No prosecution in CTV building collapse: 'This is not trial by expert'

by Phil Pennington / 01 December, 2017
RelatedArticlesModule - CTV

Rescuers search through the rubble of the collapsed CTV building. Photo / Getty Images

A criminal prosecution against the designers of the CTV building was abandoned even though engineers said it was clear substandard design led to the collapse.

On Thursday, police announced they did not have sufficient evidence for a successful prosecution.

"If I'd taken my heart's advice, we would have prosecuted. I can't take my heart's advice, I have to use my head," Detective Superintendent Peter Read said.

Justice Minister Andrew Little said he wanted to consider introducing a corporate manslaughter charge in the future.

"Everybody involved in this has walked away scot-free. And that's not right," he said.

Documents released by the police show the Crown Solicitor had concluded there was enough evidence to lay charges of negligent manslaughter against designers Alan Reay and David Harding, after a three-year $1.2 million police investigation.

Justice Minister Andrew Little Photo: RNZ / Rebekah Parsons-King

The centrepiece of that investigation was a report by the leading engineering firm BECA that lays out a dozen major deficiencies in the structural design.

"It is our opinion that, had the whole building complied with codes and practices of the day, the building, though damaged, would have had sufficient resilience not to collapse suddenly and in a pancaking fashion," BECA said.

"Dr Reay's omission to discharge his obligations in regard to the allocation of appropriate resources to the design were the reason why the design errors were not identified and corrected, and was, therefore, a substantial and operating cause of the deaths."

BECA and the two peer reviewers agreed that Dr Reay and Mr Harding did not fulfil their duty to design up to code - a major departure from expected standards, which was a substantial cause of the collapse.

Not a 'trial by expert'

But Deputy Solicitor General Brendan Horsley pulled back, saying "this is not trial by expert" and he considered the prospects of a successful prosecution were low, as did the Crown Solicitor.

"A key difficulty for the prosecution would be in proving the CTV building would not have collapsed in the absence of the identified design errors," he said.

"The expert peer reviewers were cautious about drawing this conclusion."

An American peer reviewer, who is not named, said it was possible the collapse could have occurred in the absence of design errors due to higher than expected ground motions in combination with the building's lack of resilience.

The documents explained that the building code at the time did not demand adequately strong columns for resilience in high-risk zones.

However, a New Zealand peer reviewer pointed out other buildings of a similar age and type withstood the quake and that the designers did not take into account the building having to move sideways in a quake.

The building's designer Dr Reay said he was "deeply anguished."

In a statement, he said: "I have tried to understand why the building characteristics changed after the September 2010 earthquake and then ultimately collapsed.

"It is my strongest hope that from this tragedy every possible lesson is learned."

At the time CTV was designed he held a doctorate in seismic engineering.

The engineering reports to the police said the Christchurch City Council issued the CTV building approval without a thorough structural check, but that this was standard practice - and it still is.

"Councils are reliant on the information provided by the structural engineers," said Nick Hill, chief executive of Building Officials Institute.

Engineering New Zealand said it had made "huge changes" since the CTV collapse to hold engineers more accountable.

A stricter ethical charter meant its 20,000 members had an obligation to take action if they came across poor design or any other "real' public safety issue, it said.

Also, they could no longer resign their membership if they came under investigation, as Dr Reay did.

Dr Reay remains a director and shareholder in various engineering, design and property companies, including Engenium, which was what he renamed his main firm after the CTV Royal Commission.

Engenium has been awarded major contracts, such as the Health Research Education Facility in Christchurch, schools and Alexandra Park Apartments in Auckland.

The Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment said it has introduced a slew of changes since 2011 aimed at reducing death, injury and loss in a quake, including better seismic design standards for buildings.

This article was originally published by RNZ.

Latest

How to know if you are being sexually harassed at work
89757 2018-04-23 00:00:00Z Social issues

How to know if you are being sexually harassed at …

by The Listener

The Employment Relations Act is very clear about what constitutes sexual harassment in New Zealand.

Read more
Some corner of an English field
89918 2018-04-22 00:00:00Z History

Some corner of an English field

by Pamela Wade

Pamela Wade visits a village in rural England and finds the war-time deaths of her uncle and his two Kiwi-airmen mates have not been forgotten.

Read more
The brain researcher who was diagnosed with a brain tumour
89704 2018-04-22 00:00:00Z Profiles

The brain researcher who was diagnosed with a brai…

by Clare de Lore

Few people could be better suited than Louise Nicholson to deal with a brain tumour diagnosis.

Read more
Discovering the majesty and fragility of New Zealand kauri
88483 2018-04-22 00:00:00Z Environment

Discovering the majesty and fragility of New Zeala…

by Josie Stanford

A twilight tour in Waipoua Forest highlights the majesty, and the fragility, of our mighty kauri.

Read more
Sweet Country – movie review
89842 2018-04-22 00:00:00Z Movies

Sweet Country – movie review

by Peter Calder

An Australian western with Sam Neill is a searing masterpiece.

Read more
The role that diet plays in causing gout is smaller than people think
89404 2018-04-22 00:00:00Z Health

The role that diet plays in causing gout is smalle…

by Nicky Pellegrino

It's often said that diet is the most important cause of gout, but for most people changing it won't lower uric acid levels enough to stop the pain.

Read more
15 and snapping the stars: The new generation of music media
88446 2018-04-21 00:00:00Z Music

15 and snapping the stars: The new generation of m…

by Sharon Stephenson

Wellington teenager McKenzie Jennings-Gruar is part of a new-generation media pack on the music festival circuit.

Read more
Moa Please! Give Anika Moa a prime-time spot on TV right now
89886 2018-04-21 00:00:00Z Television

Moa Please! Give Anika Moa a prime-time spot on TV…

by Diana Wichtel

It’s time the tornado of Seven Sharp and Anika Moa Unleashed was set free on prime time.

Read more