Mankading, it's just not cricket

by Paul Thomas / 13 April, 2019
The MCC first agreed, then disagreed, with the dismisssal of Jos Buttler that sparked furious debate. Photo/Getty Images

The MCC first agreed, then disagreed, with the dismisssal of Jos Buttler that sparked furious debate. Photo/Getty Images

RelatedArticlesModule - mankading cricket

The Indian Premier League’s first mankading case has exercised the cricketing gods.

In the 1964 US Supreme Court decision Jacobellis v Ohio, Justice Potter Stewart wrote that, while he wouldn’t attempt to define hard-core pornography, “I know it when I see it”.

Like most of his colleagues, Stewart decided pornography was nowhere to be found in the work in question, Louis Malle’s 1958 film The Lovers. Given The Lovers had won the Special Jury prize at the Venice Film Festival, the fact that it wasn’t pornography was presumably evident to most people outside the American Midwest.

Although Stewart was applauded by some for bringing common sense to bear, others questioned whether a legal ruling should be made on the basis of one’s personal reaction. Sport often has similar debates when the “spirit of the game” is evoked or comes into conflict with the game’s laws.

In cricket, “mankading” – after Vinoo Mankad, an Indian all-rounder of the 1940s and 50s – occurs when the batter at the non-striker’s end leaves the crease before the bowler has released the ball and the bowler, rather than going through with the delivery, removes the bails, thereby effecting a run-out.

Although mankading is within the laws, it has traditionally been regarded as not in the spirit of the game, particularly if the bowler hasn’t forewarned the batter that they’re putting themselves at risk. However, the growth of short-form cricket prompted a partial rethink, with some arguing that, in an era of increasingly aggressive running between wickets and in formats in which every run counts, batters were exploiting the spirt of the game to give themselves a head start.

Hence, in 2017, the Marylebone Cricket Club (MCC), the custodian of the game’s laws, tweaked this particular law to emphasise “the importance of the non-striker remaining in their ground until the ball is released”.

Nevertheless, furious debate ensued when Englishman Jos Buttler recently became the first player to be mankaded in 12 seasons of the Indian Premier League. One of the best limited-overs batsmen in the game, Buttler had made 69 off 43 balls and was steering the Rajasthan Royals to a comfortable victory when he was mankaded by the Kings XI Punjab captain and Indian spinner Ravi Ashwin. The Royals promptly collapsed, losing seven wickets in quick succession, and ended up losing by 14 runs.

Angry words were exchanged on the field and in the media between those who believed Ashwin had violated the spirit of the game and those who insisted the law is the law is the law.

An unapologetic Ashwin went further, effectively dismissing the very notion of the spirit of the game: “I don’t understand the point of sporting spirit, because it’s within the rules.” That drew a sharp rebuke from the Board of Control for Cricket in India, which labelled the practice “shady … akin to back-stabbing” and warned Ashwin to keep both the spirit and the laws of the game in mind.

The critical component in this grey area is surely intent: did the bowler approach the wicket fully intending to send down a delivery or was he looking for an opportunity to mankad? Was the batter seeking an unfair advantage or did he just get his timing wrong? Although Ashwin claimed his act was “pretty instinctive”, slow-motion footage suggests premeditation on his part and absent-mindedness, rather than nefarious intent, on Buttler’s.

And although the controversy involved a clash between the laws and the spirit of the game, it would have been defused had the law been correctly applied. After initially declaring that Buttler had no one to blame but himself, the MCC did a U-turn: “We believe the pause was too long between the time Ashwin reached the crease and the moment it was reasonable to expect the ball to be delivered. When Buttler could have reasonably expected the ball to be delivered, he was in his ground.” Therefore, he should have been given not out.

Oh, and by the way, “after further reflection, we don’t think it was within the spirit of the game”.

This article was first published in the April 13, 2019 issue of the New Zealand Listener.

Latest

Medical specialist and writer Eileen Merriman's prescription for success
104920 2019-04-25 00:00:00Z Profiles

Medical specialist and writer Eileen Merriman's pr…

by Clare de Lore

Eileen Merriman doesn’t have to dig too deep to find the angst, humour and drama for her award-winning novels.

Read more
We still remember them: The best in new Anzac Day reading
105020 2019-04-25 00:00:00Z Books

We still remember them: The best in new Anzac Day…

by Russell Baillie

The tide of great New Zealand books on the world wars shows no sign of going out. Russell Baillie reviews four new Anzac books.

Read more
Fine lines: New Anzac books and graphic novels for kids
105028 2019-04-25 00:00:00Z Books

Fine lines: New Anzac books and graphic novels for…

by Ann Packer

A telegraph “boy”, heroic animals and even shell-shock make for engaging reads for children.

Read more
Keeping up appearances: The challenging job of restoring NZ's lighthouses
104978 2019-04-25 00:00:00Z Life in NZ

Keeping up appearances: The challenging job of res…

by Fiona Terry

Ensuring lighthouses stay “shipshape” isn’t a job for the faint-hearted.

Read more
The former major reuniting service medals with their rightful owners
105015 2019-04-25 00:00:00Z Life in NZ

The former major reuniting service medals with the…

by Fiona Terry

Service medals are being reunited with their rightful owners thanks to former major Ian Martyn and his determined research.

Read more
PM announces 'Christchurch Call' to end use of social media for terrorism
104952 2019-04-24 00:00:00Z Politics

PM announces 'Christchurch Call' to end use of soc…

by Noted

A meeting aims to see world leaders and CEOs of tech companies agree to a pledge called the ‘Christchurch Call’.

Read more
Red Joan: Judi Dench almost saves Soviet spy story from tedium
104942 2019-04-24 00:00:00Z Movies

Red Joan: Judi Dench almost saves Soviet spy story…

by James Robins

The fictionalised account of a British woman who spied for the Soviet Union is stiflingly quaint.

Read more
What to watch on TV this Anzac Day
104749 2019-04-24 00:00:00Z Television

What to watch on TV this Anzac Day

by Fiona Rae

Māori TV once again devotes the day to Anzac programming, including a live broadcast from Gallipoli.

Read more