New pizza eatery La Trattoria takes the reins from Il Buco

by Kate Richards / 12 April, 2018
La Trattoria

The cheese and toppings at new all day eatery La Trattoria are laid on thick, Roman-style.

New Ponsonby all-day eatery La Trattoria blends South America and Italy 

Despite changing names from Il Buco to La Trattoria and being under new management, on the surface everything is much the same at Ponsonby’s dinkiest pizza parlour: The pizzas are still square and cooked to order in an electric oven. They still cost $6 and the first bite will still burn the roof of your mouth, badly. Coffee comes from Karangahape Rd favourite Eighthirty, and you still have to stand or eat outside if you’re having in. But looks can be deceiving. The pies have changed.

New owner Santiago de los Reyes is from Uruguay, South America, where the concept of pizza was brought by Italian migrants at the end of the 19th Century. Slightly south of his home country, in Argentina, almost 60% of the population is of Italian descent, making it one of the most Italian-influenced countries in the world. Pizza’s a big deal to him.

The slices served in Uruguay and Argentina, and at Reyes’ shop, are Roman-style – thick bases and lots of toppings – similar to the ones Il Buco owner Johnny Caracciolo used to offer. Reyes was a regular at the shop and friendly with Caracciolo, so when the opportunity to take the keys presented itself he took it, and gave the food a subtle new spin.


Alfajores, crumbly butter cookies with dulce de leche, and other sweet treats are also on offer.

Let’s start with the cheese – a crucial element of most pizza, but imperative on a South American pizza. Reyes says the right amount is roughly 400 grams for every 12 inches of dough. I thought he meant 40 grams, but then he said this: “we have a saying at home about what we eat – meat, fat, flour. Yeah, they eat pretty badly in Uruguay.” Reyes has been working with Clevedon-based cheesemaker Massimo Lubisco on a cow’s milk mozzarella which he orders every few days to keep it fresh. The cheese only keeps for 10 days at a time; thankfully he’s tearing through it.

Classic Roman-style dough is cold-proved for up to 90 hours; Reyes proves his for 12-ish hours in the fridge, the cool temperatures preventing shrinkage in the pan. It’s rolled slightly thicker than Neapolitan pizza, but isn’t heavy. There are 11 topping combinations, including two vegan options, and one of the bases comes stuffed with ham. Reyes plans to change the menu regularly.

What’s most important to note, however, is that a couple of slices of pizza here are still one of the best lunch deals in Auckland. If you have room after that, you should also try a slice of ricotta cake. Filled with rum-soaked raisins and whipped ricotta, it’s made to Reyes’ grandma’s recipe and goes great with a cup of black coffee. 

La Trattoria
113 Ponsonby Rd


Auckland waterfront stadium plans revealed
97933 2018-10-19 06:34:37Z Auckland Issues

Auckland waterfront stadium plans revealed

by Rowan Quinn

Plans for a 50,000-seat waterfront stadium in downtown Auckland that would replace Eden Park have been revealed.

Read more
The eclectic range of Kiwi composer Rhian Sheehan
97711 2018-10-19 00:00:00Z Music

The eclectic range of Kiwi composer Rhian Sheehan

by James Belfield

Rhian Sheehan is hitting the road with a collection of intimate tracks – a world removed from soundtracks for theme parks and virtual-reality games.

Read more
Anika Moa's celebrity takes the back seat on soul-baring new LP
97774 2018-10-19 00:00:00Z Music

Anika Moa's celebrity takes the back seat on soul-…

by James Belfield

Anika Moa says she only ever shares “about 5% of what and who I am”. Her new album says otherwise.

Read more
There's only one way to deal with the undignifying symptoms of chronic illnesses
97788 2018-10-19 00:00:00Z Nutrition

There's only one way to deal with the undignifying…

by Ruth Nichol

After she was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis, Shona Daubé learned how to live with chronic illness with a smile.

Read more
50 great Auckland restaurants where you can eat well for less than $50
94144 2018-10-19 00:00:00Z Auckland Eats

50 great Auckland restaurants where you can eat we…

by Metro

Here are 50 Auckland restaurants to try that won't break the bank – and tips on what you should order.

Read more
Notes from Cambodia: Is the young democracy sliding back towards dictatorship?
93903 2018-10-19 00:00:00Z Travel

Notes from Cambodia: Is the young democracy slidin…

by James Borrowdale

James Borrowdale looks beneath the shiny surface of modern capitalism in Cambodia.

Read more
Jami-Lee Ross' deeply ugly practice of taping could still snare Simon Bridges
97923 2018-10-18 14:50:17Z Politics

Jami-Lee Ross' deeply ugly practice of taping coul…

by Jane Clifton

First it was: follow the money. Now it’s cherchez la femme. Wherever the Jami-Lee Ross conflagration takes us next, Ross will go down in history.

Read more
Stop the truck! Pūhā & Pākehā gets a new Grey Lynn home
97905 2018-10-18 11:55:17Z Auckland Eats

Stop the truck! Pūhā & Pākehā gets a new Grey Lynn…

by Kate Richards

Founders of popular food truck Pūhā & Pākehā have opened up an eatery in Surrey Crescent offering new interpretations of traditional Māori cuisine.

Read more