Multinational tax: What we can do about the missing billions

by Pattrick Smellie / 01 April, 2016
RelatedArticlesModule - Tax avoidance

Photo/Getty Images

It’s easy to stoke outrage at multinationals’ low taxes but harder to do something about it.

According to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) – the so-called rich-countries club – tax avoidance by multinational companies is worth US$100-240 billion a year. That’s 4-10% of total global corporate income tax.

In other words, the amount of tax not paid by corporations worldwide roughly equals the size of the New Zealand economy – about US$200 billion.

Renewed interest in this perennial problem was sparked by a New Zealand Herald investigation showing how little income tax multinationals with local operations are paying. On the face of it, foreign companies with New Zealand sales of $10 billion a year paid a mere $1.8 million of income tax. Clearly there is jiggery-pokery going on.

A big part of the problem is the universally shared agreement that though tax should be paid, it should not be paid more than once. The ­resulting web of international treaties to prevent double taxation is unlikely to be unwound, even though it represents one of the foundations on which multinational companies can organise their affairs to try to pay tax nowhere.

When Apple sells a phone in New Zealand, almost every aspect of production occurred somewhere else. Just about the only taxable activity here is GST paid by the consumer. Apple might have a warehouse and salespeople in this country, but those are costs to the business. It would be unsurprising if it didn’t generate a profit.

As tax specialist Robin Oliver puts it, “When I look at some of the ­numbers that come up, I’m surprised at how much [income tax] they pay in New Zealand, because what the hell do they do here?”

Think of the problem the other way around. As this country’s only company of global scale, Fonterra pays most of its income tax here while operating in dozens of countries. What would the effect on the tax base be if Fonterra was levied proportionately to its operations elsewhere? Says Oliver, “Be careful what you wish for.”

Meanwhile, the Government is moving to impose GST on low-value items bought from overseas websites, making it harder for consumers to avoid tax on the consumption of those multinationals’ activities. For the likes of Amazon, concern for its global reputation will make it comply when it could theoretically dodge collecting sales tax for a foreign country, says Rob McLeod, former Oceania chairman of accounting firm EY and a leading tax expert on both sides of the Tasman. Granted, these are still taxes paid by the little guy, collected by the big guy. But McLeod is sceptical of claims that there are easy wins against corporate taxpayers by clamping down on transfer pricing and thin capitalisation – two of the most common forms of cross-border tax avoidance – in the way Australia tried to do last year.

First, New Zealand already has stringent rules in that area. Second, the Australian Taxation Office has backed off some elements of the proposed new regimes. The urge to move aggressively against avoidance can backfire if it stifles investment.

And there’s the rub. The OECD is achieving strong momentum in its Base Erosion and Profit-Shifting project to reduce multinational tax avoidance partly because many governments desperately need tax revenue to fix their budgets ­following the global financial crisis.

At the same time, however, the worst offenders at encouraging tax dodging are often ­governments themselves. “Competition for the tax base is as much a competition between governments as it is between taxpayers and tax authorities,” says McLeod. Look no further than this month’s cut to the British corporate tax rate to 17%, he says.

Companies operating in countries with higher corporate income tax rates will be tempted to shift, if the grass is green enough, says McLeod, although bricks-and-­mortar operations are far harder to relocate than digital businesses such as Google, which exists in the ether and whose tax ­practices excite the most ­opprobrium.


Science must trump ideology in the GE debate
104784 2019-04-18 08:52:29Z Politics

Science must trump ideology in the GE debate

by The Listener

A New Zealand-developed super-grass that appears to drastically reduce greenhouse gas emissions might be blocked in this country by the Green Party.

Read more
Simon Bridges hails PM Jacinda Ardern's capital gains tax u-turn as victory
104803 2019-04-18 00:00:00Z Politics

Simon Bridges hails PM Jacinda Ardern's capital ga…

by Jo Moir

The National Party is calling the u-turn on a capital gains tax a massive failure for the Prime Minister.

Read more
John Campbell is replacing Jack Tame on TVNZ's Breakfast show
104860 2019-04-18 00:00:00Z Television

John Campbell is replacing Jack Tame on TVNZ's Bre…

by Noted

The TV network is switching things up - again.

Read more
John Lanchester’s ecological-dystopian tale about a barricaded Britain
104431 2019-04-18 00:00:00Z Books

John Lanchester’s ecological-dystopian tale about…

by Catherine Woulfe

The Wall may be speculative fiction, but it feel like it's just round the corner.

Read more
Why we should take care when we talk about drug side effects
104426 2019-04-18 00:00:00Z Psychology

Why we should take care when we talk about drug si…

by Marc Wilson

If we find that up to 10% of people report insomnia after taking Panadol, does that mean it was a side effect of the drug?

Read more
Capital Gains Tax debate should have been a godsend for Simon Bridges
104754 2019-04-17 00:00:00Z Politics

Capital Gains Tax debate should have been a godsen…

by Bevan Rapson

Talk of a capital gains tax hits a particular nerve, but changing the tax system doesn’t always have to be like pulling teeth.

Read more
Government abandons capital gains tax plan
104759 2019-04-17 00:00:00Z Politics

Government abandons capital gains tax plan

by Noted

No consensus was reached over the capital gains tax recommendation.

Read more
How tough is it for the middle class in New Zealand?
104675 2019-04-17 00:00:00Z Social issues

How tough is it for the middle class in New Zealan…

by Pattrick Smellie

Money worries have set off a wave of populist politics in most Western democracies, but not here. Pattrick Smellie investigates why.

Read more