Paula Bennett says she didn't lie about her circumstances to Work and Income

by RNZ / 17 July, 2017

Help us find and write the stories Kiwis need to read

Deputy Prime Minister Paula Bennett says she "didn't lie as such about my circumstances". Photo / Getty Images

In an interview, Paula Bennett was asked about her own experience of being on a benefit and whether she was ever dishonest with Work and Income.

Deputy Prime Minister Paula Bennett, who also received a benefit as a sole parent, says she was never in a position of having to lie to Work and Income, as Metiria Turei did.

There has been a mixed political reaction to Ms Turei's admission that she lied to Work and Income in the 1990s so her sole parent benefit would not be cut.

Labour Party leader Andrew Little said Ms Turei was brave and honest to admit to breaking the rules, but National Party MP Steven Joyce said people would be disappointed.

Mrs Bennett said she was often on a sole parent benefit herself, but also said Ms Turei's admission was disappointing.

She said she had never found herself in a position where she had to lie to Work and Income.

"I think people work really hard in this country and they pay their taxes and they want it to be fair and for that we expect people to be honest and not cheating.

"I was often on benefit, I had jobs and I was always trying to get off when I was on, because I wanted to work and didn't want to be on a benefit.

"But no, I didn't deliberately lie, I didn't lie as such about my circumstances ... I didn't lie to them about my circumstances to get more money.

"I remember hard times on the benefit and I've never bought into that people choose to be there ... and that it's a great lifestyle, because it's not, it's actually really hard."

She disagreed with the Green Party policy of removing the practice of cutting benefits to those who failed to comply with particular rules.

"I think we should be talking about the fact that they're talking about taking away work obligations as part of their policy, and I've got to be honest that just completely horrifies me.

"It's never for missing one job interview, there's always a warning system, there's always a series of circumstance.

"I can tell you that for most of those that receive a sanction they never actually get any cut in the weekly amount they get."

She admitted there were thousands of people who did have their benefits cut, however.

"We've equally, though, got the lowest number of sole parents that we've had since 1988.

"And those women and their children - they are predominantly women - are doing so much better off benefit, not just financially but equally for the hope and everything that they've got in that household.

"If you can work you should be, and if you are on a benefit and you can be looking for work then I think most New Zealanders expect there to be a mutual obligation that you're doing that."

Comparing Todd Barclay to Metiria Turei a long bow - deputy PM

She said it was a wide bow to draw to compare it to National MP Todd Barclay who, after a scandal where it is alleged he secretly recorded staff at his electorate office, announced he would not be standing in the next election.

Mr Barclay has not shown up at Parliament for the past three weeks, but was still being paid about $3000 a week.

Mrs Bennett said he was still working.

"He's certainly been advocating on behalf of his electorate, he's still doing that work, he's still doing work on behalf of his constituents and things.

She said it had been recess for the past week and the coming week, and although he had not been at Parliament for the two weeks before that she expected he would return to Parliament after the recess.

"He's not fronting to the media and he doesn't actually have to do that. I mean, he has been doing his job in his electorate and I expect to see him in the next three weeks in Parliament."

"I think most people would give him a week, or six days that he wasn't in Parliament, to be fair."

She said she thought the government did give beneficiaries a fair break as well.

"For those who have their benefits cut the difference is they can recomply really easily, and as such get their benefit back."

This article was originally published by RNZ.

Latest

Best smartphones on the NZ market: What to look for and what to avoid
94991 2018-08-16 00:00:00Z Tech

Best smartphones on the NZ market: What to look fo…

by Peter Griffin

The smartphone market is complex, rapidly evolving and heavy on marketing hype. Here's NOTED Tech's five-point guide to help you before you buy.

Read more
Simon Bridges' expenses leak inquiry to be decided by Speaker
95000 2018-08-15 10:18:16Z Politics

Simon Bridges' expenses leak inquiry to be decided…

by Craig McCulloch

Parliament's referee Trevor Mallard is to decide today whether to launch a full-scale investigation into who leaked Simon Bridges' travel expenses.

Read more
Quinovic ad 'disgusts' landlords
94989 2018-08-15 08:02:40Z Property

Quinovic ad 'disgusts' landlords

by Katie Doyle

Landlords and real estate groups have joined tenants in condemning a Quinovic advertising campaign that appeared to celebrate making renters lives a m

Read more
Business might not trust the Govt, but should the Govt trust business?
94928 2018-08-15 00:00:00Z Politics

Business might not trust the Govt, but should the …

by Jane Clifton

The Ardern Administration and the business community are at loggerheads on the issue of trust – and there's fault to be found on both sides.

Read more
How a museum robbery lead to a bizarre story about feather fetishists
94411 2018-08-15 00:00:00Z Books

How a museum robbery lead to a bizarre story about…

by Linda Herrick

When Kirk Wallace Johnson heard about the theft of 299 rare birds skins, he had no idea what he was getting himself into.

Read more
New Zealand's soil has a lack of selenium, but we make up for it in the sea
94776 2018-08-15 00:00:00Z Nutrition

New Zealand's soil has a lack of selenium, but we …

by Jennifer Bowden

Many Kiwis are deficient in selenium, which plays an important role in inflammation, immunity and the production of thyroid hormones.

Read more
Some of our best subversive Kiwi playground rhymes
91871 2018-08-15 00:00:00Z Humour

Some of our best subversive Kiwi playground rhymes…

by Paul Little

“Roll, roll, roll your dope, Scrunch it at the end. Puff, puff, That’s enough. Now pass it to your friend.”

Read more
Bridges: National caucus didn't leak travel expenses
94949 2018-08-14 11:07:18Z Politics

Bridges: National caucus didn't leak travel expens…

by Jo Moir

Opposition leader Simon Bridges is standing by his MPs, saying he doesn't believe one of them leaked his travel expenses to media.

Read more