Silent witness: The forgotten NZ movie star

by Paul Little / 17 November, 2018

Eve Balfour in her “Greek costume” from Five Nights, 1915.

A tale of melodrama, morals and murder.

The list of successful New Zealand-born actors working internationally is a long one: Sam Neill, Melanie Lynskey, Karl Urban and Anna Paquin are all flat-out thespians. But they come in the wake of pioneers, stretching back more than a century, who had to head north to find work simply because so little was happening here.

Expat stars who shone brightly in the Northern Hemisphere and are now all but forgotten – or whose New Zealand origins have been obscured by the fog of history – include Ewen Solon, James Laurenson, Denis Lill, Gina Bellman, Jonathan Elsom, Anouska Hempel and Chris Rankin.

One of the earliest and possibly least known of their number is the silent-movie actress Eve Balfour, born in Christchurch in 1890. She appeared in silent films such as The Mystery of the Diamond Belt and The Woman Who Did, as well as on the British stage. History now remembers her mainly for the scandal occasioned by her starring turn as Viola in the melodrama Five Nights in 1915.

According to an account in the Lancashire Post, headed “Scandal at a Preston Cinema”, the film featured a murder and a child born out of wedlock. The latter element aroused the moral indignation of a local member of the police force, Chief Constable James P. Ker Watson, who made his disapproval loudly and widely known. He had been at a screening of this allegedly salacious farrago, which was also attended by “several hundred men, women and children”.

Filmmakers Fred White and Walter Stott, keen to preserve their reputations or, possibly, to maximise the publicity opportunities presented by the chief constable’s imprecations, sued him for defamation. The case was held in Preston.

Millhand and mother of seven Margaret Buck told the court, “I have never seen a picture half as bad as this one” – although whether she was referring to its aesthetic or moral qualities remains unclear. Fred Daggers, army veteran and also the progenitor of seven children (which seems to have been the minimum for Preston at the time), said, “It was not a fit picture to be shown to any young person, as no doubt it would affect their future morals.”

White and Stott lost their suit. According to the Lancashire Post, “The film was never seen in Preston again, and it is now considered lost. But although it was also banned in places such as Accrington, Birkenhead and Southport, Five Nights would be shown without demur – but with considerable profit – in Blackpool and Wigan, as well as in Liverpool, Manchester, Birmingham and London.”

As for that fair flower of Canterbury, Eve Balfour, she took the greatest exception to the suggestion she had participated in the making of an immoral piece of work and defended herself vigorously, saying, “I will tell you what I wear in the studio scene, the only one that can possibly be the cause of the objection at Preston. I wear a Greek costume, not of transparent material, but of heavy silk, and besides my face only one shoulder and arm are bare. I would wear that costume in any restaurant in London, and then I should have more on than many of the women there in ordinary evening dress.”

The film being presumed lost, we can only take her word for it. Balfour married British stage actor Stanley Howlett and died in Birmingham in 1955.

This article was first published in the August 2018 issue of North & South.


Dear Oliver: A son's poignant tribute to his mother
93895 2018-12-13 00:00:00Z Books

Dear Oliver: A son's poignant tribute to his mothe…

by Peter Wells

A reminder that nothing can really prepare us for the death of a beloved parent.

Read more
Big Little Lies author does it again in Nine Perfect Strangers
100041 2018-12-13 00:00:00Z Books

Big Little Lies author does it again in Nine Perfe…

by Catherine Woulfe

The new book by Liane Moriarty can induce cravings despite its health retreat setting.

Read more
Barbershop confidential: Nelson's Man Cave offers more than just haircuts
99534 2018-12-13 00:00:00Z Psychology

Barbershop confidential: Nelson's Man Cave offers …

by Fiona Terry

In Nelson, there’s a place where modern “cavemen” can go to be groomed, chill out to music, and find someone to tell their troubles to.

Read more
The Listener's 50 Best Champagnes of 2018
100190 2018-12-13 00:00:00Z Wine

The Listener's 50 Best Champagnes of 2018

by Michael Cooper

Celebrate the festive season with sparkling wines from Central Otago to Champagne, priced from $10 to $125.

Read more
Win a double pass to Vice, the new Dick Cheney movie
100368 2018-12-12 10:44:10Z Win

Win a double pass to Vice, the new Dick Cheney mov…

by The Listener

Oscar-winning writer-director Adam McKay brings his trademark wit to the true story of US Vice President Dick Cheney in Vice.

Read more
End of an era: Auckland's independent film library Videon to shut its doors
100360 2018-12-12 10:00:59Z Small business

End of an era: Auckland's independent film library…

by Alex Blackwood

An iconic Auckland store is closing.

Read more
Michael Moore takes on Trump with fire and fury in Fahrenheit 11/9
100230 2018-12-12 00:00:00Z Movies

Michael Moore takes on Trump with fire and fury in…

by James Robins

The conflagration that gave the US President Trump is traced to September 2001.

Read more
10 ideas for the perfect summer Christmas menu
100210 2018-12-12 00:00:00Z Food

10 ideas for the perfect summer Christmas menu

by Lauraine Jacobs

Seafood stars in the entrée courses before turkey takes centre stage, with all the trimmings, to be followed by a fantastic fruity pudding.

Read more