Is the Govt's ban on new oil and gas exploration brave or naive?

by The Listener / 19 April, 2018
Photo/Getty Images

Photo/Getty Images

RelatedArticlesModule - Oil and gas exploration ban

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern's move to ban new oil and gas exploration permits is at once justifiable and yet arguably cavalier with a major industry.

Just transition or heart over head? In grabbing back the political agenda after a messy March, the Government has made a string of brave calls, all intended to prove that it will walk the talk on a “transformative” agenda.

Some were well-signalled. For example, shifting transport funding from highway construction in favour of urban public transport, rail and road safety should have come as no surprise. The same goes for the demise of Government backing for large-scale irrigation schemes, part of a wider agenda still being developed that aims to make intensive agriculture pay its way environmentally, as well as in export dollars.

However, the decision to stop issuing offshore oil and gas exploration permits was not pre-election policy. Although Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern was musing privately months ago about the politics of such a move, it is barely a month since she broke from her formal programme to accept a petition from Greenpeace on the forecourt of Parliament.

Always with an eye to powerful imagery, Greenpeace backed the moment with pictures of history-changing Labour leaders of the past: Savage, Kirk, Lange and Clark. Ardern could enter that pantheon with a huge symbolic gesture designed to make real her claim that climate change is “this generation’s nuclear-free moment”.

She has done so, in a move that is at once measured and justifiable yet also naive and arguably cavalier with a major industry. No other country with a significant oil and gas industry has made such a decision.

Signalling today that domestic supplies of natural gas will wind down over the next 30 years is a powerful incentive to industries dependent on gas to adapt or disappear.

The electricity industry has already proven that 10 years is plenty of time to make such a big adjustment. Just a decade ago, Contact and Genesis Energy were planning to import natural gas and talking up fears of a gas shortage.

Instead, rising electricity prices funded a switch to more wind and geothermal power plants and delivered 85% renewable electricity. Power companies have closed some gas-fired power stations and have been notably silent on the Government’s oil and gas decision.

They have moved on. For other major gas users, it is not so simple. Methanex, which exports more than a billion dollars’ worth of natural gas a year as methanol, will probably disappear. Its Think Big-era plants at Motunui and Waitara can be unbolted and moved to another country.

Fonterra, which uses gas for milk processing in the North Island and coal in the south, may use more coal, although in the longer term, the absence of gas will force it to switch to electricity for industrial heat.

However, the naivety of the Government’s new policy is that it will not, of itself, reduce global carbon emissions, but could increase New Zealand’s if it leads to more coal use in the meantime.

To head off that possibility, the soon-to-be-announced Interim Climate Change Committee will need to give the ineffectual emissions trading scheme teeth to drive the carbon price high enough to encourage industry to adopt cleaner fuels – just as electricity has already done.

To its support base, the Government’s oil and gas decisions are an overdue breath of future-focused fresh air. To those working and investing in affected industries, however, it is creating uncertainty over the country’s fourth-largest source of export receipts. That is a big call.

But by leaving in place existing production and exploration rights, there is no immediate Rogernomics-style shock reaction to a crisis. Ardern is making much of differentiating hers as a reforming Labour Government but not a brutal one.

And as recent reports make clear, decarbonising early is less costly than sudden change forced by slow progress on carbon reduction targets.

There are, of course, risks. It is disingenuous to claim that existing permits might sustain a healthy oil and gas sector until the 2040s. The fruitless hunt for major gas fields in the Great South Basin since the 1960s proves the point that exploration is expensive and usually unsuccessful.

But perhaps the biggest risk is the promise of a Government-led “transition” to new industries of the future. Airy ministerial talk of capital being redeployed to new activities is a carbon copy of Rogernomics-era rhetoric. Capital was redeployed, but not necessarily in New Zealand.

The Government is talking a big game on its ability to direct the emergence of such new industries, but its capacity to deliver this upside of transformative change is untested and the value of the industries it is disrupting is all too measurable.

This editorial was first published in the April 28, 2018 issue of the New Zealand Listener.

Latest

Hop to it: The best Kiwi beers for summer
99461 2018-12-14 00:00:00Z Dining

Hop to it: The best Kiwi beers for summer

by Michael Donaldson

Here's what to crack open on a hot day, from our very own Kiwi brewers.

Read more
Te Atatu's new cafe The Sugar Grill celebrates local history and family
100443 2018-12-13 16:46:27Z Auckland Eats

Te Atatu's new cafe The Sugar Grill celebrates loc…

by Jean Teng

Nickson Clark's new cafe The Sugar Grill is a project 19 years in the making.

Read more
Time Magazine’s Person of the Year recognises the global assault on journalism
100431 2018-12-13 11:36:23Z World

Time Magazine’s Person of the Year recognises the …

by Peter Greste

Time Magazine has just announced its “Person of the Year” for 2018, and for once, it isn’t one person.

Read more
The devastating effect of discarded Christmas plastic
100417 2018-12-13 09:31:47Z Planet

The devastating effect of discarded Christmas plas…

by The Listener

Over the European holiday season, the Mediterranean Sea’s plastic load rockets by a whopping 40%, as people buy then simply ditch plastics like lilos.

Read more
The worst humanitarian crisis in the world that no one knows about
100384 2018-12-13 00:00:00Z World

The worst humanitarian crisis in the world that no…

by Todd Pitock

A country rarely in the media spotlight, here's why we can't ignore Chad.

Read more
Trump's stolen slogan and the campaign advisor who did his bidding
100401 2018-12-13 00:00:00Z World

Trump's stolen slogan and the campaign advisor who…

by Emma Land

If you thought Donald Trump came up with the slogan "Make America Great Again," you’d be mistaken.

Read more
Big Little Lies author Liane Moriarty on how life became stranger than fiction
100261 2018-12-13 00:00:00Z Profiles

Big Little Lies author Liane Moriarty on how life …

by Diana Wichtel

When Liane Moriarty was summoned to meet Nicole Kidman in a Sydney cafe, the Hollywood star made it clear she was serious about optioning the book.

Read more
Dear Oliver: A son's poignant tribute to his mother
93895 2018-12-13 00:00:00Z Books

Dear Oliver: A son's poignant tribute to his mothe…

by Peter Wells

A reminder that nothing can really prepare us for the death of a beloved parent.

Read more