When will liquidators face greater scrutiny under law?

by Jonathan Underhill / 02 October, 2017
RelatedArticlesModule - Liquidators

Illustration/Getty Images

Creditors should be better off when our insolvency laws are eventually reformed, putting liquidators under greater scrutiny.

After beating Inland Revenue in the High Court, insolvency practitioner Imran Kamal says his liquidation and advisory business is booming.

Having won his court case, Kamal doesn’t expect to be singled out again – he did home detention and 150 hours of community work in 2013 for his role in a tax-evasion case. IRD wanted him banned for five years for that conviction and his handling of two 2014 liquidations. But in rejecting the IRD’s suit, the High Court accepted there was nothing in the law that required a liquidator to be broadly fit for the task in the Companies Act 1993. Seemingly, anyone could do the job of liquidator provided they were over 18, weren’t an undischarged bankrupt or certified under mental health legislation and didn’t have ties to the company in focus or its directors, shareholders or associates.

As former Commerce Minister Paul Goldsmith said in a Cabinet paper last November, “There is no statutory occupational regulation system for insolvency practitioners.”

There is certainly no mention of any offences under the Tax Administration Act and in all other regards, Kamal is eminently qualified – an experienced accountant and insolvency specialist with more than 20 years of experience.

“I am handling over 100 liquidations, am well-experienced and resourced and hold legal qualifications in insolvency,” he says. “Practitioners who have demonstrated capability and trustworthiness as liquidators should not be unfairly prohibited from practice.”

But prior convictions may become relevant in insolvency-law reforms. The Insolvency Practitioners Bill, introduced in 2010, has been on hold since its second reading in 2013, and thanks to the work of an Insolvency Working Group, is likely to get more teeth to stop unsatisfactory practitioners entering the market.

There is likely to be a co-regulatory licensing regime operated by the Restructuring Insolvency & Turnaround Association of NZ (Ritanz) and Chartered Accountants Australia & New Zealand (Caanz), overseen by the Registrar of Companies, the Cabinet paper from last November suggests.

John Fisk of PwC.

Greater powers

There would be new grounds for disqualification, including convictions for dishonesty under the Crimes Act and serious offences under the Tax Administration Act. The courts would get greater powers to remove liquidators.

The Government has yet to release details of the bill’s refinements, but remains committed to the reforms – once the hiatus of the election is over and assuming, on the election-night results, a National Party-led administration is back in power.

“In my view, the current regime is too loose,” says Commerce Minister Jacqui Dean. “For example, a person can be convicted of tax evasion or other serious forms of knowledge-based criminal offending, yet still operate as an insolvency practitioner – a position that relies on trust.

“There are insufficient effective sanctions against ‘self-interested’ practitioners who overcharge for their services or do unnecessary work to obtain larger fees, or against ‘debtor-friendly’ liquidators who fail to comply with their statutory duty to protect the interests of creditors,” she says.

The problems are concentrated in the liquidation of small and medium-sized companies and particularly voluntary liquidations.

Typically, when a small or medium-sized enterprise gets into trouble, the shareholders’ investment has been wiped out. Directors may wish to shuffle company assets to a related party to keep them away from creditors and have “incentives to appoint a debtor-friendly liquidator”. Usually, the amounts owed to creditors are too small to bother chasing through the courts.

Directors of troubled companies will sometimes invoke the 10-day rule, under which they can appoint their own liquidator or enter voluntary administration within 10 days of a creditor petitioning to liquidate their company.

The benefit is in installing a liquidator who may be more sympathetic, whereas one installed by IRD or a major lender is likely to take a more aggressive approach to directors’ obligations. That’s a distinction touted by many insolvency firms. Most practitioners discharge their duties satisfactorily.

Kamal supports the intention of the Government’s proposed reforms and “regulation that ensures a high-quality pool of liquidators to administer corporate insolvency. I do not necessarily believe that qualified and experienced liquidators should face any bans or sanctions for unconnected and/or historical issues.”

He says he would like to see a more competitive market, including the ability to win work from the IRD. “I hope regulators take this into consideration when redrafting the new Insolvency Bill, to prevent a growing oligopoly.”

Any rule change must also ensure creditor-appointed liquidations are done in such a way as to look after the best interests of all creditors, Kamal says.

