Ending solo mum sanction could cost govt $25m a year

by Craig McCulloch / 17 January, 2018

The policy has been in place since 1990. Photo / Getty Images

Officials warn the cost could balloon if the policy is ditched.

Moves to scrap a sanction against some solo mums will cost the government more than $100 million over four years, ministry officials say, and the cost could blow out "considerably" if the plan encourages more mothers not to name their baby's father.

Single parents who refuse to name the other parent have $22 deducted from their benefit every week per child. After 13 weeks, another $6 per family is docked.

The policy was introduced in 1990 to ensure fathers paid child support.

The Labour-led government last year confirmed it would repeal the penalty, saying there was no evidence it worked.

A Ministry of Social Development report - obtained under the Official Information Act - said the government would pay out at least $25 million more a year as a result of ditching the sanction.

Officials warned that cost could balloon, "potentially considerably", if people were then incentivised to rip off the system.

For example, mothers might choose not to name the father so he could avoid paying child support to the Crown and could instead pay her privately under the table.

Acting Minister of Social Development Peeni Henare said the current penalty unfairly punished thousands of children in low-income families.

Peeni Henare. Photo / Rebekah Parsons-King

"We do not believe children in these households should have to foot the bill and be unfairly punished for an absent parent."

He said the $100m figure was an early estimate and the final cost was still being established.

"And while it is a cost and we acknowledge that - it's actually the cost of ensuring sole parents are given their full entitlement."

However, National's social development spokesperson Louise Upston said the report showed the government's policy had a "dark side".

"Vulnerable women will be threatened with all sorts of things not to name the father.

Louise Upston. Photo / Emile Donovan.

"We don't want them under even greater pressure from a dad who should be paying and isn't."

She said the government was making a "very dangerous" move with no alternative.

Auckland Action Against Poverty spokesperson Alastair Russell said the MSD report showed vulnerable families were missing out on $25 million a year that they needed.

"That is money that goes into food, nappies, all the essentials of life that these kids in poverty need."

He said the penalty was an "appalling indictment on the welfare system".

"Punishing mothers for the behaviour or actions of fathers is brainless. It does not work."

Child Poverty Action Group spokesperson Michael O'Brien said the "narrow focus" on cost missed the point.

"Let's have a look at what the costs are to the children and families involved."

And he said National's argument that removing the sanction would increase the pressure on mothers was simply "scaremongering".

"I'm not seeing any real evidence to suggest that has any kind of substantive basis to it."

The MSD report noted that officials looked into the sanction's effectiveness in October 2016 and found it was "unclear" whether it had worked.

"The Ministry does not have sufficient evidence to confirm if the benefit reduction is achieving the policy's intent."

As of March 2017, more than 13,000 sole parents had been penalised, affecting nearly 17,000 children.

An exemption can be granted for reasons such as family violence concerns or the pregnancy being a result of rape or incest.

This article was originally published by RNZ.


Techweek: The mixed bag that is our fledgling gig economy
91500 2018-05-25 14:12:09Z Tech

Techweek: The mixed bag that is our fledgling gig …

by Peter Griffin

The gig economy isn’t yet proving a viable alternative for most people dreaming of being their own boss.

Read more
Be like Mike: Lessons the National Party could learn from Hosking
91478 2018-05-25 07:42:51Z Politics

Be like Mike: Lessons the National Party could lea…

by Graham Adams

Leaders of the National Party come and go, but Mike Hosking endures. Simon Bridges could learn from him.

Read more
M bovis will cost $1 billion - no matter what the solution is
91474 2018-05-25 07:03:24Z Environment

M bovis will cost $1 billion - no matter what the …

by Eric Frykberg

Wrangling over what to do about the cattle disease Mycoplasma bovis is going down to the wire but whatever the solution, it's expected to cost $1b.

Read more
Ireland's abortion referendum:  what you need to know
91404 2018-05-25 00:00:00Z World

Ireland's abortion referendum: what you need to k…

by Claire Pierson

Ireland is holding a referendum later today that could dramatically change its stance on abortion. Here’s a rundown of what's happening and why.

Read more
The royal wedding proves there's 'nothing essentially white about Britishness'
91409 2018-05-25 00:00:00Z Television

The royal wedding proves there's 'nothing essentia…

by Diana Wichtel

There was pomp. There was circumstance. But the union of Prince Harry and Meghan Markle was never going to be a royal wedding as usual.

Read more
How influential artist Michael Parekōwhai is transforming Te Papa
90618 2018-05-25 00:00:00Z Arts

How influential artist Michael Parekōwhai is trans…

by Anthony Byrt

In a rare interview, Michael Parekōwhai opens up about his work, the trauma of loss, and his new installation at Te Papa.

Read more
Top syrah wine picks from New Zealand and abroad
91336 2018-05-25 00:00:00Z Wine

Top syrah wine picks from New Zealand and abroad

by Michael Cooper

Syrah, one of the great grapes of the Rhône Valley, is at home Downunder and these wines prove it.

Read more
Paula Bennett kicked out of House as tempers flare between Speaker and National
91466 2018-05-24 16:32:18Z Politics

Paula Bennett kicked out of House as tempers flare…

by RNZ

There have been testy scenes at Parliament this afternoon during Question Time, with National's deputy leader thrown out of the House.

Read more