Where Hands Touch: The biggest problem with the interracial Nazi romance

by James Robins / 26 April, 2019
RelatedArticlesModule - Where Hands Touch

A teenage interracial romance set in Nazi Germany is a well-intended but simplistic melodrama.

In her films Belle and A United Kingdom, director Amma Asante skilfully smuggled piercing interrogations of race and gender in through the back door of prestigious historical dramas. Her characters are often stuck between worlds, not feeling at home in either of them.

Asante’s latest, Where Hands Touch, continues this theme. Its central character is Leyna (Amandla Stenberg), a young black girl in Nazi Germany during its final convulsive year. Her mother (Abbie Cornish) is German and white, and her Senegalese father was a soldier during World War I and part of the French occupying forces after Germany’s defeat. Leyna feels German, although every aspect of Nazi ideology contends that she is not.

Leyna’s story is an admirable composite salvaged from the wreckage of history: as many as 25,000 black Germans survived the midnight of the century. Survival, as a postscript tells us, is defiance. But Asante’s treatment of it feels uncomfortable in many ways.

The first issue is common to war-era films: perfect clothes, soft lighting, stagey sets, rigid writing, ’Allo Allo!-style German-accented English. On top of this is Leyna’s verboten romance with Lutz (George MacKay), a teen who likes to listen to the Billie Holiday record his officer father (Christopher Eccleston) keeps locked away. Lutz is also, not to put too fine a point on it, a fanatical member of the Hitler Youth.

Although the “humanising Nazis” controversy that greeted the UK/US release of the film was meant well, it seems misguided considering Lutz’s narrative arc towards realisation. Nevertheless, was this really the only way to tell Leyna’s story?

Where Hands Touch must necessarily brush up against the Holocaust, and at the very least, Asante does no disrespect. But we’re back in the territory of what critic Michael André Bernstein called the Schindler’s List effect: “a work that manipulates the emotions raised by the enormity of its historical theme in order to disguise the simplistic melodrama”.

We go to see these sorts of movies because they’re uplifting, because they satisfy our need for rescue, reparation and redemption. But justice isn’t done by these saviour or survivor stories, either morally or artistically. It bears repeating: many millions were not saved, many millions were not protectors. A film that tried to distil even an ounce of the horror (like Son of Saul) would, of course, be unendurable. But it would be closer to the truth.

IN CINEMAS NOW

★★★

Video: Rialto Distribution

This article was first published in the April 27, 2019 issue of the New Zealand Listener.

Latest

When did a damn fine cup of coffee get so complicated?
106251 2019-05-24 00:00:00Z Food

When did a damn fine cup of coffee get so complica…

by Jean Teng

Long-time latte sipper Jean Teng embarks on a journey through the world of soft brews.

Read more
Win a double pass to a special preview of Sometimes Always Never
106301 2019-05-24 00:00:00Z Win

Win a double pass to a special preview of Sometime…

by The Listener

Billy Nighy plays Alan, a stylish tailor with moves as sharp as his suits, who has spent years searching tirelessly for his missing son.

Read more
What we must learn from the Israel Folau controversy
106275 2019-05-23 09:31:01Z Social issues

What we must learn from the Israel Folau controver…

by The Listener

Israel Folau has done us the unintended favour of showing how hard and counterproductive it would be to try to outlaw all comments that ...

Read more
Speaker criticised for chaotic way rape allegations emerged
106266 2019-05-23 08:58:23Z Currently

Speaker criticised for chaotic way rape allegation…

by RNZ

Speaker of the House Trevor Mallard has accepted some responsibility for the way in which rape allegations played out at Parliament yesterday.

Read more
Christchurch mosque attack: Terrorism charge could be risky – but it's important
106286 2019-05-23 00:00:00Z Crime

Christchurch mosque attack: Terrorism charge could…

by Keiran Hardy

Why was the terrorism charge added at this later stage? And why is it significant?

Read more
Why George Soros is a target of the far right
106102 2019-05-23 00:00:00Z World

Why George Soros is a target of the far right

by Stuart McMillan

Philanthropist George Soros, long loathed by the radical right, is spending billions to support liberal democracy and fight hate crimes.

Read more
Ian McEwan confronts the biggest mysteries of life in Machines Like Me
105820 2019-05-23 00:00:00Z Books

Ian McEwan confronts the biggest mysteries of life…

by Charlotte Grimshaw

Ian McEwan’s tale of human-robot love links emotional and artificial intelligence in intriguing ways, writes Charlotte Grimshaw.

Read more
Is chemical residue on fruit and vegetables worth worrying about?
105778 2019-05-23 00:00:00Z Nutrition

Is chemical residue on fruit and vegetables worth…

by Jennifer Bowden

The chemical residues on fruit and vegetables are not dangerous, but rinsing is still advisable.

Read more