How politicians' words influence other people's actions

by Marc Wilson / 13 November, 2018
RelatedArticlesModule - Politicians words influence actions

Photo/Getty Images

Politicians like to pretend their words don’t influence others’ actions, but if that’s so, why utter them?

In recent weeks, US President Donald Trump has said he’ll cut taxes for the middle class and bring the price of medicines down. He’s stated he’ll remove birthright citizenship and that refugee caravans include killers and other ne’er-do-wells.

It’s this last that has got him in even more hot water than usual, fuelling claims that, by normalising xenophobia, he is indirectly responsible for the actions of Robert Bowers, the man arrested for killing 11 people at the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh.

The shootings came on top of a series of pipe bombs sent to prominent Trump opponents, including Hillary Clinton, allegedly by Floridian Cesar Sayoc, a bloke who claims native American heritage and has a van festooned with symbols referencing the Ku Klux Klan.

Nope, Trump says, his inflammatory shouts of “lock her [Hillary] up” and “fake news” have nothing to do with these actions.

Closer to home, Judith Collins was variously accused of trolling – or inciting others to troll – the couple featured in the Government’s recent KiwiBuild public-relations exercise, questioning whether they should have been eligible for the scheme. She denied any wrongdoing.

I’m not putting Collins in the same ballpark as Trump. My focus is politicians’ routine denial that words can influence other people’s actions. I think I have a knock-down argument that proves them wrong. At least, I think I have one that proves they don’t believe their own press on this one. If words don’t influence actions, why do they spend pots of cash on political advertising? Why stump at all during elections? Why open your mouth at all, because people are going to think and do whatever it is they do with nary a hint of persuasion?

Trump and Collins have in common that they blimmin’ well hope their words make a difference. “Words don’t matter” is clearly rubbish. It’s deluded, hypocritical, or a marker of self-serving inconsistency.

What do we know about persuasion? I can recommend the book Yes! 50 Scientifically Proven Ways to be Persuasive, by Robert Cialdini, Noah Goldstein and Steve Martin. It’s a good pop-psych intro to decades of research on getting people to do or buy what you want.

I’m pretty sure that it’s not that Steve Martin –  you know, the actor who also plays the ukulele. The real name-drop here is Cialdini – he’s been around for a long time and is a big deal in persuasion literature. A man so famous in my circles that he doesn’t even have a Google Scholar profile.

Cialdini’s best-known book is one of his first: Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion.

Cialdini distilled persuasion down to six principles, which he is said to have gleaned from several years of sneaking around used-car lots, sales rooms and charity organisations. These might have been hot stuff in the 80s but I bet they’re foundational for anyone who wants to get into marketing now.

In some ways, they’re not rocket science. If you give someone something small, they’re more likely to do something bigger when you next ask (reciprocity). The less of something there is, the more desirable it appears (scarcity). When you’re trying to make a decision, people you think are experts are more likely to persuade you (authority), as are people you like (likeability). People will trust you to do in the future what you’ve done in the past (consistency), and they’ll look at what other people are doing if they’re uncertain what they should do (consensus).

You can see these principles in hotel rooms (90% of guests recycle their towels) and in doctors displaying their degrees on the wall. Trump’s midterms campaign slogan? “Promises made, promises kept.” If I give you a 10% tax cut, then you’ll vote for me …

This article was first published in the November 17, 2018 issue of the New Zealand Listener.


Dear Oliver: A son's poignant tribute to his mother
93895 2018-12-13 00:00:00Z Books

Dear Oliver: A son's poignant tribute to his mothe…

by Peter Wells

A reminder that nothing can really prepare us for the death of a beloved parent.

Read more
Big Little Lies author does it again in Nine Perfect Strangers
100041 2018-12-13 00:00:00Z Books

Big Little Lies author does it again in Nine Perfe…

by Catherine Woulfe

The new book by Liane Moriarty can induce cravings despite its health retreat setting.

Read more
Barbershop confidential: Nelson's Man Cave offers more than just haircuts
99534 2018-12-13 00:00:00Z Psychology

Barbershop confidential: Nelson's Man Cave offers …

by Fiona Terry

In Nelson, there’s a place where modern “cavemen” can go to be groomed, chill out to music, and find someone to tell their troubles to.

Read more
The Listener's 50 Best Champagnes of 2018
100190 2018-12-13 00:00:00Z Wine

The Listener's 50 Best Champagnes of 2018

by Michael Cooper

Celebrate the festive season with sparkling wines from Central Otago to Champagne, priced from $10 to $125.

Read more
Win a double pass to Vice, the new Dick Cheney movie
100368 2018-12-12 10:44:10Z Win

Win a double pass to Vice, the new Dick Cheney mov…

by The Listener

Oscar-winning writer-director Adam McKay brings his trademark wit to the true story of US Vice President Dick Cheney in Vice.

Read more
End of an era: Auckland's independent film library Videon to shut its doors
100360 2018-12-12 10:00:59Z Small business

End of an era: Auckland's independent film library…

by Alex Blackwood

An iconic Auckland store is closing.

Read more
Michael Moore takes on Trump with fire and fury in Fahrenheit 11/9
100230 2018-12-12 00:00:00Z Movies

Michael Moore takes on Trump with fire and fury in…

by James Robins

The conflagration that gave the US President Trump is traced to September 2001.

Read more
10 ideas for the perfect summer Christmas menu
100210 2018-12-12 00:00:00Z Food

10 ideas for the perfect summer Christmas menu

by Lauraine Jacobs

Seafood stars in the entrée courses before turkey takes centre stage, with all the trimmings, to be followed by a fantastic fruity pudding.

Read more