Decision to force woman to pay likely abuser will have 'chilling effect'

by RNZ / 22 January, 2019
womens refuge

Photo: Women's Refuge.

The lawyer of a woman ordered to pay $28,000 to her likely abuser has urged the justice minister to intervene and has called for law reform to avoid 'retraumatisation' of victims.

Yesterday, Justice Edwards ordered Mariya Taylor to pay her alleged abuser $28,000, despite finding it "likely" he assaulted and falsely imprisoned her in the 1980s in behaviour described as "heinous".

Ms Taylor made her claims against Robert Roper and the Royal New Zealand Air Force (RNZAF), which were dismissed in September because the claims were made outside The Limitations Act.

In a separate case in 2014, Roper was tried and convicted of 20 counts of sexual offending against members of his family and three other women between 1976 and 1988. This included the rape of his own daughter.

One of the woman's lawyers, Geraldine Whiteford, said her client was overwhelmed by the decision and had been revictimised and retraumatised due to the legal process.

"Mr Roper is a man who subjected her to serious abuse and the judge found most of it had occurred and it's had a devastating effect on her psychologically, so the effect of the decision is to revictimise her," she said.

She said the case highlighted an area where law reform was required to ensure abuse victims were able to achieve adequate redress and that failure to do would create a chill factor, making victims reluctant to come forward.

"It's a terrible decision for other victims of sexual abuse because they can't get justice through the criminal system, but delivers shockingly poor outcomes for victims, the civil system is a slightly easier route for victims who wish to seek justice against the perpetrators and this decision will have a chilling effect on victims who are considering this route."

She said the United Nations had called for governments to ensure laws allowed victims to pursue redress.

Ms Whiteford called for Justice Minister Andrew Little to intervene and for law reform to give judges a better guide to use their discretion around determining court costs.

Speaking to Morning Report from the United Nations offices in Geneva, Mr Little declined to address the particulars of the case until he had studied what legal advice had been given to Ms Taylor, which he said may have been poor.

"It's a most unfortunate outcome, I'd have to consider how she's been been a victim or what she's been a victim of, whether it's the court system or whether indeed it's the poor advice of her lawyer," he said.

"As a former lawyer myself, dealing often with vulnerable people ... I was equally aware of lawyers who often gave advice to people that I found unfathomable and the only person who walked away with anything was the lawyer with a big fat paycheque and the client who had to pay for it."

Mr Little signalled he would not be looking into the issue of costs being paid under these types of the circumstances.

"The issue of High Court costs, the judges and the Law Society deal with and the Attorney-General takes responsibility for that sort of thing.

"There's long-established rules about costs and ... costs and cost rewards are reviewed periodically, but there are some basic principles that are about ensuring that some people who take big risks or lawyers who advise clients to take risks, when the risks don't pay off, then there is a consequence."

Ms Taylor had sought damages against both Roper and the RNZAF for the mental harm she said was caused by Roper's actions between 1985 and 1987 at the Whenuapai air base in Auckland.

Sixteen witnesses, including two experts, gave evidence at the trial.

RNZAF denied she raised complaints with it. However, witnesses said he locked her in a wire-walled storage cupboard and she said it occurred once a month, sometimes for more than an hour, over years.

"I found it likely that Mr Roper had acted as [she] alleged, and that these acts were a material and substantial cause of [her] mental injury, namely, her post-traumatic stress disorder," Justice Edwards wrote in a decision.

"There can be no dispute that Mr Roper's conduct towards [her] was heinous."

However, because the Ms Taylor's claims were made outside The Limitations Act, and because there was insufficient evidence to support her claims of disability preventing her from making them earlier, Justice Edwards could not uphold the case.

Because Roper incurred costs while providing a legal defence, he was eligible to claim costs against Ms Taylor.

Justice Edwards said awarding the costs against Ms Taylor "encourages litigants to consider whether there are cost-effective alternatives to court litigation to resolve the underlying dispute".

This article was first published on Radio NZ.

Latest

The best thing to come from the Black Caps' defeat
108621 2019-07-20 00:00:00Z Sport

The best thing to come from the Black Caps' defeat…

by Paul Thomas

For New Zealanders, the Cricket World Cup final was a brutal reminder of sport’s great paradox. But there's hope on the horizon.

Read more
What New Zealand can do about the militarisation of space
108498 2019-07-20 00:00:00Z Tech

What New Zealand can do about the militarisation o…

by Duncan Steel

We may decry the notion, but the hostile use of space is creeping into the plans of various countries.

Read more
Five technologies from the space race that we take for granted
108506 2019-07-20 00:00:00Z Tech

Five technologies from the space race that we take…

by Peter Griffin

If US$154 billion to land 12 men on the Moon seems excessive, consider the things we use every day that had their roots in a Nasa lab.

Read more
Top investigator urges police to speak up about wrongful convictions
108539 2019-07-19 00:00:00Z Crime

Top investigator urges police to speak up about wr…

by Mike White

Mike White talks to investigator Tim McKinnel, who says police often turn a blind eye to possible corruption out of a misplaced sense of loyalty.

Read more
Jacinda Ardern to focus on Australia deportations in talks with Scott Morrison
108570 2019-07-19 00:00:00Z Politics

Jacinda Ardern to focus on Australia deportations…

by Craig McCulloch

PM Jacinda Ardern has doubled down on her criticism of Australia's deportation policy as "corrosive", ahead of her meeting with Scott Morrison.

Read more
How closed adoption robbed Māori children of their identity
108572 2019-07-19 00:00:00Z Social issues

How closed adoption robbed Māori children of their…

by Te Aniwa Hurihanganui

Te Aniwa Hurihanganui looks at the outdated Adoption Act and its impact on Māori who grew up desperate to reconnect.

Read more
The new robotic surgery aiding vaginal mesh removal
108377 2019-07-19 00:00:00Z Health

The new robotic surgery aiding vaginal mesh remova…

by Ruth Nichol

Women with complications caused by deeply embedded vaginal mesh are being helped by a pioneering surgical technique.

Read more
A beautiful mind: What people with Alzheimer's can teach us
108544 2019-07-19 00:00:00Z Health

A beautiful mind: What people with Alzheimer's can…

by Fergus Riley

North Auckland farmer Fergus Riley has uncovered many important lessons in caring for his father Peter, who has Alzheimer’s.

Read more