Fonterra's many masters

by Pattrick Smellie / 08 April, 2016
Co-op’s different interests make life complicated.
CowField
Photo/Thinkstock


John Wilson’s frustration that Fonterra is misunderstood is shared – by the very people his explanations would ideally target: its investors.

The largest interested group is its 10,500-odd dairy farmers, whose pri­mary concern is the price Fonterra pays for its milksolids. The other group is non-farmer investors who can get in on the action with Fonterra through the Fonterra Shareholders’ Fund (FSF), whose units trade on the NZX and give access to dividends based on Fonterra’s earnings, but hold no voting rights.

Farmer shareholders are far less interested in Fonterra’s overall profitability than whether their farms make money.

Private investors in the FSF are more interested in Fonterra’s plans for growth. Those plans require new capital for investment, but farmer shareholders are neither able to provide enough of it, nor willing to let Fonterra take on new equity that would significantly dilute their ownership. Meanwhile, there’s pressure on the co-op to keep farmers afloat.

“The use of scarce capital to support farmers can’t be helpful” for growth plans, noted First NZ Capital after Fonterra announced its results for the six months to December 31, 2015.

This is one of Fonterra’s “elephants in the room”. Another is the misalignment between the interests of its farmer shareholders and its manufacturing and processing operations.

When milk prices are low, farmers struggle, but Fonterra’s processing margins rise because the main input – milk – is comparatively cheap. When the milk price is high, manufacturing is less profitable but farmers do better. In an ideal world, these two would balance out and earnings would be fairly stable.

But life’s not that simple. For a start, milk production is a far larger business than manufacturing, so the two don’t naturally balance. And second, the manufacturing business doesn’t yet match the hype about value-added processing. Most of Fonterra’s production is low-value, commodity goods.

The other big problem is interpreting Fonterra’s financial results. Its ­performance measures are a continuous work in progress, making long-term and sometimes year-to-year comparisons difficult. The business is complex and each of its global operations has a different story. Farming in China is performing poorly, but food service is doing well. The ingredients business here is performing well, but struggling in Australia. Latin America is problematic.

In other words, the problem of interpretation is not all about townies’ ignorance. By design, the Fonterra behemoth is a complex beast.

Read more:

With continuing turmoil in the dairy industry, Fonterra chairman John Wilson says critics of our largest company have got it wrong.

Follow the Listener on Twitter or Facebook.

Latest

Fall into a beautiful abyss at this must-see dance show in Auckland
102571 2019-02-20 12:12:54Z Where to go in Auckland

Fall into a beautiful abyss at this must-see dance…

by Metro

A contemporary dance show that marries dystopian anxiety with raw energy is a must-see at the Auckland Arts Festival.

Read more
Climate change declaration 'politically charged' – Thames-Coromandel mayor
102563 2019-02-20 09:39:08Z Planet

Climate change declaration 'politically charged' –…

by Kate Gudsell

A push to get local authorities to sign up to a declaration on climate change is "politically charged and driven", the Thames-Coromandel mayor says.

Read more
What's inside Metro's March/April 2019 issue?
102558 2019-02-20 09:24:47Z Auckland Issues

What's inside Metro's March/April 2019 issue?

by Metro

Top 50 wines, rappers Church & AP, fast-talking poet Selina Tusitala Marsh and what to see at Auckland Arts Festival.

Read more
China could be using Taiwan as a testing ground for disinformation campaigns
102550 2019-02-20 00:00:00Z World

China could be using Taiwan as a testing ground fo…

by Gavin Ellis

A Taiwanese diplomat’s death in Japan has become a symbol of the consequences and dangers of disinformation.

Read more
The best way to beat food cravings? Fill up on the objects of your desire
102087 2019-02-20 00:00:00Z Nutrition

The best way to beat food cravings? Fill up on the…

by Jennifer Bowden

Research has shown that dieters’ attempts to resist eating certain foods appear to lead to cravings for those foods.

Read more
Deepfake: How disinformation fools our brains and damages democracy
102545 2019-02-20 00:00:00Z Tech

Deepfake: How disinformation fools our brains and…

by Gavin Ellis

Message manipulation using bots, algorithms and, now, AI software is making it harder to know what’s real – and threatening democracy itself.

Read more
Move to introduce digital tax for foreign companies profiting online
102519 2019-02-19 09:23:12Z Economy

Move to introduce digital tax for foreign companie…

by RNZ

New Zealand is lining up to introduce a new tax on multinational companies that make money out of online goods and services in this country.

Read more
National's high-risk gamble on marijuana and euthanasia
102484 2019-02-19 00:00:00Z Politics

National's high-risk gamble on marijuana and eutha…

by Graham Adams

Having polarising MPs like Paula Bennett and Maggie Barry leading the opposition to popular reforms could be kryptonite to the National Party.

Read more