Voluntourism: When charity does more harm than good

by The Listener / 21 September, 2017

Help us find and write the stories Kiwis need to read

RelatedArticlesModule - Voluntourism

Photo/Getty Images

Some of the world’s poorest children are taken from their families and used as bait for the booming business of feel-good “voluntourism”.

It will have come as a shock to all those well-intentioned school and university students who’ve taken pride in doing volunteer work in orphanages abroad to learn that they’ve been doing more harm than good.

Few will have an inkling of it, but it transpires that kind-hearted Kiwis – retired people among them – have been part of an insidious system whereby the world’s poorest children are used as bait for the booming business of feel-good “voluntourism”.

The world’s biggest organiser of charity-aid tourism, World Challenge, has just stopped sending students to work in orphanages in Asia, accepting the mounting scientific and academic evidence that it is a very damaging practice.

Global agency Rethink Orphanages underlines this with renewed pleas to stop young students, including New Zealanders, embarking on this superficially charitable practice. The trips have been marketed to students as a learning and compassion-building experience. But although the volunteers are rewarded with hugs and selfies, the harsh truth is that the children are left with instability and loss and inevitably suffer when the volunteers leave. Every farewell to a kind worker with whom they have bonded exacerbates the little ones’ emotionally crippling attachment disorders.

Worse, volunteers may unknowingly aid bogus child-farming operations that are designed as magnets for tourist dollars without any sincere focus on the children’s welfare and often rife with cruelty and sexual abuse. Children desperate for love and affection are vulnerable to those who seek to exploit them.

JK Rowling. Photo/Getty Images

Even were all these orphanages bona fide charities, there’s now overwhelming evidence of their harm. One academic monograph drawn from multiple studies of orphanages in many countries confirms “children exposed to institutional care do not receive the type of nurturing and stimulating environment needed for healthy psychological development”. And yet they abound. The Cambodian Government reports the number of orphanages within its borders has increased by an extraordinary 75% since 2005, when the influx of Western tourists began.

There simply are no good orphanages, according to author and philanthropist JK Rowling, who has researched the options through her child-development charity Lumos. Rowling found study after study detailing the harm even well-run institutions do to children, and was further appalled at the scams where children are treated as commodities by unscrupulous operators. Commenting last year, she said she was often asked to use her hefty Twitter influence to encourage volunteerism. “I will never retweet appeals that use poor children as an opportunity to enhance Westerners’ CVs.”

Agencies such as Unicef and Save the Children have long warned of the perverse effects of Western charity in creating a cruel money chain for the lucrative warehousing of children. They estimate as few as one in five institutionalised “orphan” children worldwide are in fact without a parent. Most are “bought” from impoverished parents for cash, or promises of better education, and used as bait for cash from tourists and charities.

Developmentally, the children would be better off with family members, however poor. Attachment is crucial for brain and social development. The West has long realised this, leading to the decline of anything resembling orphanages. This, on reflection, makes “voluntourism” in poor countries’ orphanages the more perverse; akin to visiting child zoos. Orphaned children or state wards in nations such as ours are rarely kept in group “homes”, and then only for minimal periods, precisely because the lack of personal care and affection is disastrous for them. Foster care and whanau placement are what help children thrive.

The challenge now is to redirect the money flow. Well-meaning tourists and donors, universities and schools must reassess their generosity and volunteering choices, backing programmes that strengthen access to healthcare, education and work in poor communities, and which incentivise loving and consistent family bonds.

Arguments that orphanages are still necessary in poor countries are challenged by Lumos’s success in assisting Moldova, Europe’s poorest state, reduce its incidence of institutionalising children by 70% in 10 years. It has helped achieve similarly dramatic falls in parts of the Czech Republic and Bulgaria.

As Rowling says, the solution is not comfier, jollier orphanages. “It is my dream that, within my lifetime, the very concept of taking a child away from its family and locking it away will seem to belong to a cruel, fictional world.”

This editorial was first published in the September 30, 2017 issue of the New Zealand Listener.

Latest

With friends like Donald Trump, who needs enemies?
93834 2018-07-21 00:00:00Z World

With friends like Donald Trump, who needs enemies?…

by Paul Thomas

The US President treats his Western allies to a tongue-lashing while cosying up to Vladimir Putin, causing alarm at home and around the world.

Read more
Who Is America? is predictably alarming – and scarily relevant
93831 2018-07-21 00:00:00Z Television

Who Is America? is predictably alarming – and scar…

by Diana Wichtel

Only Bernie Sanders comes out unscathed in Sacha Baron Cohen’s absurdist new series Who Is America?

Read more
Organic wine is getting bigger in New Zealand. These are our top picks
93885 2018-07-21 00:00:00Z Wine

Organic wine is getting bigger in New Zealand. The…

by Michael Cooper

Quality rather than quantity drives New Zealand's organic wine producers.

Read more
Killer robots: The question of how to control lethal autonomous weapons
93876 2018-07-20 08:23:45Z Tech

Killer robots: The question of how to control leth…

by Peter Griffin

The computer scientist who has become a leading voice on the threat posed by killer robots describes himself as an “accidental activist”.

Read more
The man who's making sure performing artists are seen in the regions
93813 2018-07-20 00:00:00Z Theatre

The man who's making sure performing artists are s…

by Elisabeth Easther

For 35 years, Steve Thomas has been at the helm of Arts On Tour, taking musical and theatrical acts from Kaitaia to Stewart Island.

Read more
The Eco Economy: Millennials, money and saving sustainably
93645 2018-07-20 00:00:00Z Economy

The Eco Economy: Millennials, money and saving sus…

by Sharon Stephenson

Millenials are leading the rise of the eco economy.

Read more
Cuba Libre is a new Caribbean-influenced restaurant-bar in Ponsonby
93862 2018-07-19 15:05:51Z Auckland Eats

Cuba Libre is a new Caribbean-influenced restauran…

by Kate Richards

Rum, cigars and Cuban sandwiches are on the menu at new Ponsonby restaurant, Cuba Libre.

Read more
Our plastic recycling efforts will go nowhere without the right information
93822 2018-07-19 00:00:00Z Environment

Our plastic recycling efforts will go nowhere with…

by The Listener

If turns out that some plastics marketed as eco-friendly degrade only to a certain point and often outlive their human recyclers.

Read more