When governments tear themselves apart

by Bill Ralston / 21 February, 2018
RelatedArticlesModule - Governments NZ

Former Prime Minister David Lange is congratulated by Jim Bolger after his valedictory speech in Parliament in 1996. Photo/Getty Images

Governments that ride triumphantly into power must learn a lesson from history.

One morning after the 1975 election, in which a resurgent National Party had ousted a one-term Labour Government, I stood in an upstairs corridor of the deserted Parliament Building.

I had flown to Wellington to collect some government papers I needed for my never-to-be-finished masters thesis. Outgoing Deputy Prime Minister Bob Tizard walked past, whistling tunelessly, and disappeared through a dark-panelled door. I wandered away, thinking to myself, “This is how a government dies: not with a bang but a forlorn whistle.”

Labour, led by the charismatic Norman Kirk, had been elected in 1972, but barely 20 months later, Kirk was dead and Bill Rowling was leader. In the year before the next election, the Government was staggering under the weight of rising debt and the trade impact of the UK joining the European Economic Community and lacked a clear economic policy.

The newly elected National Government, with Robert Muldoon as Prime Minister, lasted longer, nearly three full terms, until one night, alarmed at the risk of one or two of his rebellious backbenchers crossing the floor on some legislation, he drunkenly called a snap election. He lost.

For the next three years, David Lange and Labour looked good. Finance Minister Roger Douglas took Labour down a radical free-market path, disentangling the country from a thicket of regulations and subsidies that were strangling the economy into near-bankruptcy. Then Lange decided the country needed a “cup of tea and a lie down”. Douglas did not and the Fourth Labour Government tore itself apart. Lange quit as Prime Minister, Douglas was sidelined and the Government drifted to a crushing defeat.

Jim Bolger, who led the new National Government, soon fell out with his Douglas-inclined Finance Minister, Ruth Richardson, and she dropped by the wayside. His Government waddled on for three terms, the last two years without him as leader because Jenny Shipley decided she was the only one who could avert an electoral collapse in 1999. She did not.

Helen Clark and Labour returned for a surprisingly comfortable nine years, but eventually the fickle electorate got bored and National’s John Key took power. His Government also lasted three easy terms, but with a year to go in the last term, he quit and Bill English took over as Prime Minister, hoping to win the next election against a dull and disorganised Labour opposition. National did win the most votes, but the vagaries of MMP allowed Labour’s vibrant new leader, Jacinda Ardern, to form a government with New Zealand First and the Greens.

And that is where we are now. The lesson of the past 45 years is that governments ride triumphantly into power, but all too often, internal arguments rip them apart. Only Clark and Key managed to maintain the discipline required with their caucus and voters.

Things look rosy now for the Ardern Government, but history tells us it can turn to custard without that discipline and focus. Ardern is the ideal face for the new Government, popular, charismatic, collegial in style. Behind her stand Grant Robertson and David Parker, the hard-working “tight forwards” of her Cabinet. It looks shakier when you turn your attention beyond Labour to the far looser NZ First and the Greens.

The lesson of the Kirk/Rowling Government is not to do too little; Lange showed us it is possible for a government to do too much, too fast. Ardern would be wise to adopt the Clark and Key approach of stable, centralised leadership. Otherwise, she may find herself in 2020 whistling alone in a deserted corridor.

This article was first published in the February 10, 2018 issue of the New Zealand Listener.


The death of Radio Live
99147 2018-11-16 06:54:48Z Radio

The death of Radio Live

by Colin Peacock

14 years after launching “the new voice of talk radio”, MediaWorks will silence Radio Live. Mediawatch looks at what could replace it.

Read more
Should Lime scooters stay or should they go?
99103 2018-11-16 00:00:00Z Social issues

Should Lime scooters stay or should they go?

by The Listener

For every safety warning, there’ll be a righteous uproar about the public good regarding the environment. It's about finding the right balance.

Read more
Kiwi drama Vermilion is hamstrung by a frustrating lack of clarity
98992 2018-11-16 00:00:00Z Movies

Kiwi drama Vermilion is hamstrung by a frustrating…

by James Robins

Academic and film-maker Dorthe Scheffmann has had a hand in some of New Zealand cinema’s most beloved movies. So what went wrong?

Read more
Win the 100 Best Books of 2018
99119 2018-11-16 00:00:00Z Win

Win the 100 Best Books of 2018

by The Listener

Each year, the Listener offers one lucky subscriber the chance to win all 100 of our Best Books.

Read more
Full of light and art, Forestry Cafe is south-east Auckland's newest coffee spot
99142 2018-11-15 16:49:34Z Auckland Eats

Full of light and art, Forestry Cafe is south-east…

by Alex Blackwood

New opening Forestry Cafe brings a city vibe to Flat Bush.

Read more
Turning a corner: Why this wayward Auckland teen stayed in school
99114 2018-11-15 10:34:07Z Social issues

Turning a corner: Why this wayward Auckland teen s…

by Vomle Springford

When Acer Ah Chee-Wilson was 14, he wanted to be in a gang.

Read more
What Kate Sheppard said that changed the course of New Zealand politics forever
99084 2018-11-15 00:00:00Z Politics

What Kate Sheppard said that changed the course of…

by Noted

Helen Clark and even Meghan Markle have quoted Kate Sheppard – what did she say that was so powerful?

Read more
Why Bret McKenzie is going straight with a new band
99026 2018-11-15 00:00:00Z Profiles

Why Bret McKenzie is going straight with a new ban…

by Russell Baillie

After a year of stadium comedy and Muppet shows, Bret McKenzie talks about returning to his music roots in a band whose songs are no laughing matter.

Read more