Reflections on my encounter with the charming Dan Malloryby Michele Hewitson
He penned a bestselling thriller under a pseudonym, but as Michele Hewitson discovered, author Dan Mallory also proved himself to be a charmingly adept bullshit artist.
The author is American Dan Mallory. His pen name is AJ Finn. Mallory is quiet and private. Finn will tell you anything and everything. Some of it, it turns out, is true. Because here’s the twist in the plot of that really great thriller: Mallory said he had brain cancer, and survived it. He told people his mother had cancer and did not survive it. He said his brother committed suicide. None of these things are true. He told me his mother would be travelling with him to New Zealand. He joked: “Only one of us will make it back alive. She’s quite spirited.” This was quoted in a recent New Yorker investigation into who Dan Mallory/AJ Finn really is. I nearly fell off my chair. I couldn’t decide whether I had been duped, so I put one sock back on and continued reading.
By now my mind is spinning. I phone Langstone. Her mind is spinning. She says, “Everything that we’re talking about is like a beautifully executed psychological thriller … it could be the most extraordinary and brilliant book.”
King didn’t want to talk about Mallory. She was quite upset and conflicted. She said, by email: “Dan was the perfect festival guest. He was warm and gracious in all my dealings with him, and he was generous with his time while he was at the festival, taking part in events that went beyond promotion for his book … He endeared himself to a lot of people. He did state at the time that mental illness has loomed large in his life and the New Yorker article confirms that.”
Mallory made a statement to the New Yorker, through a PR firm, which, in brief, said he invented a physical illness to cover up his mental illness. “It is the case that on numerous occasions in the past, I have stated, implied, or allowed others to believe that I was afflicted with a physical malady instead of a psychological one: cancer, specifically.” He has since gone quiet. I phoned and left a message asking him to call me, without any hope that he would. I said, a bit plaintively: “I named your plant!” He told me he lived alone except for a pet plant. I asked if it had a name and when he said that it didn’t, I suggested Roger was a good name for a pet plant. He loved that, he said, and that he was going to go right out and get a little name tag for the plant. Does he even have a plant? Do I want to take the name back? I don’t know.
I went back through my notes. I can’t find anything that appears to be a direct lie, except by omission. I mentioned his Highsmith doctorate and he didn’t correct me. Langstone says he “danced” around this with her, too, and moved the conversation on.
A senior publishing executive contacted by the New Yorker said, “My God! I knew I’d get this call. I didn’t know if it would be you or the FBI.” Were we conned? Or tricked? Langstone, like me, is trying to work this out. “I don’t know the answer to that because I don’t know how much of what I was presented with was Dan and how much of what I was presented with was AJ Finn. He drew a very distinct line between the two of them … There’s a really interesting sense of dislocation, isn’t there, to be able to lift outside of yourself and move between two different people and two different truths.” She says: “I still really like Dan. I adored my time with him.”
But who did she, and many others, spend time with? And does it matter if a novelist, whose job it is to make things up – and to make people believe his fiction – makes things up?
“I wish I had some sort of clarity for you,” says Langstone. But it is the sheer murkiness that provides the frisson. He’s Tom Ripley, Langstone says. “He’s actually become a Patricia Highsmith character. All of that masquerading and pretending … I find that quite dazzling and also really sad.” It is our confused feelings about the charming chancer, Tom Ripley, which makes him such an enduring and oddly endearing character. Langstone’s first thought about Dan Mallory was, “I hope he’s okay.”
His publishers are sticking by him. His second book, he has said, will involve “a female thriller writer and an interviewer who learns of a dark past”. Life, as we like to say, is stranger than fiction.
This article was first published in the February 23, 2019 issue of the New Zealand Listener.
“We bow down to this idea of Elon Musk or Jeff Bezos going to Mars, when here in our own country, we had the equivalent."Read more
Comedian Tim Batt buys up domains for new Brian Tamaki-backed political party.Read more
Long-time latte sipper Jean Teng embarks on a journey through the world of soft brews.Read more
Billy Nighy plays Alan, a stylish tailor with moves as sharp as his suits, who has spent years searching tirelessly for his missing son.Read more
Israel Folau has done us the unintended favour of showing how hard and counterproductive it would be to try to outlaw all comments that ...Read more