Read more
New casual fine-diner Lillius opens in Eden Terrace
83392 2017-11-21 09:11:50Z Dining

New casual fine-diner Lillius opens in Eden Terrac…

by Kate Richards

Hospitality pros Shannon Vandy and Fraser McCarthy offer a new fine-dining eatery with a no-waste approach

Read more
Why #MeToo isn't taking off in Asia
83353 2017-11-21 00:00:00Z World

Why #MeToo isn't taking off in Asia

by Anna Fifield

Making sexual harassment unacceptable in Asia will require huge cultural shifts.

Read more
The rise of the social enterprise
83384 2017-11-21 00:00:00Z Business

The rise of the social enterprise

by Sally Blundell

A new breed of business, the social enterprise, is more intent on benefiting the community and protecting the environment than on maximising profit.

Read more
Best for who? The pressure on school leavers to choose university
83358 2017-11-20 15:22:07Z Education

Best for who? The pressure on school leavers to ch…

by Nicole Barratt

Thousands of school leavers will make big decisions this month, but a pressure brewing for years has skewed the decision-making process for some.

Read more
Dominatrix: The Renee Chignell story
83339 2017-11-20 12:58:50Z Crime

Dominatrix: The Renee Chignell story

by Donna Chisholm

Former teen dominatrix Renée Chignell was once NZ's most infamous woman. She talked to Metro in 2009 about one of the country's most notorious murders

Read more
Drugs in small town NZ: 'It's easier to get meth than cannabis'
83326 2017-11-20 11:23:30Z Crime

Drugs in small town NZ: 'It's easier to get meth t…

by Tim Brown

Meth is no longer a big city problem. Otago's sleepy Clutha District is awash with the drug - but there aren't enough addiction services to help.

Read more