Mycoplasma bovis is here. It’s what comes next that’s important

by The Listener / 17 May, 2018
RelatedArticlesModule - Mycoplasma bovis New Zealand

At a time when the link between town and country is weak, our reaction to cow disease Mycoplasma bovis will be a revealing test of national solidarity.

It almost seems like the stuff of science fiction: a debilitating epidemic spreads unseen and stays several steps ahead of efforts to contain it. But the cow disease Mycoplasma bovis is not part of a far-fetched plot in a Hollywood film. For the rural sector, it has become a real-life horror story. Agriculture minister Damien O’Connor bluntly describes it as a disaster.

It’s a crisis with heartbreaking personal consequences as well as serious economic dimensions. Good farmers care deeply for their livestock, and few people would not have been moved by the sight of a Canterbury farmer almost in tears as he talked of his infected herd, painstakingly built up over decades of careful breeding, having to be slaughtered. This was the human face of an industry often pilloried for greed and environmental vandalism.

New Zealanders heard of the disease for the first time when it was identified on a South Canterbury farm in the middle of last year. M bovis poses no food-safety risk, but it’s serious enough to require the culling of infected stock. Symptoms include lameness, arthritis, mastitis, abortions, and pneumonia in calves.

How the disease got here isn’t known, but European farmers have lived with it for many years and, until last year, New Zealand was the world’s only major dairying nation to have escaped it.

At first, the Ministry for Primary Industries seemed confident the disease could be quarantined and eradicated. But as reports of infected herds multiplied, that hope looked more and more forlorn. Now, the disease has been confirmed as present in the dairying heartland, Waikato, and the crisis assumes new urgency with the approach of June 1 – “Gypsy Day”, when sharemilkers move their herds to new farms. That raises the possibility that the infection, which for the most part remains invisible, will unknowingly be spread even more widely.

Briefing MPs on the crisis, BioSecurity New Zealand chief Roger Smith theatrically announced that M bovis could be wiped out, but only by slaughtering six million cows and closing down the dairy industry – after tourism, New Zealand’s biggest source of export income. That was as good as saying that officials had given up on the idea of eradication and the emphasis must now shift to containment.

It’s not an outcome that any New Zealand farmer wants, but the outlook isn’t totally dismal. European farmers have learnt how to manage the disease, and there’s no reason why their New Zealand counterparts can’t do the same.

The agriculture sector can look to its own successful record of combating bovine tuberculosis, which affected 1700 cattle and deer herds in the 1990s but is now at an all-time low. Farmers can also take some encouragement from what happened in the kiwifruit industry: threatened with devastation by the vine disease Psa, it mounted a co-ordinated response and has bounced back spectacularly. Similarly, beekeepers have accepted that they can’t eradicate the parasitic varroa mite, once seen as potentially ruinous, but have found ways to keep infestations to manageable levels.

In the meantime, though, the dairy industry is hurting. Angry and anxious farmers have turned on the ministry. Some have accused it of overreacting; others say it was too complacent. A recurring criticism is that potentially affected farmers were given insufficient information about the risk they faced. Every crisis brings its lessons and the MPI has faced an unusually sharp learning curve.

What is, perhaps, more surprising is that farmer has turned against farmer, some claiming to have been kept in the dark by neighbours whose herds were infected. It seems clear, too, that some farmers have traded livestock on the black market, hampering efforts to trace infected animals. But it’s not a straightforward case of an irresponsible minority putting at risk the well-being of an entire industry; an estimated 70% of otherwise law-abiding farmers have been too casual about fulfilling their obligations under the National Animal Identification and Tracing (Nait) scheme. They must therefore accept some responsibility for the difficulties faced by authorities trying to track infected animals. That is another hard lesson.

To use an overworked phrase, farmers and the ministry have been given a very unpleasant wake-up call. How the Government and the country respond to this crisis, particularly at a time when traditional links between town and country are so much weaker than they were in the past, will be a revealing test of our national solidarity.

Video: TVNZ

This editorial was first published in the May 26, 2018 issue of the New Zealand Listener.

Latest

Ditch the intergenerational housing blame game, and focus on some home truths
99836 2018-12-10 00:00:00Z Social issues

Ditch the intergenerational housing blame game, an…

by Virginia Larson

What we don’t need is sloppy statistics kindling an intergenerational stoush that does no one any good.

Read more
Sally Lewis: The modern-day monk teaching meditation to prisoners
100143 2018-12-10 00:00:00Z Profiles

Sally Lewis: The modern-day monk teaching meditati…

by Clare de Lore

Could an ancient form of meditation change the lives of prisoners for better? Sally Lewis says it can.

Read more
What's inside North & South's January 2019 issue?
99815 2018-12-10 00:00:00Z Life in NZ

What's inside North & South's January 2019 issue?

by North & South

We look at the riskiest places in NZ to live, what it'll take to fix the Family Court and review 2018's weirdest and wackiest things.

Read more
The Brexit deal is the perfect Prisoner's Dilemma
100059 2018-12-09 00:00:00Z World

The Brexit deal is the perfect Prisoner's Dilemma

by Andrew Anthony

In the Prisoner's Dilemma, going after what you want – freedom – might get you the very worst outcome. It's Brexit, in other words.

Read more
How Britain's MI6 gave the world modern spycraft
100061 2018-12-09 00:00:00Z Television

How Britain's MI6 gave the world modern spycraft

by Fiona Rae

Espionage nerd David Jason takes us inside the world of secret agents, including the inaugural MI6 boss’ car.

Read more
Louis Theroux grapples with his own failure in new Jimmy Savile doco
100072 2018-12-09 00:00:00Z Television

Louis Theroux grapples with his own failure in new…

by Diana Wichtel

A chastened Louis Theroux tries to shed light on a celebrity sex fiend's brazen cunning in a new documentary.

Read more
The extraordinary story of how New Zealand entered the space race
100028 2018-12-09 00:00:00Z Business

The extraordinary story of how New Zealand entered…

by Sally Blundell

Half a century after the first manned spacecraft orbited the moon, the space race is back on and New Zealand is in the game. But are we ready?

Read more
Quiet, please! The commodification of silence
97964 2018-12-09 00:00:00Z Travel

Quiet, please! The commodification of silence

by Margo White

The commodification of quiet – how silence became a top trend in wellness tourism.

Read more