Goldsmith’s paper says that at any one time there may be between 10 and 20 practitioners who are engaging in incompetent, dishonest or debtor-friendly behaviour, “including up to five who are grossly dishonest”.

To put that in perspective, there were about 2500 appointments for insolvency services in the year through August 2016, with a third accepted by just three firms – PwC, KPMG and Deloitte. The volume is more concentrated than that, though – about a quarter were accepted by seven individuals within three firms – four from PwC, two from KPMG and one from Shephard Dunphy.

Elephant in the room

The IRD is the elephant in the room on volume alone. In the past three years, it has filed an annual average 885 applications to liquidate businesses. It uses a panel of three firms for all its work – PwC, KPMG and Deloitte.

“Inland Revenue is a creditor in about 95% of insolvent liquidations and makes the largest number of liquidation applications to the court by far,” Goldsmith’s Cabinet paper says. “Inland Revenue is often among the first creditors not to be paid, because companies with liquidity problems have incentives to keep paying trade creditors and employees so they can continue to trade.”

Insolvency specialist John Fisk, a managing partner at PwC, concurs. “There are some directors, who when they get into financial difficulty, will try to use the IRD as a bank, because they’ve got no source of funding.”

Fisk is Ritanz chairman and also sat on the Insolvency Working Group. His association has 430 members, of whom more than 100 have sought accreditation under its voluntary licensing process, which was developed with the legislative reforms in mind. He says the law change will make it compulsory.

“If there are inadequacies with insolvency practitioners, there needs to be a way for creditors to get answers without having to go to court,” Fisk says.

His association is finalising a code of conduct that will give creditors and the courts the ability to hold a liquidator to account. “It’s in all of our interests as insolvency practitioners to raise the standards.”

This article was first published in the September 30, 2017 issue of the New Zealand Listener.

MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage


New Zealanders love a good ghost story
86094 2018-01-22 00:00:00Z History

New Zealanders love a good ghost story

by Redmer Yska

We New Zealanders are known for being down to earth and no-nonsense, but there's a surprising number of Kiwi stories with a supernatural element.

Read more
How to avoid burnout at work
86051 2018-01-22 00:00:00Z Psychology

How to avoid burnout at work

by Marc Wilson

Taking positive steps at work will help keep weariness at bay.

Read more
A puppy-buyer's guide to getting a new dog
86100 2018-01-21 00:00:00Z Social issues

A puppy-buyer's guide to getting a new dog

by Sally Blundell

Just saying “oh, how adorable” is not all you need to do before taking on a new dog.

Read more
Tarawera eruption: What was the mysterious ghost canoe?
86076 2018-01-21 00:00:00Z History

Tarawera eruption: What was the mysterious ghost c…

by Dale Williams

For more than 130 years, lovers of ghost stories have enjoyed talking about one of our most enduring mysteries: the Phantom Canoe of Lake Tarawera.

Read more
How to get the health benefits of nuts without the cost
85733 2018-01-21 00:00:00Z Nutrition

How to get the health benefits of nuts without the…

by Jennifer Bowden

You need 30g of nuts a day to maximise their health benefits. Here's some tips on how to do it without putting a hole in your wallet.

Read more
Model car collector Winton Amies: 'I'm just a big kid collecting toys'
84783 2018-01-21 00:00:00Z Life in NZ

Model car collector Winton Amies: 'I'm just a big …

by Guy Frederick

When Amies moved to Naseby’s old butcher shop 22 years ago, he brought 1200 model cars with him; now he has more than 3000.

Read more
Trade Me bans sale of pugs, British and French bulldogs
86110 2018-01-20 10:49:32Z Business

Trade Me bans sale of pugs, British and French bul…

by Sally Blundell

As a result of growing concern over the welfare of pugs, British and French bulldogs, Trade Me has announced they're banning the sale of these breeds.

Read more
Puppy farming: New Zealand's secret dog-breeding shame
86056 2018-01-20 00:00:00Z Currently

Puppy farming: New Zealand's secret dog-breeding s…

by Sally Blundell

NZ has an unregulated puppy-breeding industry where unscrupulous operators can flourish, so why aren’t we following the lead of overseas governments?

Read more