The Larnachs by Owen Marshall review

by Elizabeth Alley / 25 June, 2011
The Larnachs is a sensitive, compassionate and discreet reworking of fact.
Owen Marshall is on the move again. Not that he has ever stood still for long. Widely regarded as one of our pre-eminent short-story writers, whose voice resonates through New Zealand small town and urban jungle alike, Marshall taught us to hear ourselves as we really are. If, for some, his novels have not consistently scaled quite the same literary pinnacle, they have always been thoughtful, original and written in the near-perfect prose style his wide readership appreciates.

With , he’s achieved a sensitive, compassionate and discreet re­creation of a story that, in less able hands, could well have faltered.

In this fictional reworking of historical fact, Marshall takes the skeleton of the true story of William Larnach, squire of Larnach Castle and respected member of Parliament, his marriage to third wife Conny and her scandalous love affair with his son Douglas, culminating in William’s suicide in the Parliament Buildings. The familiar setting of Larnach Castle, with its large well-appointed estate, within the social fabric of colonial settlement in Otago and Wellington, provides a strong sense of reality and is the refined background against which Marshall imagines the unfolding of the doomed love affair. Interspersed are vivid glimpses of Richard Seddon and William Massey and the acerbic wider Larnach family.

Marshall’s voice has always had an elegant restraint, and, sensitive to the potential for this story to erupt into pure melodrama, he has pitched it perfectly.

On the face of it, this is a risky construct. Very little happens. Social life on the peninsula and political life in Wellington go on as normal. The tensions of the story rest entirely on the diminishing relationship between William and Conny and the developing passion between Conny and her stepson. There is minimal dialogue, and only the two counterbalanced narrative voices of Dougie and Conny, each recording their growing desperation and determination against a growing background of hostility and rumour that simmers throughout the genteel colonial province like a growing virus. In that it is filtered through these two voices, the full scandalous drama of the affair is more muted than sensational, but that seems entirely compatible with the protective carapace that surrounded the socially powerful.

The tragic outcome is historical fact, but the story is also a moving reflection on the nature of love amid the social constraints of the time. It was a story just waiting to be written. Thank goodness it was Marshall who wrote it.

THE LARNACHS, by Owen Marshall ­(Vintage, $39.99).

Elizabeth Alley is a ­Wellington reviewer.


Stormy Daniels could sink Trump faster than Robert Mueller – here's why
91456 2018-05-26 00:00:00Z World

Stormy Daniels could sink Trump faster than Robert…

by Paul Thomas

Scandal piles on scandal for President Donald Trump. But there's a view that Stormy Daniels poses more of a threat than the Russia investigation.

Read more
How to drink alcohol 'mindfully'
90452 2018-05-26 00:00:00Z Health

How to drink alcohol 'mindfully'

by Rosamund Dean

Some practical advice from Rosamund Dean’s game-changing plan to attain – still merry – self-restraint.

Read more
There's nothing to fear at Outward Bound – except for fear itself
91356 2018-05-26 00:00:00Z Travel

There's nothing to fear at Outward Bound – except …

by Lauren Buckeridge

The Outward Bound school at Anakiwa makes you stare fear in the face and conquer it. Lauren Buckeridge does just that.

Read more
Techweek: The mixed bag that is our fledgling gig economy
91500 2018-05-25 14:12:09Z Tech

Techweek: The mixed bag that is our fledgling gig …

by Peter Griffin

The gig economy isn’t yet proving a viable alternative for most people dreaming of being their own boss.

Read more
Could medicinal cannabis be a cash cow for our poorest regions?
91486 2018-05-25 11:51:26Z Business

Could medicinal cannabis be a cash cow for our poo…

by Max Towle

Ruatoria-based Hikurangi Enterprises wants to be front and centre in the medicinal cannabis industry.

Read more
Be like Mike: Lessons the National Party could learn from Hosking
91478 2018-05-25 07:42:51Z Politics

Be like Mike: Lessons the National Party could lea…

by Graham Adams

Leaders of the National Party come and go, but Mike Hosking endures. Simon Bridges could learn from him.

Read more
M bovis will cost $1 billion - no matter what the solution is
91474 2018-05-25 07:03:24Z Environment

M bovis will cost $1 billion - no matter what the …

by Eric Frykberg

Wrangling over what to do about the cattle disease Mycoplasma bovis is going down to the wire but whatever the solution, it's expected to cost $1b.

Read more
Ireland's abortion referendum:  what you need to know
91404 2018-05-25 00:00:00Z World

Ireland's abortion referendum: what you need to k…

by Claire Pierson

Ireland is holding a referendum later today that could dramatically change its stance on abortion. Here’s a rundown of what's happening and why.

Read more