The nurses' pay dispute has put the Government in a tricky situation

by The Listener / 31 May, 2018
RelatedArticlesModule - Nurses NZ

Photo/Getty Images

The Ardern administration knows that time's up on the pay gap, but nurses must be wary of squandering public goodwill with stories of anxious patients during strike action.

The Government has been blunt with private-sector employers: wages should and will rise under its watch, and if they can’t afford to pay staff enough in this new climate, then they’ll be out of business.

The current nurses’ pay dispute gives this administration a chance to lead by example – albeit without the threatened corollary. Hospitals will not be left to go out of business. But Workplace Relations and Safety Minister Iain Lees-Galloway has been adamant about the imperative to pay workers more than we have been doing, not only as a matter of decency but also as an unavoidable cost, like any other, of doing business.

Given this tough rhetoric, the Government has little choice but to ensure the district health boards meet nurses’ demands with a fair offer. Nurses are not low-paid, but are a highly qualified and indispensable workforce. Yet pay in the profession, which is still dominated by women, lags behind other sectors of the workforce.

The current, apparently generous, offer from the boards does not do quite enough to redress this. The proposed $500 million increase to base rates, to be brought in over 15 months, would leave nurses still well behind the growth in the median pay rate since 2008. Median pay has grown 31% in the past decade; nurses’ 19%. Using that same measurement, teachers are 11% ahead of nurses, and they’re currently asking for a 14% pay rise.

The politics are tough for the Government, especially given its reluctance to upset business, which is traditionally hostile to Labour-led administrations. However, it is relatively easy to be generous with taxpayers’ money. It is often not so easy for small businesses – which include many GPs – to display the same largesse. How is that extra expense covered other than from their own pockets, or by charging their patients more?

The nurses’ settlement, wherever it ends up, cannot be seen in isolation. The implications of a generous settlement, especially in other parts of the health sector, are real and, for some, genuinely troubling. Even a settlement at the DHBs’ current proposed rate will unsettle the private sector by increasing pressure for pay rises in the rest of the workforce. But there are signs our society is taking a fresh look at both pay equity and at what constitutes a decent wage.

It’s significant that even for the business-friendly National Party, one of the biggest boasts it has made of its stewardship of health was that low-paid care workers won a significant pay rise. Never mind that it was forced upon the previous Government after court action sponsored by the E tū union; the fact remains that National came to see the virtue of paying a higher wage to a group of mostly women workers.

Only someone who has never been a caregiver would describe the occupation as unskilled. In fact, it requires considerable skill to do well but caregivers had been lagging so far behind men doing similar jobs in the workforce that the catch-up was conspicuously overdue.

The worldwide rumblings set off by the #MeToo movement have focused attention on women’s rights in every sphere to the point that achieving pay equity for female workers is surely on any government’s to-do list.

The DHBs have understandably highlighted their offer’s upside: nurses with just five years’ experience could earn at least $90,000 a year, once overtime and sundry add-ons are counted. The nurses’ claims are just one of a slew of rising costs that DHBs face, and will always face. Chief among them are rising pharmaceutical prices: blow the budget on nurses, and there’s less in the kitty for other therapies. Balancing these competing demands for limited finance is never easy – for governments, DHBs or any employers. The demands on public money are bottomless. The purse is not.

Surely one part of the package the Government should consider is making limited compensation, as happens in cities such as London, for the cost of living in Auckland, whether the workers be nurses, teachers or police. That would help alleviate recruitment problems.

As this winter’s flu season hits, nurses need to be mindful not to erode their high level of public trust with industrial action that stretches goodwill too far. Front-page photos of anxious patients and stories of cancelled operations have the potential to dent the image of a profession held in high regard, and of workers New Zealanders believe should get a fair deal.

This article was first published in the June 9, 2018 issue of the New Zealand Listener.


In a Time of Monsters: Emma Sky's attempt to shed light on the Middle East
108292 2019-07-24 00:00:00Z Books

In a Time of Monsters: Emma Sky's attempt to shed…

by Peter Calder

A diary of adventures in the volatile Middle East is diverting but hardly illuminating, writes Peter Calder.

Read more
The sum of our fears: The literature of climate change
108842 2019-07-24 00:00:00Z Books

The sum of our fears: The literature of climate ch…

by Jenny Nicholls

The most interesting books on climate change.

Read more
The bad news about tattoo removal
108205 2019-07-24 00:00:00Z Health

The bad news about tattoo removal

by Ruth Nichol

Tattoo regret is rising, but removal of the offending ink isn’t painless – for the person or their pocket.

Read more
Former inmate Paul Wood's insights on improving NZ's criminal-justice system
108325 2019-07-23 00:00:00Z Profiles

Former inmate Paul Wood's insights on improving NZ…

by Clare de Lore

As the Government spends millions reforming the criminal-justice system, Paul Wood says crime would be reduced if we taught our children emotional...

Read more
Camino Skies: An inspiring Kiwi doco about grief and determination
108733 2019-07-23 00:00:00Z Movies

Camino Skies: An inspiring Kiwi doco about grief a…

by Russell Baillie

A New Zealand-made documentary about those who walk the 800km Camino trail is heartbreaking, blistering and terrific.

Read more
Funny As is a hilarious and horrifying look at NZ's comedy history
108591 2019-07-23 00:00:00Z Television

Funny As is a hilarious and horrifying look at NZ'…

by Fiona Rae

Five-part series Funny As: The Story of New Zealand Comedy shows just how far our humour has come.

Read more
Eyes front: My advice for those seeking retinal surgery
108209 2019-07-23 00:00:00Z Health

Eyes front: My advice for those seeking retinal su…

by Mark Broatch

If flashes of light or spooky shadows suddenly appear in your vision, see your optician or doctor without delay.

Read more
Jacinda Ardern supports, does not commit to 'climate emergency' declaration
108769 2019-07-23 00:00:00Z Planet

Jacinda Ardern supports, does not commit to 'clima…

by Jo Moir

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has stopped short of committing to a declaration of climate emergency in Parliament.

Read more