Fruit juice shows that not all plant-based diets are healthy

by Jennifer Bowden / 10 December, 2017

Photo/Getty Images

If you believe fruit fibre floating in a glass of fresh juice makes it any less sugary, you’re mistaken.

QUESTIONIn a past column on sugar in fruit versus juice, you noted that the sugar in fruit is encapsulated by the cell wall. I presume in the process of making juice, the cells are broken. So if fruit juice contains pulp, does this mean the integrity of the cells is maintained? Or is the act of squeezing an orange sufficient to disrupt the cell walls?

ANSWER: It’s a modern conundrum – although plant-based diets are recommended for good health, not all plant-based foods are healthy. A recent study found that a diet that emphasises less-healthy plant foods is associated with a higher risk of coronary heart disease. So, which plant foods are dodgy?

In a major US study, researchers tracked 200,000 adults over 20 years and found those who stuck to a diet rich in such foods as whole grains, fruits, vegetables, nuts and legumes had a significantly lower heart disease risk than people who consumed less-wholesome plant foods. The less-healthy foods included fruit juices, refined grains, potatoes, fries and sweets, reported the Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

Fries and refined grains are well known to be less than healthy, but it’s a surprise to many people that juice squeezed from a fresh, wholesome piece of fruit could be bad for us.

All fruit contains sugars, along with vitamins, minerals and dietary fibre. So why is the sugar in fruit okay but the sugar in fruit juice a problem?

In fruit’s natural state, the sugars are neatly contained within the cells of the fruit pulp. Studies suggest the fibre in whole fruits may slow emptying of the stomach and therefore how quickly the sugars are absorbed into the circulation.

A slower, more gradual rise in blood-sugar levels is preferable as that is linked to a reduced risk of developing type 2 diabetes and heart disease; it may also help with healthy weight maintenance.

Chewing a piece of fruit releases the sugars in the juice from the cellular structure. In contrast, when the fruit is squeezed, the pulp structure is broken to release the fruit juice containing the sugars. Even if juice contains some pulp, its removal from the fruit indicates cells have been disrupted. The sugars in the resulting juice are then absorbed more quickly.

On top of that, several pieces of fruit typically go into a glass of juice, providing a much bigger sugar hit than eating a single orange, say.

Fruit is best enjoyed just the way nature intended – whole from the plant.

This article was first published in the November 4, 2017 issue of the New Zealand Listener.

Latest

Why is there a massive table down at the Auckland Viaduct?
90168 2018-04-27 09:30:58Z Urbanism

Why is there a massive table down at the Auckland …

by Vomle Springford

If you’ve been along the waterfront lately, you may have noticed a rather large blue table at the Eastern Viaduct.

Read more
The Handmaid's Tale season two extends the novel in the #MeToo moment
90164 2018-04-27 09:02:44Z Television

The Handmaid's Tale season two extends the novel i…

by Linda Wight

The second season of Handmaid's Tale promises to continue to disturb - and inspire.

Read more
The dubious justice of jailhouse confessions
90153 2018-04-27 07:27:24Z Crime

The dubious justice of jailhouse confessions

by Mike White

Prison informants should be considered the most untrustworthy of all witnesses, but NZ police and prosecutors still resort to them when desperate.

Read more
Why young South Koreans are sceptical about reunification
90126 2018-04-27 00:00:00Z World

Why young South Koreans are sceptical about reunif…

by Francine Chen

Despite North Korea’s recent diplomatic overtures, young South Koreans believe reunification is an unlikely prospect in their lifetimes.

Read more
How Kimbra's Primal Heart was shaped by New York and Ethiopia
90120 2018-04-27 00:00:00Z Music

How Kimbra's Primal Heart was shaped by New York a…

by James Belfield

After visiting Ethiopia, I decided I needed to be around that energy where I could feel vitality all around me, says pop star Kimbra.

Read more
Why you crave junk food and how to make it stop
89472 2018-04-27 00:00:00Z Nutrition

Why you crave junk food and how to make it stop

by Jennifer Bowden

When it comes to eating junk food, unaddressed hunger and fatigue do come back to bite us.

Read more
Top wine picks from Nelson and Canterbury
90133 2018-04-27 00:00:00Z Wine

Top wine picks from Nelson and Canterbury

by Michael Cooper

Nelson and Canterbury are far smaller in terms of their vinous output than Marlborough, but they certainly hold their own in terms of quality.

Read more
The Law Society's #MeToo (But Not Just Yet) moment
90144 2018-04-26 14:40:52Z Social issues

The Law Society's #MeToo (But Not Just Yet) moment…

by The Listener

The Law Society is investigating a female lawyer, but silent about how it’s dealing with sexual misconduct matters.

Read more