The Children Act doesn't do justice to Ian McEwan's novel

by James Robins / 17 December, 2018
RelatedArticlesModule - The Children Act movie review

Emma Thompson may be on the bench but legal drama The Children Act is yet another example of the limits of literary adaptation.

The Children Act is the second film this year that writer Ian McEwan has adapted from one of his novels. And, similar to On Chesil Beach, the result is patchy.

As with much of McEwan’s fiction, The Children Act is shot through with evocative religious themes: redemption, sacrifice, revelation, judgment. The inimitable Emma Thompson stars as Fiona Maye, a British High Court judge burdened with troubling cases. Early on, in her own “Judgment of Solomon”, she must rule on whether to separate conjoined twins, even though one of them will inevitably die.

The toll of her work rebounds on her crumbling marriage to academic Jack (Stanley Tucci), just as she’s handed an urgent new file: a teenage Jehovah’s Witness named – wait for it – Adam (Fionn Whitehead) has leukaemia and is refusing a transfusion. The “soul is in the blood and it belongs to God”, his parents claim. Presumably, God gave him corrupted blood in the first place, but Fiona presides over a “court of law, not of morals”. She can override the wishes of a minor to save his life.

This heady moral dilemma only governs the first half of the story. The rest is consumed with the consequences of her decision, and it is then that the film steadily departs the bounds of believability.

The two leads, Thompson and Whitehead, are stark contrasts – her composed, erudite performance carries the film. He, on the other hand, brings it down with bursts of immature whingeing and exasperation.

The strength of McEwan’s writing is in the intricacy of his language and the quiet devastation he often visits on his characters. On the page, Adam’s actions made sense and followed the logic of a redeemed martyr. When translated to the screen, however, subtle tragedy gives way to melodrama and things begin to look very contrived, as if the characters were not human beings with agency but marionettes.

So, as with On Chesil Beach, the adaptation of The Children Act proves that sometimes literature can achieve things that film cannot.



Video: Roadshow Films NZ

This article was first published in the December 22, 2018 issue of the New Zealand Listener.


101413 2019-01-20 00:00:00Z Life in NZ

Searching Great Barrier Island for the meaning of…

by Joanna Wane

Joanna Wane goes to Great Barrier Island in search of the answer to life, the universe and everything.

Read more
Australian classic Storm Boy gets a modern remake
101340 2019-01-19 00:00:00Z Movies

Australian classic Storm Boy gets a modern remake

by James Robins

The biggest beak in Oz screen history returns in a remake of a 1970s favourite.

Read more
Go South: The NZ travel show with no narration or score
101364 2019-01-19 00:00:00Z Television

Go South: The NZ travel show with no narration or…

by Russell Brown

New Zealand jumps on the captivating, if time-consuming, bandwagon of televising cross-country journeys.

Read more
The downsides of tiny houses
101357 2019-01-19 00:00:00Z Property

The downsides of tiny houses

by Megan Carras

Tiny houses look marvellous but have a dark side. Here are three things they don’t tell you on marketing blurb.

Read more
Scientists reveal the secrets to a restorative sleep
100946 2019-01-19 00:00:00Z Health

Scientists reveal the secrets to a restorative sle…

by Mark Broatch

A third of New Zealanders don’t get enough sleep and it’s killing us. Mark Broatch asks sleep scientists what we can do to get a good night’s slumber.

Read more
10 tips for getting a better night's sleep
100957 2019-01-19 00:00:00Z Health

10 tips for getting a better night's sleep

by The Listener

Don’t use the snooze button on your alarm clock. Alarms spike blood pressure and heart rate, and snooze buttons just repeat the shock.

Read more
Gone in 60 seconds: The hard lessons from the Cryptopia heist
101395 2019-01-18 14:38:51Z Tech

Gone in 60 seconds: The hard lessons from the Cryp…

by Peter Griffin

Time is of the essence in a bank heist, and in the digital world, cryptocurrency tokens can be transferred in a flash and converted to US dollars.

Read more
Escape the hustle and bustle of Queen St at new Auckland central eatery NEO
101383 2019-01-18 09:28:19Z Auckland Eats

Escape the hustle and bustle of Queen St at new Au…

by Alex Blackwood

NEO is a new all-day eatery overlooking Queen St.

Read more