Man told he must quit free night class or face benefit cut

by Eva Corlett / 17 May, 2018

Photo: RNZ / Eva Corlett

An unemployed man with depression has been told to quit his free night class or he and his partner won't be able to access full benefits.

The man and his partner, who are parents to an eight-year-old, are taking business classes at Te Wānanga O Aotearoa in Ōtara, South Auckland.

While his partner is eligible for a student allowance, he is not, because he used up his quota years ago.

He has depression and anxiety, so is not seeking work. He is too old for a student loan and he has been told that going on a sickness benefit will affect his partner's benefit, which will leave them struggling.

The man, who asked to remain anonymous, thought that enrolling in a night course would give him confidence and set him up for work or even starting a business.

"It's something that I've always wanted to do, to get more business-minded and to be able to run a business that I'm happy with and my partner's happy with and also maybe grow a legacy with our daughter, but just at the moment it's going nowhere fast."

He has been told by StudyLink that if he and his partner both want to access full benefits, one of them will have to give up their studies.

Work and Income told his Auckland Action Against Poverty advocate that he was not entitled to the student allowance because, at 55, he was too old and had studied in the past.

StudyLink has given them options - his partner can opt for a student loan to boost their money, which will need to be paid back, or his partner could cancel her benefit and live off a total of just over $380 a week for the family.

His other option is to withdraw from study and become a 'dependent partner' - which will boost their income up to just under $500.

He said the system had tunnel vision.

"They're saying, you know 'people should get off the benefit and go and do a job or do a course'.

"So what I am doing? We're doing things the honest way and that's to go out and do a course that is free."

He said stopping study could seriously affect his mental health and the family was already struggling.

"There is nothing positive for us to focus on because our money's just gone. We don't even see our money basically ... and it shouldn't be that way."

He has chosen to stay on the course but isn't getting any support from the government, meaning his family is surviving off his partner's student allowance and the families tax credit - around $340 a week.

If they were allowed to retain their benefits while studying they would have an extra couple of hundred dollars a week.

Beneficiary advocate Alastair Russell, from Auckland Action Against Poverty. Photo / Eva Corlett

The couple's beneficiary advocate Alastair Russell, from Auckland Action Against Poverty, said Work and Income was not putting people first.

"What they are looking at is a rigid interpretation of a set of legislation and ignoring other legislation, which allows them to use discretion to meet this couple's needs.

"The culture within Work and Income remains toxic and we have a government that will not change any of the legislation, which allows Work and Income to act in brutal ways towards people.

"If we don't change the legislation ... we change nothing."

In recent weeks, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has called upon welfare providers to act with kindness and flexibility towards people seeking support.

In a statement, the lead ministry for StudyLink and Work and Income, the Ministry of Social Development, said it would look into the case fully today and make sure the couple get all the support they are entitled to.

A government overhaul of the welfare system has been promised as part of the coalition agreement with the Green Party.

This article was originally published by RNZ.


Wally Haumaha appointment process was 'adequate and fit for purpose'
98982 2018-11-12 12:20:20Z Politics

Wally Haumaha appointment process was 'adequate an…

by Jo Moir

An inquiry into the government's appointment of the deputy police commissioner has found the process was "adequate and fit for purpose''.

Read more
Yellow is Forbidden: A Kiwi director's fashion doco stands apart from the rest
98978 2018-11-12 00:00:00Z Movies

Yellow is Forbidden: A Kiwi director's fashion doc…

by James Robins

China’s foremost fashionista is the subject of Pietra Brettkelly's strikingly beautiful new documentary.

Read more
Philip Temple on his relationship with the great NZ writer Maurice Shadbolt
98324 2018-11-12 00:00:00Z Books

Philip Temple on his relationship with the great N…

by Philip Temple

From his new Maurice Shadbolt biography, Temple writes about why he took on the task of recounting the life of this colourful & controversial figure.

Read more
Why you should raise your child as an intuitive eater
98505 2018-11-12 00:00:00Z Health

Why you should raise your child as an intuitive ea…

by Jennifer Bowden

There’s a balance between schoolkids eating enough for their energy needs and learning to recognise hunger through intuitive eating.

Read more
How Cuba Street became the heart of Wellington's bohemia
98657 2018-11-12 00:00:00Z Travel

How Cuba Street became the heart of Wellington's b…

by Redmer Yska

A once-seedy precinct has become an eclectic mix of cafes and hip retailing, its history celebrated in a new book.

Read more
Aro Valley: The home of Wellington's craft-beer success story
98661 2018-11-12 00:00:00Z Travel

Aro Valley: The home of Wellington's craft-beer su…

by Redmer Yska

Aro Valley is a suitably grungy fit for Garage Project, the darling of Wellington's craft beer scene.

Read more
Riders on the storm: Shared bikes and scooters show the need for new road rules
98668 2018-11-12 00:00:00Z Life in NZ

Riders on the storm: Shared bikes and scooters sho…

by Virginia Larson

With the advent of ride-share scooters and e-bikes, it's time to reconsider the road rules - so everyone can stay safe.

Read more
Armistice Day: Untold stories of the war wounded and those who cared for them
98832 2018-11-11 00:00:00Z History

Armistice Day: Untold stories of the war wounded a…

by Anna Rogers

Anna Rogers gives these groups, often profoundly damaged by war, the recognition they deserve in her centenary history With Them Through Hell.

Read more