Ministry of Social Development staff used false names, fearing client attacks

by Edward Gay / 21 September, 2017

Help us find and write the stories Kiwis need to read

The Social Security Appeal Authority ordered MSD to stop the practice. Photo / Alexander Robertson

Ministry of Social Development staff have used false names on legal documents because they say they fear attacks by volatile clients.

The staff were on the ministry's Benefit Review Committee, which hears complaints from beneficiaries.

The Social Security Appeal Authority told the ministry's chief executive two years ago to stop the practice, but it continued.

The authority has now ordered the ministry to release the names, and referred its decision to the Solicitor General.

MSD chief executive Brendan Boyle. Photo / Pool, Fairfax

Beneficiaries who have a dispute can lodge a complaint with the Benefits Review Committee - an internal ministry panel. If they are not happy with the outcome, they can appeal to the Social Security Appeal Authority.

In March, there was an attempt by a ministry manager to communicate with the authority in secret.

The manager told the authority that ministry staff sitting on the committee used false names to protect their safety and that papers filed previously with the authority contained false names and signatures, without telling the authority.

This was not the first time. The authority had previously criticised the ministry for allowing decision-makers to keep their identities secret, saying it contravened natural justice and was unlawful.

Ministry of Social Development (MSD) chief executive Brendan Boyle gave a personal undertaking that the practice would not continue and apologised.

But it did not stop there.

Appeals continued to be signed by staff using false names and signatures. Initially, Mr Boyle told the authority that it was a staff error, but still the practice continued.

MSD argued the practice was justified in light of two Work and Income staff in Ashburton being murdered in 2014 and the ministry being convicted of health and safety charges as a result.

It said one of the cases before the authority involved a beneficiary who had threatened to kill ministry staff and was abusive.

However, evidence before the authority showed the threatening-to-kill allegation was three years old and the police had assessed the beneficiary as "harmless".

MSD referred that client to a section inside the ministry called the Remote Client Unit, which deals with clients the ministry believes to be dangerous.

The authority found that on one occasion the Remote Client Unit had deliberately misled the ministry's own committee.

In its ruling, the Social Security Appeal Authority said that could not be more serious; it deprived the beneficiary of their legal rights and undermined the department.

The authority said the idea of faceless decision-makers was repugnant. It said if the identities of decision-makers remained secret, they could not be held to account for their decisions.

Under New Zealand law, there are very few cases where the identity of a decision-maker is concealed. One example is national security.

The authority ruled that it believes there is an absolute prohibition on decision-makers being anonymous and Mr Boyle's justification for continuing the process lacked substance.

Its finding has been referred to the Solicitor General, as Crown Law Officer, in a rare move.

A spokesperson for Crown Law confirmed the decision had been received.

In a statement to RNZ, Mr Boyle said he was standing by the decision to anonymise staff names when dealing with what he called "volatile clients".

He said the ministry has taken the authority's decision seriously and it was looking at its legal position.

This article was originally published by RNZ.


Killer robots: The question of how to control lethal autonomous weapons
93876 2018-07-20 08:23:45Z Tech

Killer robots: The question of how to control leth…

by Peter Griffin

The computer scientist who has become a leading voice on the threat posed by killer robots describes himself as an “accidental activist”.

Read more
The man who's making sure performing artists are seen in the regions
93813 2018-07-20 00:00:00Z Theatre

The man who's making sure performing artists are s…

by Elisabeth Easther

For 35 years, Steve Thomas has been at the helm of Arts On Tour, taking musical and theatrical acts from Kaitaia to Stewart Island.

Read more
The Eco Economy: Millennials, money and saving sustainably
93645 2018-07-20 00:00:00Z Economy

The Eco Economy: Millennials, money and saving sus…

by Sharon Stephenson

Millenials are leading the rise of the eco economy.

Read more
Cuba Libre is a new Caribbean-influenced restaurant-bar in Ponsonby
93862 2018-07-19 15:05:51Z Auckland Eats

Cuba Libre is a new Caribbean-influenced restauran…

by Kate Richards

Rum, cigars and Cuban sandwiches are on the menu at new Ponsonby restaurant, Cuba Libre.

Read more
Our plastic recycling efforts will go nowhere without the right information
93822 2018-07-19 00:00:00Z Environment

Our plastic recycling efforts will go nowhere with…

by The Listener

If turns out that some plastics marketed as eco-friendly degrade only to a certain point and often outlive their human recyclers.

Read more
NZ International Film Festival: 50 years of bringing world cinema to our shores
93745 2018-07-19 00:00:00Z Movies

NZ International Film Festival: 50 years of bringi…

by David Larsen

The NZ International Film Festival is 50 years old this year – find out how they choose the line-up from long-standing director Bill Gosden.

Read more
Mary Shelley – movie review
93770 2018-07-19 00:00:00Z Movies

Mary Shelley – movie review

by James Robins

A biopic about writer of Frankenstein turns into lacklustre period piece.

Read more
We need to know more about what’s behind NZ's dire youth-suicide rate
93676 2018-07-19 00:00:00Z Psychology

We need to know more about what’s behind NZ's dire…

by Marc Wilson

New Zealand's youth-suicide rates are the highest in the OECD and the burden falls heavily on Māori and Pasifika peoples.

Read more