Mary Queen of Scots is a handsome but flawed biopic

by James Robins / 28 January, 2019
RelatedArticlesModule - Mary Queen of Scots movie review

The star-studded Tudor period-drama isn’t quite worth losing one’s head over.

It took a while – a few centuries, in fact – for historians to haul Mary Stuart out from the basement and dust off her gowns. She was an archvillain for so long: a papist dupe in a land of Protestants, denounced by Reformation leader John Knox as a “strumpet”, haunted by rumours of murder and rebellion.

Now, in Mary Queen of Scots, a handsome but flawed biopic, we have a history so revisionist that it bears little resemblance to history at all. This is the valorised version of her short-lived rule and tragic demise.

Of course, Mary and cousin Liz have featured in movies forever. Dramatisation always demands cut corners, split differences, composite characters. Narratives must be pared down and themes elevated. What matters is whether those themes and characters are interesting – pedants be damned.

As played by Saoirse Ronan, Mary is fierce and independent, an enlightened and tolerant sovereign, a proto-feminist icon despite being a feudal monarch. From the moment she disembarks at Leith in 1561, Catholic Mary is seen as an imminent threat to Protestant England with a greater claim to the crown held by her cousin Elizabeth I (Margot Robbie).

So begins a decades-long struggle for supremacy. This being a script written by Beau Willimon, co-creator of the US version of House of Cards, there is much scheming, treason and betrayal conducted in dark rooms.

What’s curious about Willimon’s story is the extent to which sex, sexism and gender are pushed to the fore, whereas the arguably more relevant religious fanaticism of the day is sidelined. Though they never actually met – they do here, though – Mary and Elizabeth are bound by their predicaments: female royals with rapacious men for advisers who could turn at any moment. They range from the silky and conniving William Cecil (Guy Pearce) to the aforementioned Knox (David Tennant), who denounces “a woman with a crown” as “worse than pestilence”.

The cousins are opposites as well as mirrors: Mary thrice-married, with one child (the future King James), whereas Elizabeth was famously chaste, refusing to wed for fear a husband would threaten her power. For all the high drama of Mary’s story, it is actually Robbie’s performance as Elizabeth that cuts through stronger. “I am a man,” she declares mournfully – a clever line revealing just how much she had to sublimate herself to the throne and the role of queen.

All of which really is intriguing. But this envelope-pushing only goes so far. The look and feel of the film will be familiar to anyone who’s seen a period piece before: formal, staid, stuffy and theatrical. Nobody’s ruffs ever get too ruffled. The ideas are ambitious, the execution (shall we say) less so.

IN CINEMAS NOW

★★★

This article was first published in the February 2, 2019 issue of the New Zealand Listener.

Latest

Death of the gods: The woeful response to kauri dieback disease
102578 2019-02-21 00:00:00Z Planet

Death of the gods: The woeful response to kauri di…

by Bob Harvey

The closer you get to a kauri, the more you realise you are looking at one of the wonders of the planet.

Read more
Win a double pass to Everybody Knows
102573 2019-02-20 13:19:44Z Win

Win a double pass to Everybody Knows

by The Listener

Starring Penélope Cruz and Javier Bardem, Everybody Knows is a gripping new thriller about the fissures and fault lines that can tear a family apart.

Read more
Fall into a beautiful abyss at this must-see dance show in Auckland
102571 2019-02-20 12:12:54Z Where to go in Auckland

Fall into a beautiful abyss at this must-see dance…

by Metro

A contemporary dance show that marries dystopian anxiety with raw energy is a must-see at the Auckland Arts Festival.

Read more
Climate change declaration 'politically charged' – Thames-Coromandel mayor
102563 2019-02-20 09:39:08Z Planet

Climate change declaration 'politically charged' –…

by Kate Gudsell

A push to get local authorities to sign up to a declaration on climate change is "politically charged and driven", the Thames-Coromandel mayor says.

Read more
What's inside Metro's March/April 2019 issue?
102558 2019-02-20 09:24:47Z Auckland Issues

What's inside Metro's March/April 2019 issue?

by Metro

Top 50 wines, rappers Church & AP, fast-talking poet Selina Tusitala Marsh and what to see at Auckland Arts Festival.

Read more
China could be using Taiwan as a testing ground for disinformation campaigns
102550 2019-02-20 00:00:00Z World

China could be using Taiwan as a testing ground fo…

by Gavin Ellis

A Taiwanese diplomat’s death in Japan has become a symbol of the consequences and dangers of disinformation.

Read more
The best way to beat food cravings? Fill up on the objects of your desire
102087 2019-02-20 00:00:00Z Nutrition

The best way to beat food cravings? Fill up on the…

by Jennifer Bowden

Research has shown that dieters’ attempts to resist eating certain foods appear to lead to cravings for those foods.

Read more
Deepfake: How disinformation fools our brains and damages democracy
102545 2019-02-20 00:00:00Z Tech

Deepfake: How disinformation fools our brains and…

by Gavin Ellis

Message manipulation using bots, algorithms and, now, AI software is making it harder to know what’s real – and threatening democracy itself.

Read more