Are antidepressant pills really effective?

by Marc Wilson / 23 March, 2018
RelatedArticlesModule - Anti-depressant pills

Photo/Getty Images

Johann Hari is right about some things, but effective depression treatment means casting a wide net. 

“Prediction is not explanation,” I was once told. Women are more likely to vote for Labour, study for PhDs in art history and get depressed, but that doesn’t mean it is because they’re women.

About 10% of us will experience depression, and Johann Hari’s new book is a personal account of a journalist’s search for insight into his own experience.

Hari makes several headline-worthy claims. He urges us, for example, not to accept uncritically that depression is caused by lopsided brain chemistry, specifically levels of the neurotransmitter serotonin, and that routine drug treatment is the only option. He writes that depression has multiple “causes” that have nothing to do with our brains, including life experience, in the past and present.

Most controversially, he argues that prescriptions for medication to treat depression aren’t worth the paper they’re written on, and we should throw our therapeutic nets wider.

The science of prediction is relevant here. We know that depression is about 50% heritable, or genetic: if you have a close family member with major depression, you’re two to three times as likely to develop major depression as someone who does not. This is true of most psychiatric conditions: family history is a predictor of risk.

But not everyone with this genetic risk goes on to develop the disorder. Think of it as having a switch that doesn’t get flipped unless the conditions – such as life experience, for example – are right. Having that genetic risk and bad stuff going down makes Jack (or Jill) much more likely to become a sad boy (or girl).

If antidepressants increase the levels in the brain of such chemicals as serotonin, do serotonin levels predict depressed mood? We can’t directly delve into brains to see, but what we can do is deplete these brain chemicals by interfering with or blocking the process that produces them and seeing if mood changes. And that’s exactly what happens, particularly for men with a family history of depression.

If lowering levels of these brain chemicals lowers mood, does putting them in make you happier? Is it true, as Hari suggests and the Verve song insists, that “the drugs don’t work”? And if they do work, is it only because they have a placebo effect? The way to test this is to treat two groups of depressed people, one with a placebo, the other with an antidepressant, and see what happens.

Hari reports, accurately, that 20-40% of 10 people given a sugar pill will report feeling better. But 40-60% of those 10 who get an antidepressant feel better. The evidence is unequivocal that antidepressants do work and they work better than a sugar pill. But not everyone will feel better, whether they got the real or the pretend pill.

As good as a pill, though – and better if you consider side effects – is talk therapy. The prevailing view is that talk therapy is as effective as medication. An important thing these reviews obscure is that therapy may help people for whom the drugs don’t work, and maybe vice versa. We’re not very good at working out what works best for whom.

Regardless, if Hari was never asked what else might be going on for him, he never spoke to a good health professional. I defy anyone who’s been to see a clinical psychologist for more than a couple of sessions to swear they weren’t asked about their lives.

In short, Hari is right about some things, but his central claims that people treat depression as if it’s all about brains and that drugs are used as the only treatment even though they don’t work are wrong. Prediction isn’t explanation: I don’t feel confident that we’ve explained depression, but that doesn’t mean we don’t know how to help most people who experience it.

Marc Wilson is a Victoria University psychology professor and Listener columnist.

This article was first published in the March 3, 2018 issue of the New Zealand Listener.

Latest

How NZ women won the right to vote first: The original disruptors & spiteful MPs
96463 2018-09-19 00:00:00Z History

How NZ women won the right to vote first: The orig…

by Vomle Springford

Is it right that while the loafer, the gambler, the drunkard, and even the wife-beater has a vote, earnest, educated and refined women are denied it?

Read more
Fémmina: The story of NZ's unsung suffrage provocateur Mary Ann Müller
96479 2018-09-19 00:00:00Z History

Fémmina: The story of NZ's unsung suffrage provoca…

by Cathie Bell

Mary Ann Müller was fighting for women’s rights before Kate Sheppard even arrived here, but her pioneering contribution to the cause is little known.

Read more
How Marilyn Waring went from political prodigy to international influencer
96505 2018-09-19 00:00:00Z Profiles

How Marilyn Waring went from political prodigy to …

by Clare de Lore

Marilyn Waring is nearing the last chapter of an account of her time as an MP, which ended abruptly with the calling of a snap election.

Read more
Ian McKellen charms his way through a documentary about his life
96472 2018-09-19 00:00:00Z Movies

Ian McKellen charms his way through a documentary …

by James Robins

Joe Stephenson’s tender documentary Playing the Part looks at McKellen's life as an actor, activist and perpetual wizard.

Read more
The Chosen Bun: A smart new burger joint opens in Stonefields
96507 2018-09-19 00:00:00Z Auckland Eats

The Chosen Bun: A smart new burger joint opens in …

by Alex Blackwood

Burgers, milkshakes and fries are not rare things to find in Auckland, so The Chosen Bun's owners were smart to be very picky about their ingredients.

Read more
The brutality experienced by the suffragettes
11636 2018-09-19 00:00:00Z Listener NZ 2015

The brutality experienced by the suffragettes

by Sally Blundell

As we mark 125 years since NZ women got the right to vote, we must remember it didn't come easily.

Read more
The case for closing prisons
96403 2018-09-18 00:00:00Z Social issues

The case for closing prisons

by Paul Little

If we want a prison system that does a better job than the current one, alternatives aren’t hard to find.

Read more
Jennifer Curtin: The feminist political scientist mixing rugby with politics
96422 2018-09-18 00:00:00Z Profiles

Jennifer Curtin: The feminist political scientist …

by Clare de Lore

Australian-New Zealander Jennifer Curtin says the lopsided nature of the Bledisloe Cup pales in comparison to the slump in transtasman relations.

Read more