Barbara Ehrenreich takes on life, death and the illusion of controlby Peter Calder
Veteran muckraker Barbara Ehrenreich's new work examines the subject of modern medicine and consumer expectations of it.
Her best-known book, Nickel and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America, which charted her three-month experiment of trying (and failing) to live on the minimum wages she earnt in dead-end jobs, put flesh on the bones of statistics.
She’s doing the same here, in a sense, unpicking the abstractions of healthcare and inviting us to consider them as though living might be a better way to spend our time than constantly seeking to postpone dying: the question, she poses in the introduction, is whether to think of “death as a tragic interruption of your life [or] of life as an interruption of an eternity of personal non-existence … a brief opportunity” to engage with the world.
This is not the wittering of a self-help airhead. Ehrenreich has a PhD in cellular immunology and was diagnosed with breast cancer in 2001, so she has skin in the game on both sides of the clinician-patient divide. She brings both knowledge and experience to a searching examination of our preoccupation with delaying death.
Modern medicine and consumer expectations of it drive the search for potential rather than actual disease, and legitimise interventions that may be entirely unnecessary and are far from risk-free. In exploring the implications of this, Enhrenreich does not presume to speak globally – about screening programmes, for instance – but about the pressure on individuals to submit to procedures and the epidemic of overdiagnosis that results.
Most of the ideas in this book are not new – Ehrenreich credits Ivan Illich’s groundbreaking 1975 book Medical Nemesis, which popularised the concept of iatrogenic (doctor-caused) illness that Florence Nightingale had described – and it focuses, understandably, on the privatised and profit-driven US healthcare system.
But whether analysing medical examination as a ritual humiliation, stripping away the “veneer of science” that covers much practice or exploring diet fads and gym obsession, Ehrenreich brings her trademark style to bear. Baby boomers, in particular, should pay attention.
Natural Causes: Life, Death and the Illusion of Control, by Barbara Ehrenreich (Granta, $32.99)
This article was first published in the July 7, 2018 issue of the New Zealand Listener.
As dieting is exposed as the lie that it is, the weight-loss industry is unravelling.Read more
Damien Dempsey’s music recounts Ireland’s traumatic history, but it resonates half a world away in New Zealand.Read more
Andrew Little says the plan to enter the drift at Pike River, using the existing access tunnel, was by far the safest option.Read more
Is a defence force that regularly covers up and denies wrongdoings among its ranks – from war crimes to drunkenness – operating above the law?Read more
New Zealand screenwriter Anthony McCarten talks about Bohemian Rhapsody, his second big film of 2018 after the Churchill drama Darkest Hour.Read more
Released in 1977, Dario Argento’s campy Suspiria was a landmark in cult horror. Now, director Luca Guadagnino has remade it in a new style.Read more