How TV pundits reacted to the rise of Jacinda Ardern

by Diana Wichtel / 15 August, 2017
RelatedArticlesModule - Jacinda Ardern

On the box: Labour leader Jacinda Ardern.

Labour’s new “relentlessly positive” leader comes up against dinosaurs.

The Jacinda Effect: it sounds like a television show, the kind where a contestant comes on stage to sceptical looks, opens her mouth and wows Simon Cowell. “I don’t really know what the X factor is,” new Labour Party leader Jacinda Ardern told Hilary Barry on Breakfast. “I’ve also been called a new lick of paint.” At least this is better than the emetic “battle of the babes!” headlines when Ardern ran against National’s Nikki Kaye in 2011. That had male commentators appraising skirt lengths and – dear lord – dusting off jelly-wrestling metaphors.

Ardern is determined to smile through it all. She has to. She has promised, relentlessly, to be “relentlessly positive”. Jacindamania, the Jassiah … Not everyone sees the funny side. “I would definitely take her as seriously as I have any of the previous five [Labour leaders] I’ve seen before her,” purred Deputy Prime Minister Paula Bennett on The Nation.

But clearly the Jacinda-rama-lama-ding-dong is getting to Bennett. “I feel like she’s stolen my relentless positivity,” she wailed to an unsympathetic-looking Lisa Owen. “So I was going to go for eternal optimism.” Sorry, Paula, also taken. Ardern has promised “optimism for New Zealand”. She came up through John Key’s “I’m ambitious for New Zealand” years, watching and learning.

On Q+A, Ardern and deputy leader Kelvin Davis went for a good-cop, bad-cop vibe. Davis launched an ill-advised litany of gags about National: Bill English has “the personality of a rock”, the Government is as “dry as dandruff!”, he chortled. “That’s a bit harsh,” muttered Jessica Mutch, while Ardern tried to look optimistic for New Zealand that this awkward moment would soon pass.

There was another possible misstep on The Nation. Under heavy fire from Owen, Ardern refused to commit to staying on as leader if her party lost. On the panel, former Labour Party president Mike Williams noted that if she committed, some voters might decide to vote for National and give Ardern a go next time. She may claim to be doing politics differently, but it’s still politics.

As she demonstrated to Mark Richardson on The AM Show, she has also picked up a trick or two from other leaders. She is honing an accusatory index finger that could soon rival Aunty Helen’s death stare. She will need it with all the mansplaining going on at the sight of a self-described “youth-adjacent” woman getting some power.

After Ardern had to deal with those pregnancy questions on The AM Show and The Project, NZ Herald columnist John Roughan cleared up the situation for us: “… it was in the context of her age, not her gender alone, that she was asked about starting a family. It’s a pity, I think, that she chose to spin that question into a gender issue.” Of course. It was all her fault. If she decided against having children now, that would be fine too, he continued. “I have never heard a woman criticised for that decision.”

He may want to speak to Helen Clark. He may also want to speak to Julia Gillard, who in 2011, when Prime Minister, was accused by an opponent of having chosen to “deliberately remain barren”. And he may want to speak to Ardern. In 2012, during a debate about paid parental leave, she copped the sort of jibe – “How many kids do you have?” – that women without children, and the odd man, encounter in political life.

The dinosaurs won’t change, but this disruption in politics-as-usual is a useful demonstration of what women are still up against. With the Greens having some disruption of their own, all bets are off. On Sunday, Ardern told John Hudson about her cat, growing up in the 90s and the Ginger Spice hair she had at 17. He suggested that this election was about “intergenerational warfare”. She was too relentlessly positive to agree with a metaphor that, although better than jelly-wrestling, sounds a little threatening. But shots have been fired from both sides of the generational divide. Let the battle begin.

This article was first published in the August 19, 2017 issue of the New Zealand Listener.


In a Time of Monsters: Emma Sky's attempt to shed light on the Middle East
108292 2019-07-24 00:00:00Z Books

In a Time of Monsters: Emma Sky's attempt to shed…

by Peter Calder

A diary of adventures in the volatile Middle East is diverting but hardly illuminating, writes Peter Calder.

Read more
The sum of our fears: The literature of climate change
108842 2019-07-24 00:00:00Z Books

The sum of our fears: The literature of climate ch…

by Jenny Nicholls

The most interesting books on climate change.

Read more
The bad news about tattoo removal
108205 2019-07-24 00:00:00Z Health

The bad news about tattoo removal

by Ruth Nichol

Tattoo regret is rising, but removal of the offending ink isn’t painless – for the person or their pocket.

Read more
Former inmate Paul Wood's insights on improving NZ's criminal-justice system
108325 2019-07-23 00:00:00Z Profiles

Former inmate Paul Wood's insights on improving NZ…

by Clare de Lore

As the Government spends millions reforming the criminal-justice system, Paul Wood says crime would be reduced if we taught our children emotional...

Read more
Camino Skies: An inspiring Kiwi doco about grief and determination
108733 2019-07-23 00:00:00Z Movies

Camino Skies: An inspiring Kiwi doco about grief a…

by Russell Baillie

A New Zealand-made documentary about those who walk the 800km Camino trail is heartbreaking, blistering and terrific.

Read more
Funny As is a hilarious and horrifying look at NZ's comedy history
108591 2019-07-23 00:00:00Z Television

Funny As is a hilarious and horrifying look at NZ'…

by Fiona Rae

Five-part series Funny As: The Story of New Zealand Comedy shows just how far our humour has come.

Read more
Eyes front: My advice for those seeking retinal surgery
108209 2019-07-23 00:00:00Z Health

Eyes front: My advice for those seeking retinal su…

by Mark Broatch

If flashes of light or spooky shadows suddenly appear in your vision, see your optician or doctor without delay.

Read more
Jacinda Ardern supports, does not commit to 'climate emergency' declaration
108769 2019-07-23 00:00:00Z Planet

Jacinda Ardern supports, does not commit to 'clima…

by Jo Moir

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has stopped short of committing to a declaration of climate emergency in Parliament.

Read more